Compensating for too-small frame?
#51
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
A fellow I know is a huge fan of The Who. He's gotten the autographs of Daltry, Townshend and Entwistle, and he bought one of Keith Moon's. He has everything they've ever recorded, he's seen them live dozens of times, bla, bla, bla. But the one thing he really lusted after was Rickenbacker guitar like Pete Townshend played (and frequently smashed) -- and not just any ol' Rick, but a proper 1960s Rickenbacker model 360, with a "cherry-burst" finish. Just like Pete played.
After saving-up for the better part of a decade, he was finally able to buy just such a guitar. It cost him more than I paid for my last car. And here's the thing: this fellow doesn't play guitar. He has fingers like Vienna sausages, and no musical talent. But I've never seen him as happy as when he's looking at it hanging on his living room wall, in the center of all of his framed Who memorabilia -- a touchstone to a group of guys who were at their best before he was even born.
After saving-up for the better part of a decade, he was finally able to buy just such a guitar. It cost him more than I paid for my last car. And here's the thing: this fellow doesn't play guitar. He has fingers like Vienna sausages, and no musical talent. But I've never seen him as happy as when he's looking at it hanging on his living room wall, in the center of all of his framed Who memorabilia -- a touchstone to a group of guys who were at their best before he was even born.
Last edited by rch427; 07-01-20 at 04:40 AM.
#52
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
So, I ended up doing what I've sometimes done in the past, when on the fence: I made a low-ball offer, and left it up to the seller to make up my mind for me, so to speak. I offered what I thought I could re-sell it for, if it doesn't work out (and if I could bear to part with it).
Spoiler alert: I just got notification that they accepted my offer.
Spoiler alert: I just got notification that they accepted my offer.
#53
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2018
Posts: 2,529
Likes: 1,976
From: SW Ohio
So, I ended up doing what I've sometimes done in the past, when on the fence: I made a low-ball offer, and left it up to the seller to make up my mind for me, so to speak. I offered what I thought I could re-sell it for, if it doesn't work out (and if I could bear to part with it).
Spoiler alert: I just got notification that they accepted my offer.
Spoiler alert: I just got notification that they accepted my offer.
#55
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,904
Likes: 527
From: SW Ohio
Bikes: Puch Marco Polo, Saint Tropez, Masi Gran Criterium
#56
I'd like to hear from one of our regulars that believes 2cm in top tube is a "measly" amount. For me, even a half cm in top tube length is significant. A shorter bike cannot simply be made up with a longer stem. It will certainly help make it fit, but the bike will feel very differently. It just takes experience to know.
My biggest issue with a frame too small is bar drop. Not a lot of adjustment in your average stem. Yes, there are stems that can go "up" along with seat, but for me, they look goofy. In addition to not riding a bike that doesn't fit physically, it also needs to fit aesthetically.
#57
Dedicated Detritus Dodger


Joined: Oct 2015
Posts: 485
Likes: 662
From: Fairfax, California
Bikes: Some mighty fine ones at that!
I was going to say that you cannot properly call it a "grail bike" if it does not fit you, but Wildwood beat me to it.
I work at a musical instrument store and we have a term for guys (yes, they're ALWAYS men) like this:
Blues lawyers.
After saving-up for the better part of a decade, he was finally able to buy just such a guitar. It cost him more than I paid for my last car. And here's the thing: this fellow doesn't play guitar. He has fingers like Vienna sausages, and no musical talent. But I've never seen him as happy as when he's looking at it hanging on his living room wall, in the center of all of his framed Who memorabilia -- a touchstone to a group of guys who were at their best before he was even born.
Blues lawyers.
#58
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
#64
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
No, it's not the most exceptional example of their frames; it lacks some of the really special touches that I've seen. And it's by Angelo, rather than Francesco. But it's in the original finish, and I love the color; it's so understated and unusual.
#67
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
#68
Senior Member




Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 15,382
Likes: 8,301
From: Seattle area
Bikes: Bikes??? Thought this was social media?!?
A fellow I know is a huge fan of The Who. He's gotten the autographs of Daltry, Townshend and Entwistle, and he bought one of Keith Moon's. He has everything they've ever recorded, he's seen them live dozens of times, bla, bla, bla. But the one thing he really lusted after was Rickenbacker guitar like Pete Townshend played (and frequently smashed) -- and not just any ol' Rick, but a proper 1960s Rickenbacker model 360, with a "cherry-burst" finish. Just like Pete played.
After saving-up for the better part of a decade, he was finally able to buy just such a guitar. It cost him more than I paid for my last car. And here's the thing: this fellow doesn't play guitar. He has fingers like Vienna sausages, and no musical talent. But I've never seen him as happy as when he's looking at it hanging on his living room wall, in the center of all of his framed Who memorabilia -- a touchstone to a group of guys who were at their best before he was even born.
After saving-up for the better part of a decade, he was finally able to buy just such a guitar. It cost him more than I paid for my last car. And here's the thing: this fellow doesn't play guitar. He has fingers like Vienna sausages, and no musical talent. But I've never seen him as happy as when he's looking at it hanging on his living room wall, in the center of all of his framed Who memorabilia -- a touchstone to a group of guys who were at their best before he was even born.
__________________
Vintage, modern, e-road. It is a big cycling universe.
Vintage, modern, e-road. It is a big cycling universe.
#69
I don't know. I have 5 bikes. Some of you guys have 20 or more. I'm sure many of them "ride the same."
Above, I was talking about "fitting the same," which isn't ... the same.
What's the point of bikes fitting the same? I don't even really want "exactly" that. I want them to be very much in the ballpark with not a huge difference in bar drop.
I don't have a track bike, but do have access to a velodrome. They don't allow road bikes, or I would ride on it.
Agree. And the other side of the goofy looking coin, as you say, is bar drop, which can make a too-small road bike end up looking like a time trial setup.
Above, I was talking about "fitting the same," which isn't ... the same.
What's the point of bikes fitting the same? I don't even really want "exactly" that. I want them to be very much in the ballpark with not a huge difference in bar drop.
I don't have a track bike, but do have access to a velodrome. They don't allow road bikes, or I would ride on it.
Agree. And the other side of the goofy looking coin, as you say, is bar drop, which can make a too-small road bike end up looking like a time trial setup.

Feel is different from fit, you mentioned feel, I got the 2 conflated. As it turns out, I am all torso and my affinity for older Italian bikes turned out fortuitous as they typically have a top tube 2-3cm longer than the seat tubes. But I also can deal with a square bike by either an offset seat post (not my favorite look) or a longer stem. My butt/hands position is essentially the same on all my bikes only with the BB moving forward and backwards relative to that seat/bars setup. It is odd to ride one bike with the BB "back" and the next day ride a bike with the BB "forward". But after 5-10 minutes, I'm used to the "new" setup.
If I had the time or inclination, I'd get the exact same bike in my max/min sizes, set both to fit properly with stems/posts and see how different the feel is. I doubt I would notice, I'm no princess by any means, but who knows. I just know I have had bikes too small and I don't like them in the end no matter how much I wished they worked.
#71
Thread Starter
Full Member

Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 217
Likes: 53
From: San Francisco
Bikes: 1965 Hetchin's, 1977 Galmozzi, 1956 Rochet, 1947 Gnome et Rhone, 1972 De Rosa, 1948 Bates B-A-R, 1989 Trevor Jarvis (Baines) "Flying Gate", etc.
Thanks, Millstone! It should be a fun project. I'll post a photo or two once it's built-up, so everyone can scratch their heads and ask "Why the hell would he do that to a Galmozzi?!"
#72
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2013
Posts: 2,090
Likes: 350
Seller called that 55? Lot of headtube for a 55. Even if 55 on centers that is a lot of headtube. Frame drop looks normal, head will look taller if frame has little drop. Sellers don’t always know what they have. You won't know for sure until it is in your hands.
Coaster brake on this one? That hurts. There are some very fine Stucchi and Gloria city bikes with a Galmozzi connection, look for those.
Coaster brake on this one? That hurts. There are some very fine Stucchi and Gloria city bikes with a Galmozzi connection, look for those.
#73
Member
Joined: Apr 2020
Posts: 30
Likes: 0
Bikes: Fausto Coppi and Brompton
Some say that bikes that are a few cm's smaller works for them in terms of handling sense (swaying; flare; spurt). I guess it really differs from one rider to another. Safest is to wait for the right frame or bike to come along. Patience my friend, coz it come to you as a surprise that, it may be a better bike that the one you want now.
#74
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 3,487
Likes: 1,552
From: Oakland, CA
Bikes: '82 Univega Competizione, '72 Motobecane Grand Record, '83 Mercian KOM Touring, '85 Univega Alpina Uno, '76 Eisentraut Limited
#75
Señor Member



Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 18,473
Likes: 1,559
From: Hardy, VA
Bikes: Mostly English - predominantly Raleighs
Seller called that 55? Lot of headtube for a 55. Even if 55 on centers that is a lot of headtube. Frame drop looks normal, head will look taller if frame has little drop. Sellers don’t always know what they have. You won't know for sure until it is in your hands.
Coaster brake on this one? That hurts. There are some very fine Stucchi and Gloria city bikes with a Galmozzi connection, look for those.
Coaster brake on this one? That hurts. There are some very fine Stucchi and Gloria city bikes with a Galmozzi connection, look for those.
__________________
In search of what to search for.
In search of what to search for.





