Granny gear option
#1
Thread Starter
Drop Master
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 221
Likes: 0
From: Orlando FL
Bikes: Fuji Roubaix / Scott CR-1
Granny gear option
I have a triple crank 50/39/30 with a Shimano 12-27 cassette. As I looked at the gear ratio chart at sheldons web site, I like the range of gear ratios I get if my 30T was a 36T instead. Example, if i was in
my 39/17T and I change to the 36T chainring it has the same ratio as 39/19T or pretty close to it.
***39T**36T
12 ---6.4 ---5.9
13 ---5.9 ---5.4
14 ---5.5 ---5.0
15 ---5.1 ---4.7
16 ---4.8 ---4.4
17 ---4.5 ---4.1
19 ---4.0 ---3.7
21 ---3.6 ---3.4
24 ---3.2 ---2.9
27 ---2.8 ---2.6
The 19T and 21T and sometimes the 24T is what I use for hills. I have at times
used the 27T but pride keeps me from it.
So is it possible to have a 36T chainring as a granny? The guy at performance says it can only be used as a middle chainring gear. I would have to do a lot more shifting to get to the gear I need when I approach the hills by using the 30T. Jumping on the 36T say a half mile or so away getting into the correct gear when I'm at the base of a hill is just a matter of downshifting into my 15T or 16T clog. When I hit the top all I need to do is go back into my 39T and I'm rolling hard again.I hope you guys understand my objective with this.
my 39/17T and I change to the 36T chainring it has the same ratio as 39/19T or pretty close to it.
***39T**36T
12 ---6.4 ---5.9
13 ---5.9 ---5.4
14 ---5.5 ---5.0
15 ---5.1 ---4.7
16 ---4.8 ---4.4
17 ---4.5 ---4.1
19 ---4.0 ---3.7
21 ---3.6 ---3.4
24 ---3.2 ---2.9
27 ---2.8 ---2.6
The 19T and 21T and sometimes the 24T is what I use for hills. I have at times
used the 27T but pride keeps me from it.
So is it possible to have a 36T chainring as a granny? The guy at performance says it can only be used as a middle chainring gear. I would have to do a lot more shifting to get to the gear I need when I approach the hills by using the 30T. Jumping on the 36T say a half mile or so away getting into the correct gear when I'm at the base of a hill is just a matter of downshifting into my 15T or 16T clog. When I hit the top all I need to do is go back into my 39T and I'm rolling hard again.I hope you guys understand my objective with this.
Last edited by slyjackson; 08-29-07 at 01:41 PM.
#2
The smaller BCD on your triple crank is probably 74mm, you can go as large as a 36t with a 74 BCD, and as small as 24t. Sheldon's got 36t TA rings in 74 BCD: https://sheldonbrown.com/harris/chainrings/74.html#36
#3
Really Old Senior Member


Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 14,610
Likes: 1,861
From: Mid Willamette Valley, Orygun
Bikes: 87 RockHopper,2008 Specialized Globe. Both upgraded to 9 speeds. 2019 Giant Explore E+3
You would end up with-
50-36-30
Those tooth increments are-
14 & 6
Triples work much better when the tooth counts are in more "even" increments. like your current 11 & 9 tooth increments.
You can probably get it to "work", but expect shift quality to be worse.
50-36-30
Those tooth increments are-
14 & 6
Triples work much better when the tooth counts are in more "even" increments. like your current 11 & 9 tooth increments.
You can probably get it to "work", but expect shift quality to be worse.






