Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Generic Torque Guide? (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/833892-generic-torque-guide.html)

smurray 07-21-12 06:59 AM

Generic Torque Guide?
 
Does anyone know of a place to find a general torque guide for bike components? Some of my components specify torque, such as my stem and headset. Other parts I can't find torque ratings for, such as the integrated seatpost clamp for my Leader 722TS, seatpost rail clamps, and axle nuts. I know it's not super important to have every single thing torqued exactly to spec, but I've got the wrench do I might as well do it right during assembly.

VELOGLOCK 07-21-12 07:23 AM

The Park tool manual has some general specs , try their website , Zinn may also

davidad 07-21-12 07:31 AM

http://draco.nac.uci.edu/rbfaq/FAQ/8a.7.html

FBinNY 07-21-12 09:49 AM

Using generic torque specs is worse than not using a torque wrench at all. There aren't and cannot be generic torque specs that are at all meaningful. A proper torque spec. has to be based on a specific engineering goal, such as clamping strength, and based on the diameter and pitch of the fastener used.

One of the worst places to apply a generic torque spec is on bearing adjustments such as headsets. While the screw is fairly standard (M6x1), the proper preload pressure of the bearings varies tremendously depending on the type and angle of contact. The same load that may be inadequate for one type of headset will overload and rapidly destroy another.

Rather than blindly applying what may be inappropriate specs., learn what fasteners feel like, and use the minimum torque that's sufficient to meet the goal, ie. keeping a seatpost tight enough not to slip or twist.

Ira B 07-21-12 09:58 AM


Originally Posted by fbinny (Post 14510313)
using generic torque specs is worse than not using a torque wrench at all. There aren't and cannot be generic torque specs that are at all meaningful. A proper torque spec, has to be based on a specific engineering goal, such as clamping strength, and based on the diameter and pitch of the fastener used.

One of the worst places to apply a generic torque spec is on bearing adjustments such as headsets. While the screw is fairly standard (m6x1), the proper preload pressure of the bearings varies tremendously depending on the type and angle of contact. The same load that may be inadequate for one type of headset will overload and rapidly destroy another.

Rather than blindly applying what may be inappropriate specs., learn what fasteners feel like, and use the minimum torque that's sufficient to meet the goal, ie. Keeping a seatpost tight enough not to slip or twist.



this

smurray 07-21-12 10:43 AM

Generic Torque Guide?
 
I'll ask a different question then. Does anyone know what the torque spec is on the seatpost clamp on a Leader 722TS frame?

davidad 07-21-12 11:40 AM


Originally Posted by FBinNY (Post 14510313)
Using generic torque specs is worse than not using a torque wrench at all. There aren't and cannot be generic torque specs that are at all meaningful. A proper torque spec. has to be based on a specific engineering goal, such as clamping strength, and based on the diameter and pitch of the fastener used.

One of the worst places to apply a generic torque spec is on bearing adjustments such as headsets. While the screw is fairly standard (M6x1), the proper preload pressure of the bearings varies tremendously depending on the type and angle of contact. The same load that may be inadequate for one type of headset will overload and rapidly destroy another.

Rather than blindly applying what may be inappropriate specs., learn what fasteners feel like, and use the minimum torque that's sufficient to meet the goal, ie. keeping a seatpost tight enough not to slip or twist.

I doubt that people in our thing would use a torque wrench to adjust the preload in bearings except for the outboard BB bearings, and that load is very low so finger tight is enough.

SEAtrain 07-21-12 12:46 PM


Originally Posted by smurray (Post 14510448)
I'll ask a different question then. Does anyone know what the torque spec is on the seatpost clamp on a Leader 722TS frame?

I've never been able to locate torque specs for seatpost clamps. It needs to be tight enough to prevent the saddle from slipping & turning. If you have a carbon post, THAT is the big concern. You don't want to over tighten and damage the post. I spray carbo grip on my carbon post and tighten to 5Nm. Seems to work for me.

gforeman 07-21-12 02:12 PM

My Specialized Crux is not carbon, nor is the seat post. I was given 55 in. lbs. from Specialized as the spec.

Al1943 07-21-12 02:55 PM

From my experience if you are clamping a carbon fiber tube don't use the torque spec for the clamp. You really need to know what the cf tube can safely take. Don't ask me how I know this.

ultraman6970 07-21-12 06:53 PM

I do all of that by feeling, common sense and carbon assembly paste. With that the torque needed is reduced a lot, in some parts even like 30% less torque is needed. So why you might need a torque guide, even i been noticing that it depends on the manufacturer and their tolerances the torque you have to put in some parts, between you and me i dont believe them too much because if the torque wrench is not calibrated then the danger of overtorquing something is pretty big. And believe me i have seen it with one of my friends, he called me panicking because he messed up one of his carbon stems, his trustly torque wrench was bad, a bolt went bye bye.

Well good luck :) just my experience :D over 30 years working in my own stuff, i dont know it all but so far never snapped a bolt or messed up any of my carbon bikes and parts because i went HULK in the tools, I'm just carefull :D

ultraman6970 07-21-12 06:56 PM

That the clamp can take x torque, doesnt mean the seatpost can take the same torque w/o being smashed :D Sadly a lot of parts have to work together and then the problems starts, that a stem clamp takes whatever torque doesnt mean the handlebar has to do it aswell :D Carbon paste (highly recommended) and tight by feeling, turn little by little until the parts doesn't move and dont abuse if the bolt actually can turn 3/4 turns more if you go hulk to it.


Originally Posted by Al1943 (Post 14511047)
From my experience if you are clamping a carbon fiber tube don't use the torque spec for the clamp. You really need to know what the cf tube can safely take. Don't ask me how I know this.



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:20 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.