Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Classic & Vintage (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/)
-   -   Whats your take on Replica frames? (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/705536-whats-your-take-replica-frames.html)

MACAQUE 01-08-11 12:55 AM


Originally Posted by Chris Chicago (Post 12041855)
the only good reason I can think of for doing this is to pull some goldigger cycling tail, if such a creature exists.


this creature does NOT exist. i've been searching for years

Picchio Special 01-08-11 07:18 AM


Originally Posted by repechage (Post 12045032)
The Speedplay Masi Special replica project came from the refusal of Joe Bell to Repaint it.

http://www.speedplay.com/speedplayla...asi_large.html

Here's an example of a restoration that leaves me cold:

http://cgi.ebay.com/Masi-Special-Fae...89997307534577

My hunch is that you'll agree with me. I respect Scott as a collector and historian, and it was done by Alberto, but I think it's too aggressive and kills the mojo still living in the unrestored version. Candy paint pooling in the shorelines - yuck. I can only hope the bike was beyond saving in its original nick.

Amesja 01-08-11 07:43 AM

I think it would be cooler to take a '51 Masi Special and repaint with Schwinn Decals myself...

RobbieTunes 01-08-11 08:28 AM

If I ever do another refinish, I like the idea of a cartoon character or something fun.

Not in my thoughts to rebadge something into a Masi, or anthing like that.

My 8mm Mauser would not like to be called an AK.

KonAaron Snake 01-08-11 08:32 AM


Originally Posted by RobbieTunes (Post 12046427)
If I ever do another refinish, I like the idea of a cartoon character or something fun.

Not in my thoughts to rebadge something into a Masi, or anthing like that.

My 8mm Mauser would not like to be called an AK.

I think I'd do a history theme...

Maybe a red bike could be the Mao.
A cruiser could be Old Iron Sides
Maybe the USS Monitor for a heavy bike.
Nautilus might be a good name.

Amesja 01-08-11 08:43 AM

3 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by RobbieTunes (Post 12046427)

My 8mm Mauser would not like to be called an AK.

Rebranding firearms is all the rage! The AR-15 community has done dozens of them. Here are just a few

John Deere, Hello Kitty, and Barbie! -all from the AR-15 platform (actually M-4geries)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=185301http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=185302http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=185303

bbattle 01-08-11 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by cudak888 (Post 12041537)
Then there's the question: "What is a MASI?"

Just thought I'd mention it.

-Kurt


Trying to stir up trouble? ;)

(my flame bait answer is to say that "real" Masis were built in California.)

big chainring 01-08-11 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by Henry III (Post 12045649)
Holy smokes I just got home from work and this thread blew up! This wasn't to try to pull the wool over someone's else to pass it off but more so something I could ride and not feel bad about if it got stolen, damaged etc... As for the using your own name. I actually had some decals made up with my last name on my carbon ebay road frame build and could actually do that since I have three more sets of decals. I was doing a repaint anyways since I was planning on brazing on some dt shift bosses and cable guides since it originally has stem mounted shifters.
I thought about picking up a Speciale Commuter but then what different is that Taiwan branded Masi to my Schwinnasonic? There's nothing special about newer Masi's in my opinion for what their worth. I'd never try to pass it off as a real deal and specify it's a replica on the frame somewhere. The frame/fork is the only original thing as everything else is Italian...Record low flange wheelset, headset, calipers, Cinelli stem/bars etc... Well everyone is allowed their own opinion and I got what I asked be it positive or negative.

This is one of the more bizarre threads I've seen in a while. I like the idea of the Masi decals on your Schwinn. Jeez, have a little fun. I have an old frame I'm putting Bottecchia decals on because I like the checkerboard accent decals, and Bottecchia rolls off my tongue and reminds me of Botticelli, the Italian artist.

bbattle 01-08-11 08:53 AM

I don't have a problem with anyone repainting/rebadging a bike to make it look like a more expensive bike as long as they include a disclaimer decal somewhere inconspicuous like on the seat tube down near the bottom bracket. Reputable restorers often include their decal on their work.

Of course, no amount of paint or decals will make a Varsity into a Pinarello so the disclaimer decal would not be necessary.

bbattle 01-08-11 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by Picchio Special (Post 12046301)
Here's an example of a restoration that leaves me cold:

http://cgi.ebay.com/Masi-Special-Fae...89997307534577

My hunch is that you'll agree with me. I respect Scott as a collector and historian, and it was done by Alberto, but I think it's too aggressive and kills the mojo still living in the unrestored version. Candy paint pooling in the shorelines - yuck. I can only hope the bike was beyond saving in its original nick.

Did they powdercoat that frame? All the detail in the lugwork is almost gone.

repechage 01-08-11 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by Picchio Special (Post 12046301)
Here's an example of a restoration that leaves me cold:

http://cgi.ebay.com/Masi-Special-Fae...89997307534577

My hunch is that you'll agree with me. I respect Scott as a collector and historian, and it was done by Alberto, but I think it's too aggressive and kills the mojo still living in the unrestored version. Candy paint pooling in the shorelines - yuck. I can only hope the bike was beyond saving in its original nick.

I saw images of this frame some time ago, it is much less than it could have been. It can be redone. Makes one wonder how this effort was managed by Alberto and the painter. There have been other repaints from there that were better, a poor supplier choice I guess.

gitarzan 01-08-11 09:43 AM

Would you put Schwinn decals on a Huffy?

sciencemonster 01-08-11 09:43 AM


Originally Posted by Drillium Dude (Post 12045336)
Looked for Saba decals for four years, couldn't source them. I wanted to refinish this bike - paint was in a sorry, sorry state. After removing every pantographed/engraved 'Saba' signature with a Dremel I re-badged it using my own made-up moniker, based upon the Alpine Cycles font.

The result:

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1249/...1c546881_b.jpg

Since this was now "my" bike, I took the theme to extremes - again using the Dremel - with the complete drillium treatment.

My 2 cents...

DD

Personally, I prefer a contrasting cat with my bikes. You can never get them just right trying to match. If that was me, I'd send the cat out for a repaint.

bigbossman 01-08-11 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by sciencemonster (Post 12046647)
Personally, I prefer a contrasting cat with my bikes. You can never get them just right trying to match. If that was me, I'd send the cat out for a repaint.

Or shave it.

mudboy 01-08-11 09:51 AM

Putting Masi decals on a Schwinn doesn't make it a "replica". It makes it a Schwinn with Masi decals.

Taking a Masi's geometry, design details, etc., and replicating them make it a "replica".

Personally, I'm one of those people who think "If you can't afford one of those things that you covet, like a Rolex, or a fancy handbag, or a bicycle, don't buy a fake in the hopes of impressing someone who is dumber than you are."

In other words, keep it real.

RobbieTunes 01-08-11 09:52 AM


Originally Posted by bigbossman (Post 12046651)
Or shave it.

Or give it a bath. Mine likes it, but the fur gets stuck to my tongue.

gitarzan 01-08-11 09:59 AM

Ever see a dingle berry who puts a Lamborghini decal on his beat up Tempo? Like he's fooling someone? Even if he's not trying to fool anyone he looks like a dork?

That's it.

sciencemonster 01-08-11 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by mudboy (Post 12046668)
Putting Masi decals on a Schwinn doesn't make it a "replica". It makes it a Schwinn with Masi decals.

Taking a Masi's geometry, design details, etc., and replicating them make it a "replica".

Personally, I'm one of those people who think "If you can't afford one of those things that you covet, like a Rolex, or a fancy handbag, or a bicycle, don't buy a fake in the hopes of impressing someone who is dumber than you are."

In other words, keep it real.

I think the goal is not to impress you friends - it's to satisfy yourself.

mudboy 01-08-11 11:16 AM


Originally Posted by sciencemonster (Post 12046797)
I think the goal is not to impress you friends - it's to satisfy yourself.

I suppose I don't understand, then, which is fine.

Picchio Special 01-08-11 11:22 AM


Originally Posted by sciencemonster (Post 12046797)
I think the goal is not to impress you friends - it's to satisfy yourself.

They sell replicas for that, too.

sciencemonster 01-08-11 11:51 AM

It's not the same thing. For instance, I take old flashlights and bike lights and replace the innards with superbright LEDs. His plan is the same, only on the outside. For one, you build it yourself. For two, you get something that looks exactly what you want.

I'm not saying I would do what the OP proposed, I'm just saying I can understand his motivation. You can assume he's not wanting to do something tricky, and you can say that's not for you. I just wouldn't diss it as 'phoney' or posing. You either get it, or you don't.

Drillium Dude 01-08-11 04:45 PM


Originally Posted by Picchio Special (Post 12046980)
They sell replicas for that, too.

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Velognome 01-08-11 07:56 PM

This is silly

3speed 01-08-11 08:15 PM


Originally Posted by RobbieTunes (Post 12046670)
Or give it a bath. Mine likes it, but the fur gets stuck to my tongue.

:lol::lol::lol:

Picchio Special 01-08-11 08:35 PM

Robbie and I will be appearing in the Catskills throughout the month of February. Reserve your tickets now.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:15 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.