Vintage frame identification
#1
Vintage frame identification
Hello, I have this frame and judging by the lugs, it's a Claud Butler but I can't find the model since the fork has a huge rake and the seatstay end has an odd shape. The frame was modified by a previous owner to be a fixie so the cable guides are missing. I think there was a cable pass over the bottom bracket (swiss threaded) and it could've had a derailleur hanger. I used this frame as a fixie for half a year.
The fork threads are english and the rear wheel spacing is for 5 cogs cassette. I think it was for 650 wheels since it requires long reach calipers for 622 wheels.








The fork threads are english and the rear wheel spacing is for 5 cogs cassette. I think it was for 650 wheels since it requires long reach calipers for 622 wheels.








#2
-----
If CB it is certainly late enough to be from the Holdsworthy period.
Lugset appears to be Prugnat 62/S, crown Vagner PC.
Shell appears to be Gargatte (Raccords Gargatte Freres).
You mention the BB swiss threaded. This would be more consistent with a cycle from France or Switzerland. Seat stay treatment consistent with a French product. One easy check would be to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes to see if they are BSC or metric. You mention steerer BSC. If frame tubes metric diameter it would tell us fork a replacement. Holdsworthy did employ a lot of Prugnat lugs however.
Have you been able to find any serial markings?
-----
If CB it is certainly late enough to be from the Holdsworthy period.
Lugset appears to be Prugnat 62/S, crown Vagner PC.
Shell appears to be Gargatte (Raccords Gargatte Freres).
You mention the BB swiss threaded. This would be more consistent with a cycle from France or Switzerland. Seat stay treatment consistent with a French product. One easy check would be to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes to see if they are BSC or metric. You mention steerer BSC. If frame tubes metric diameter it would tell us fork a replacement. Holdsworthy did employ a lot of Prugnat lugs however.
Have you been able to find any serial markings?
-----
Last edited by juvela; 08-18-18 at 11:14 AM. Reason: addition
#3
The BB shell has no serial marking. The worst is that I got the frame with no decals on it so I can't even know for sure if it's a Claud Butler. The current paintjob was done by a friend because the frame really needed one when I received it.
#5
multimodal commuter
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 19,810
Likes: 597
From: NJ, NYC, LI
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
#8
-----
As rhm so articulately states a CH shell and a UK origin and mutally incompatible.
If it really is CH then country of origin could only be FR or CH.
If it were CB it could not be CH threaded.
When will you be able to measure tube diameters?
-----
As rhm so articulately states a CH shell and a UK origin and mutally incompatible.
If it really is CH then country of origin could only be FR or CH.
If it were CB it could not be CH threaded.
When will you be able to measure tube diameters?
-----
#11
#12
-----
yes, the "1" fork" is the part which does not fit in.
with a CH shell and a metric tubeset we would expect a steerer diameter of 25.0mm.
so there are two possibilites:
a) the measurement is incorrect, possibly due to a miscommunication
[suspect we are not communicating well. another name for the steerer sometimes used is "fork tube." since you were able to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes you could use the same tool to measure the diameter of the steerer/fork tube. we would expect it to measure 25.0mm. if there is presently a headset in place all that is needed is to remove the headset locknut in order to make a measurement. do you have a seatpost for the bicycle? what is its diameter? this dimension will give a clue as to the tubing employed to construct the frame. if you do not have a seatpost for the bicycle you could use your measurement tool to make a measurement of the seat tube opening.]
or
b) the fork is a replacement
---
for a manufacturer identification we need to hear from luminaries on frankish matters such as [MENTION=43980]CV-6[/MENTION] & [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION]...or else [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION] who seems positively unstumpable.
-----
yes, the "1" fork" is the part which does not fit in.
with a CH shell and a metric tubeset we would expect a steerer diameter of 25.0mm.
so there are two possibilites:
a) the measurement is incorrect, possibly due to a miscommunication
[suspect we are not communicating well. another name for the steerer sometimes used is "fork tube." since you were able to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes you could use the same tool to measure the diameter of the steerer/fork tube. we would expect it to measure 25.0mm. if there is presently a headset in place all that is needed is to remove the headset locknut in order to make a measurement. do you have a seatpost for the bicycle? what is its diameter? this dimension will give a clue as to the tubing employed to construct the frame. if you do not have a seatpost for the bicycle you could use your measurement tool to make a measurement of the seat tube opening.]
or
b) the fork is a replacement
---
for a manufacturer identification we need to hear from luminaries on frankish matters such as [MENTION=43980]CV-6[/MENTION] & [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION]...or else [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION] who seems positively unstumpable.

-----
Last edited by juvela; 08-19-18 at 07:05 PM. Reason: addition
#13
If I own it, I ride it


Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 5,685
Likes: 820
From: Cardinal Country
Bikes: Lejeune(14), Raleigh, Raysport, Jan De Reus, Gazelle, Masi, B. Carré(4), Springfield, Greg Lemond, Andre Bertin, Schwinn Paramount
I am confused by this statement. Did you mean the seat stay caps, the top of the stay by the seat tube and top tube junction? Because domed ends on a chain stay are common.
#14
-----
yes, the "1" fork" is the part which does not fit in.
with a CH shell and a metric tubeset we would expect a steerer diameter of 25.0mm.
so there are two possibilites:
a) the measurement is incorrect, possibly due to a miscommunication
[suspect we are not communicating well. another name for the steerer sometimes used is "fork tube." since you were able to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes you could use the same tool to measure the diameter of the steerer/fork tube. we would expect it to measure 25.0mm. if there is presently a headset in place all that is needed is to remove the headset locknut in order to make a measurement. do you have a seatpost for the bicycle? what is its diameter? this dimension will give a clue as to the tubing employed to construct the frame. if you do not have a seatpost for the bicycle you could use your measurement tool to make a measurement of the seat tube opening.]
or
b) the fork is a replacement
---
for a manufacturer identification we need to hear from luminaries on frankish matters such as [MENTION=43980]CV-6[/MENTION] & [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION]...or else [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION] who seems positively unstumpable.
-----
yes, the "1" fork" is the part which does not fit in.
with a CH shell and a metric tubeset we would expect a steerer diameter of 25.0mm.
so there are two possibilites:
a) the measurement is incorrect, possibly due to a miscommunication
[suspect we are not communicating well. another name for the steerer sometimes used is "fork tube." since you were able to measure the diameter of the main frame tubes you could use the same tool to measure the diameter of the steerer/fork tube. we would expect it to measure 25.0mm. if there is presently a headset in place all that is needed is to remove the headset locknut in order to make a measurement. do you have a seatpost for the bicycle? what is its diameter? this dimension will give a clue as to the tubing employed to construct the frame. if you do not have a seatpost for the bicycle you could use your measurement tool to make a measurement of the seat tube opening.]
or
b) the fork is a replacement
---
for a manufacturer identification we need to hear from luminaries on frankish matters such as [MENTION=43980]CV-6[/MENTION] & [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION]...or else [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION] who seems positively unstumpable.

-----
This is weird because I once replaced the fork with a 1" steerer carbon fork and it was compatible and free of any problems, obviously I used another headset for the carbon forks.
Last edited by Nate998; 08-19-18 at 11:34 PM.
#17
It's actually not weird, because English/French/Swiss/Italian bikes, despite the vagaries of tube sizes and threading, all use the same "frame cup inside seat" dimension: 30.2 mm. So any headset that provides frame cups to fit that dimension, no matter what its top cup/nut threading or fork crown race dimension, will fit the frame (theoretically; in practice, as with most interference fits, there are sometimes "adjustments" such as peening the fork crown race seat that have to be made).
https://www.sheldonbrown.com/cribsheet-headsets.html
https://www.sheldonbrown.com/cribsheet-headsets.html
The measures were indeed correct. The seatpost I used was 1" in diameter, so 25.4 mm. I managed to measure the head tube diameter and it is 32.5. The fork steerer tube diameter is 25.0 mm.
This is weird because I once replaced the fork with a 1" steerer carbon fork and it was compatible and free of any problems, obviously I used another headset for the carbon forks.
This is weird because I once replaced the fork with a 1" steerer carbon fork and it was compatible and free of any problems, obviously I used another headset for the carbon forks.
#18
Senior Member


Joined: May 2013
Posts: 2,643
Likes: 3,330
From: Greenwood SC USA
Bikes: 2002 Mercian Vincitore, 1982 Mercian Colorado, 1976 Puch Royal X, 1973 Raleigh Competition, 1971 Gitane Tour de France and others
It's actually not weird, because English/French/Swiss/Italian bikes, despite the vagaries of tube sizes and threading, all use the same "frame cup inside seat" dimension: 30.2 mm. So any headset that provides frame cups to fit that dimension, no matter what its top cup/nut threading or fork crown race dimension, will fit the frame (theoretically; in practice, as with most interference fits, there are sometimes "adjustments" such as peening the fork crown race seat that have to be made).
https://www.sheldonbrown.com/cribsheet-headsets.html
https://www.sheldonbrown.com/cribsheet-headsets.html
I will share that if you are willing to live with a class B or C fit, you CAN run something other than a French metric headset on a French 25.0 steerer tube. My Allegro came to me with a Campagnolo 25.4 x 24 Italian threaded headset that a previous owner had fitted to the Nervor 25.0 x 1 steerer. It almost worked, though it was predictably a teensy bit loose, and he'd left out stuff like washers and a centerpull hanger to get something that needed 42 or so mm stack height to fit onto a steerer cut for a 33 mm-ish headset. I wound up replacing it with the bottom half of a generic Tange headset to fit the monkeyed-with fork crown set and the top half of a generic Motobecane headset that has about the same dimensions as a Stronglight P-3. It works much better, and I was able to carefully thread the French bits back on and have had no issues with it. Measuring stuff with good calipers makes life a lot easier.
All of that said - I think you have some sort of French bike with a Swiss threaded bottom bracket that someone has force-fitted with an English headset. Juvela mentioned Prugnat 62/S lugs with a Vagner PC fork crown and a BB shell by Gargatte (Raccords Gargatte Freres, to which I would add that the dropouts look to me like Nervex stamped units just like the ones on a zillion entry and mid-line French bikes, including this Liberia. All of this is very French. Bertin has been mentioned - did they ever use Swiss threads? I bet other makers used similar seatstay top treatments. Is that swaged and crimped?
#19
-----
WRT dropouts -
assumed also they would be a NERVEX pattern but could not find them illustrated in me NERVEX catalogue.
there are other makers of stamped ends in France.
slightly surprised to read of the 25.4mm pillar size. frame certainly looks nice enough that would have expected something such as Durifort tubing.
look forward to the observations of [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION] and/or [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION]
-----
WRT dropouts -
assumed also they would be a NERVEX pattern but could not find them illustrated in me NERVEX catalogue.
there are other makers of stamped ends in France.
slightly surprised to read of the 25.4mm pillar size. frame certainly looks nice enough that would have expected something such as Durifort tubing.
look forward to the observations of [MENTION=359579]Filochard[/MENTION] and/or [MENTION=383399]MauriceMoss[/MENTION]

-----
#20
Senior Member

Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 540
Likes: 761
From: Los Angeles, CA
Bikes: None in ridable condition
As for the frame here, it's a veritable stumpenade!
I've seen that style of stamped dropouts before, on some mid-late 70s Euro market Gitanes and Fonlupt, but then the lugs don't match at all...

Not entirely sure what this one is. I'll keep looking.
#23
#24
Señor Member



Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 18,462
Likes: 1,554
From: Hardy, VA
Bikes: Mostly English - predominantly Raleighs
Asking what may be a stupid question, but here goes - in the interest of possibly advancing the identification process. How was the seatpost diameter measured?
__________________
In search of what to search for.
In search of what to search for.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Silvestru
Classic and Vintage Bicycles: Whats it Worth? Appraisals.
14
08-17-19 05:17 AM
Collin2424
Classic & Vintage
128
04-30-10 05:24 PM










