![]() |
Originally Posted by CrimsonEclipse
(Post 23145547)
Final note: If anyone uses BMX cranksets use caution The chainline is usually around 43-45mm and not really suitable with most ROAD and MTB frames. If my memory serves, I think my 50/34 hollowtech II style, 5 x 110 mm BCD, I think is 43.5 chainline and works perfect on my folder with generally road dimensions. HOWEVER, I have a 7 speed cassette on 130mm OLD. With more modern cassettes and 135mm, things may be a whole lot different. |
Originally Posted by Duragrouch
(Post 23145575)
In which direction, too low, or too high?
If my memory serves, I think my 50/34 hollowtech II style, 5 x 110 mm BCD, I think is 43.5 chainline and works perfect on my folder with generally road dimensions. HOWEVER, I have a 7 speed cassette on 130mm OLD. With more modern cassettes and 135mm, things may be a whole lot different. For those who say I’m risking damage, I more than one bike with this arrangement that have close to a combined 20,000 miles on them without issues. |
Originally Posted by Duragrouch
(Post 23145575)
In which direction, too low, or too high?
If my memory serves, I think my 50/34 hollowtech II style, 5 x 110 mm BCD, I think is 43.5 chainline and works perfect on my folder with generally road dimensions. HOWEVER, I have a 7 speed cassette on 130mm OLD. With more modern cassettes and 135mm, things may be a whole lot different. So the outer surface is not flattened for the outer chainring. So that's not an option to buy yourself 5mm So while a BMX crankset will work for a folder, which generally have BMX chainlines, it would be a stretch for a road bike and, although do-able, not ideal for an MTB |
Originally Posted by cyccommute
(Post 23145766)
And never mind that the chain line is adjustable. With internal bearing bottom brackets, a shorter spindle can be used. With external bearing cranks, spacers can be moved around to change the chain line. I have a number or road bikes with mountain bike cranks that I’ve had to adjust the chainline so that the crank will work with a road derailer. In some cases, all of the spacers on the crank have to be put on the left side so that the derailer has enough reach.
For those who say I’m risking damage, I more than one bike with this arrangement that have close to a combined 20,000 miles on them without issues. I would not have had a clamp problem with a crank designed to accommodate 170mm BB shell, in my 168mm shell, but the chainline would have still caused shifting problems. Even a few mm's was enough to make things off. |
Originally Posted by Duragrouch
(Post 23145573)
Thanks for the info. I like that direction; For a press-fit into an aluminum bottom bracket, what happens if the press loosens over time, or is damaged somehow?
|
Originally Posted by grumpus
(Post 23146609)
Loctite 660 retaining compound fills gaps in worn bearing seats, or go full redneck with JB Weld.
|
Originally Posted by Duragrouch
(Post 23147125)
Good to know! I would hope that the 660, like Locktite's thread adhesives, has a reasonably low temp that it softens under heat, to ease disassembly.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:25 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.