Originally Posted by maddog34 (Post 20063868)

aw heck... i just wanted to find out what bike the noisy hub was on, but didn't want to get into a lengthy discussion on whether "brand names" matter... they do, when you then go look that bike up and respond accordingly with the new info...
Formula hubs, might not even have a brand on them since specialized usually orders them blank... low grade steel cones that get rough after any rust occurs... IF the hubs have "Specialized" printed on them, they tend to be a somewhat higher grade hub... let's hope that's the case, eh?

still ain't heard if Hobo tested the wheel off-bike yet.

feel free to read BS into my responses, it makes great entertainment! ...

pass the popcorn..... no, the plain stuff, that fake butter makes me ill....similar to plastic in molecular form.... ;-)

if someone is offended by mention of their gender, they probably shouldn't mention their gender......

Originally Posted by Kontact (Post 20063734)

But that isn't what happened here. In this thread, Maddog dragged something from outside the thread that didn't relate to the OP into the thread to lecture the OP about something that wasn't an issue.

Did the OP refuse to divulge bike information prior to be lectured? Nope.


Is the opinion that women are less likely to engage in debates about bicycle brand "sexist"? Hardly. Sounds pretty damn accurate to me, nor is the observation insulting to men.

As a male, you don't need to make sure that everyone is held equally accountable. Men are held less accountable, so you have nothing to make up for by not giving women a "pass".

Get off your horse.

Originally Posted by woodcraft (Post 20063918)

Not sure where you get the "ridiculous brand war behavior often seen on these boards", nor why you think that

women are less concerned with brands than men,

but agree generally about male privilege.

Originally Posted by Kontact (Post 20063892)

You either misunderstood or purposely misconstrued the OP's profile quote. At no point did she refuse to provide useful information, and you were off base in lecturing her instead of just requesting the information necessary, first.

Originally Posted by Kontact (Post 20063926)

Women, in general, are much less concerned about bicycle brands than many men, in general, are.

I base that one working in the bike industry since the late '80s and participating in boards like these for over a decade.

Women may engage in such behavior with other types of goods, but none of the women I have ever met online or in the shop are interested in declaring "SRAM sucks" or playing the "Does Trek make good bikes?" game.

To their credit.

Originally Posted by woodcraft (Post 20064064)

Well, I did just try to take apart a Bontrager hub, & thought 'this thing sucks'....

Originally Posted by Kontact (Post 20064138)

And I have some beautiful Bontrager rims that have been taking a pounding for 18 years. Maybe "brand" has little to do with most mechanical issues?

Originally Posted by maddog34 (Post 20064212)

here's a news flash for both of you... BONTRAGER is owned by Trek, and they outsource their hubs, last i heard.