Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Belt or chain (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1119644-belt-chain.html)

fujiraf 08-24-17 03:30 AM

Belt or chain?
 
Hi, what would u prefer on an urban bike with auto gears. Belt or chain drive? Any idea what is better?
Thanks

ammarolli 08-24-17 04:35 AM

I would go with belt drive frame because you don't have to oil the belt like a chain so no more squeaky squeaky rusty chains especially if you ride a lot in rain and salt.
Belt drive last much longer than a regular chain that needs to regularly replaced anyway.

You also don't get grease on your clothes so that's also nice.

You might break a chain but I don't think you would with belt it's just much harder.

HillRider 08-24-17 06:38 AM


Originally Posted by fujiraf (Post 19814255)
Hi, what would u prefer on an urban bike with auto gears. Belt or chain drive? Any idea what is better?

What do you mean by "auto gears"? If you are asking about an IGH (internal gear hub) then either chain or belt is suitable. As ammarolli noted, a belt is cleaner and more weather proof. However, it is more expensive and requires a specifically made frame to install while a chain can be used on any frame.

Breaking a chain should not be a concern unless it's improperly installed and/or badly neglected in service.

hokiefyd 08-24-17 06:52 AM

All else being equal, I would prefer a belt. As HillRider said, the frame must be set up for a belt, and if you're comparing two different bikes, one belt and one chain, then there might be other factors to consider before deciding on belt vs. chain. If you're looking at a bike that is offered in both types, and everything else is the same in terms of components and geometry, then I'd choose the belt.

fietsbob 08-24-17 07:27 AM

But, Not hardly equal, realize you can replace the chain many times for the cost of the belt drivetrain parts , costing $400+

And you must buy a special bike frame, because the loop of the belt cannot open, so the frame must break open & re close..

fujiraf 08-24-17 08:25 AM


Originally Posted by HillRider (Post 19814412)
What do you mean by "auto gears"? If you are asking about an IGH (internal gear hub) then either chain or belt is suitable. As ammarolli noted, a belt is cleaner and more weather proof. However, it is more expensive and requires a specifically made frame to install while a chain can be used on any frame.

Breaking a chain should not be a concern unless it's improperly installed and/or badly neglected in service.

Yes,that I mean internal gear hub. I want to buy an urban bike and there are2 options. 1 with belt ,& 1 with chain. I don't know what is the best.
Thanks any way for the reply. I think I ll go for the one with the belt. Cleaner.

mulveyr 08-24-17 09:27 AM


Originally Posted by fujiraf (Post 19814643)
Yes,that I mean internal gear hub. I want to buy an urban bike and there are2 options. 1 with belt ,& 1 with chain. I don't know what is the best.
Thanks any way for the reply. I think I ll go for the one with the belt. Cleaner.

A belt drive/IGH bike is ideal for a commuter/urban bike where you need reliability, cleanliness, and for it to "just work" with a minimum of maintenance. So, good choice. :-)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:32 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.