Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Front thumb shifter problem (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/953791-front-thumb-shifter-problem.html)

nicechuck 06-14-14 04:51 PM

Front thumb shifter problem
 
My roadbike has Shimano 2200 shifters. The crank thumb shifter is really hard to shift, any suggestions?

fietsbob 06-14-14 05:10 PM

Take it to a Bike shop , since you asked such a open question ...

FBinNY 06-14-14 05:43 PM

It's hard to know since you offer few details, but usually this is friction.

Could be with in the FD itself -- test by shifting by pushing down on the arm .to see if it moves easily or not

Or, friction where the wire passes below the bottom bracket, (or down from top tube on top pull), test by shifting by pulling the bare wire away from the down tube like a bow string (compare the the RD wire using the same method)

Or if not there, it could be in the handlebar/frame housing.

Also, know that often levers get harder to shift, both front and rear, when the cable is beginning to fray in the lever before breaking. If you can't identify a source of friction, you might need a new cable (replace housing at the same time).

AnkleWork 06-14-14 06:16 PM


Originally Posted by FBinNY (Post 16851496)
It's hard to know since you offer few details, but usually this is friction.

Could be with in the FD itself -- test by shifting by pushing down on the arm .to see if it moves easily or not

Or, friction where the wire passes below the bottom bracket, (or down from top tube on top pull), test by shifting by pulling the bare wire away from the down tube like a bow string (compare the the RD wire using the same method)

Or if not there, it could be in the handlebar/frame housing.

Also, know that often levers get harder to shift, both front and rear, when the cable is beginning to fray in the lever before breaking. If you can't identify a source of friction, you might need a new cable (replace housing at the same time).

(And you ask about OCD.)
It appears th OP has a problem with the thumb button on 2200 shifters, which is the release. Yes, they are frequently stiff. Most likely stiffness in the shifter mechanism itself (it may break-in) or possibly the high limit is set too "low" thus binding when in the big ring.

FBinNY 06-14-14 06:27 PM


Originally Posted by AnkleWork (Post 16851570)
(And you ask about OCD.)
It appears th OP has a problem with the thumb button on 2200 shifters, which is the release. Yes, they are frequently stiff. Most likely stiffness in the shifter mechanism itself (it may break-in) or possibly the high limit is set too "low" thus binding when in the big ring.

I don't know what this has to do with OCD. I answer people's questions as best I can, but since you know everything you're free not to read my explanations if you find them too long.

If you have a better answer, feel free to post.

AnkleWork 06-14-14 06:29 PM


Originally Posted by FBinNY (Post 16851599)
I don't know what this has to do with OCD. . .

See your thread.

FBinNY 06-14-14 06:34 PM


Originally Posted by AnkleWork (Post 16851604)
See your thread.

Yes, it was a thread I started as a tongue in cheek fun thread, and most people posted in that spirit. Apparently you saw it as an opportunity to be an ankle biter, which I gather reflects on your personality more than my OCD problem.

I gave you the courtesy of ignoring your snide post there, but apparently your personality defects are too pronounced to leave bad enough alone.

However, feel free to keep it up, because I give this kind of nonsense the attention it deserves - zero. I truly could not care less what you think.

AnkleWork 06-14-14 06:40 PM


Originally Posted by FBinNY (Post 16851611)
. . . your snide post . . .

Thin-skinned much? You are responsible for what you read into my posts. And on the subject of reading, you might consider reading as much as you write, like the questions, and other answers to start -- just a friendly suggestion.

catonec 06-14-14 06:42 PM

pretty vague question but ill do what I can.

start by disconnecting your cable from your front deraileur. hold onto the cable end and apply slight pressure. try shifting. does it feel the same or different. if its the same your problem is either in the cable/housing, or shifter.

If it feels easier then your issue is with the setup of your front deraileur.

shifter/cable issue.
1. verify your housings are all seated properly in the braze ons.
2. no kinks or bends in the cable? pull the cable out and look for broken strands which may be catching.
3. alot of dirt inside housing will cause an issue.
4. you can spray wd40 inside your shifter to clean it out if it feels gummed up
5. replace cable and housing. be sure to use metal housing endcaps everywhere you can

Deraileur issue
1. with front deraileur disconnected see if you can push and hold the cage outward as you turn the cranks. does the chain move from one ring to the next. if not you need to adjust the limit screws
2. inspect the deraileur cage and spring, no damage? is it mounted to the frame in the optimal position??

check all these things. if its still problematic repost with all that info, or then bring to a shop.
gluck.

FBinNY 06-14-14 07:07 PM


Originally Posted by AnkleWork (Post 16851623)
Thin-skinned much? You are responsible for what you read into my posts. And on the subject of reading, you might consider reading as much as you write, like the questions, and other answers to start -- just a friendly suggestion.

No, not thin skinned, certainly not about anything you might say. In order for anybody to get under my skin, I'd have to respect them first, and you don't make the cut.

But if my long winded posts bother you as much as they seem to, I don't understand why you read them.

nicechuck 06-14-14 09:35 PM

Wow, you all are fast! Thank you for the help. Everything works fine except that, it changes with no problem except takes more pressure than it should. I notice that if I press it forward and down, it takes less pressure, which maybe means it's in the shifter. I will spray it with WD 40.
Thanks again everyone


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:31 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.