Chain dropping now
#1
Chain dropping now
Peugeot Competition from the late 1990s with horizontal dropouts. 2006 Campy Chorus. I finally got around to removing the wheels, rings, cogs and derailleurs to give them a good cleaning, and now the chain drops off the small ring when I gear down to the last three cogs. You can see out of line the cogs and the rings are.
Thing is, the rear wheel is positioned perfectly in the middle, and the axle is hard against the back of the dropouts on both sides. I'm fairly certain that I hadn't previously rotated the wheel to line the rear cogs up with the front rings, as I've never had chain-dropping before and thus wouldn't have even thought to check for in-lineness. Could the seatstay-chainstay be out of whack? I'm a bigger guy, and I carry groceries in the saddlebags sometimes.
Or what?

Thing is, the rear wheel is positioned perfectly in the middle, and the axle is hard against the back of the dropouts on both sides. I'm fairly certain that I hadn't previously rotated the wheel to line the rear cogs up with the front rings, as I've never had chain-dropping before and thus wouldn't have even thought to check for in-lineness. Could the seatstay-chainstay be out of whack? I'm a bigger guy, and I carry groceries in the saddlebags sometimes.
Or what?

#3
#4
Crikey, you know what I did? I lost the spacer (FC-RE105) when taking the rings off, and, like an idiot, remounted them without a spacer. I was wondering about it at the time, but, again, like an idiot, thought maybe this particular one didn't have a spacer for some reason.
So I tightened the bolt going into the crank arm all the way, and did indeed put the small ring out of true, though in the opposite direction of your speculation. That would explain the chain-dropping, which stopped when I loosened that particular bolt to make the ring true again. Boy, I feel like a numpty, but in my defence, I fell out of cycling over the past couple of years and haven't done any wrenching for a long while. I hope to commit many more silly errors as I ramp up my cycling again (spoiler alert: I got a CPAP machine and it's changed my life!).

So I tightened the bolt going into the crank arm all the way, and did indeed put the small ring out of true, though in the opposite direction of your speculation. That would explain the chain-dropping, which stopped when I loosened that particular bolt to make the ring true again. Boy, I feel like a numpty, but in my defence, I fell out of cycling over the past couple of years and haven't done any wrenching for a long while. I hope to commit many more silly errors as I ramp up my cycling again (spoiler alert: I got a CPAP machine and it's changed my life!).

#5
Really Old Senior Member


Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 14,610
Likes: 1,861
From: Mid Willamette Valley, Orygun
Bikes: 87 RockHopper,2008 Specialized Globe. Both upgraded to 9 speeds. 2019 Giant Explore E+3
Not knowing if you had a cup & cone BB, I was going to guess a flipped spindle.
I'm beyond ignorant when it comes to Campy.
I'm beyond ignorant when it comes to Campy.
#8
It's a hidden bolt crank. Four of the mounting points are spider arms, the fifth is to the back of the crank arm with a spacer between the rings (and sometimes another spacer between the large ring and arm).









