Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Classic & Vintage (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/)
-   -   Can anyone explain... (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/942831-can-anyone-explain.html)

Italuminium 04-12-14 08:04 AM

Can anyone explain...
 
Why Campagnolo Veloce Ergopower brifters are cheaper than Sora's, but Veloce RD's are more expensive than Ultegra RD's? Just a little observation... I'm somewhat stumped by these pricing oddities.

It seems that all those Shimergo guys are right all along: Campagnolo shifters with Shimano RD's, wheels and cassettes are the cheapest way to get a brifter bike.

repechage 04-12-14 08:14 AM

Shimano has more flexibility on pricing. Campagnolo being so much smaller, each assembly has to pay its way.

gomango 04-12-14 08:24 AM


Originally Posted by Italuminium (Post 16664237)
Why Campagnolo Veloce Ergopower brifters are cheaper than Sora's, but Veloce RD's are more expensive than Ultegra RD's? Just a little observation... I'm somewhat stumped by these pricing oddities.

It seems that all those Shimergo guys are right all along: Campagnolo shifters with Shimano RD's, wheels and cassettes are the cheapest way to get a brifter bike.

Nothing wrong at all going with the lower cost Shimergo route, especially for x bikes.

I wouldn't discount the used Campy route though.

I picked up a complete 2009 Centaur group last night for less than $250.

Maybe it was pure luck, but I had answered an ad locally two months ago and he had the groupset at a higher price so I passed.

It never sold and he called me back to sell it at my "offer" price.

It's going on a friend's Ridley x bike this afternoon. :)

gomango 04-12-14 08:26 AM


Originally Posted by repechage (Post 16664263)
Shimano has more flexibility on pricing. Campagnolo being so much smaller, each assembly has to pay its way.

They do have to pay their own way, but watch closely for the next year as Campy shuffles their lineup just a bit. Probably one group, maybe another will be discontinued. Always great deals when groups are nixed.

Italuminium 04-12-14 12:19 PM


Originally Posted by gomango (Post 16664287)
They do have to pay their own way, but watch closely for the next year as Campy shuffles their lineup just a bit. Probably one group, maybe another will be discontinued. Always great deals when groups are nixed.

good advice Grady. Postponing the project to next year gives me a good time to save up for some really choice bits too.

fietsbob 04-12-14 12:32 PM

30 years ago Campagnolo was what 3rd party companies copied, now they try to make their stuff Shimano like.


My touring bike in the mid 80's got parts from when Campag admitted defeat, and gave up the MTB sector, entirely .

gomango 04-12-14 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by Italuminium (Post 16664725)
good advice Grady. Postponing the project to next year gives me a good time to save up for some really choice bits too.

The sweet spot for me is still 10 speed Chorus. Great performance, looks good and cheap.

Deals are out there on lightly used Chorus groups.

Chrome Molly 04-12-14 12:46 PM

Agree chorus is Campy's best deal going as far as their whole gruppos goes. The veloce brifters are essentially disposable. They can be "re-cored" but that one part costs about as much as a whole new set with fresh cables. The chorus on up brifters can be rebulit.

Though, on the budget end there is quite a bit to be said for Veloce pulling an Ultegra RD. It really is a sweet combination for the amount of $'s involved. Ultegra RD's really aren't tangibly outperformed by anything.

The real deals right about now are some of the higher end 10 speed wheelsets, since everything is going 11 speed. Buy a 10 speed wheelset for your 8 speed cassette, then add in the ultegra RD and veloce brifters and you have a real freshening up of a nice 80's steel ride.

dddd 04-12-14 01:46 PM

I figure that, since Shimano's brifters not only aren't rebuildable, but also that they expire just from sitting in the garage, that there is a relative scarcity of Shimano brifters in the marketplace versus Shimano rear derailers.

Whereas, with Campy, the Ergolevers on all of the seldom-used bikes that eventually get sold, with some of these bikes being parted out as "parts available" on the market, are still serviceable years longer than would be Shimano's brifters.

Also, in the past, with Campagnolo having used wider cassettes and thus a closer sprocket-to-spokes distance on their rear hubs, many a Campag rear derailer met it's maker after being shifted into the spokes.
This has resulted in a relative scarcity of Campag rear derailers versus Campag Ergolevers available.

Lastly, with Shimano offering MTB derailers, many of these get substituted for a bike's original Road derailer, leaving a few more Shimano road rear derailers looking for a home.

gomango 04-12-14 02:09 PM


Originally Posted by Chrome Molly (Post 16664765)
Agree chorus is Campy's best deal going as far as their whole gruppos goes. The veloce brifters are essentially disposable. They can be "re-cored" but that one part costs about as much as a whole new set with fresh cables. The chorus on up brifters can be rebulit.

Though, on the budget end there is quite a bit to be said for Veloce pulling an Ultegra RD. It really is a sweet combination for the amount of $'s involved. Ultegra RD's really aren't tangibly outperformed by anything.

The real deals right about now are some of the higher end 10 speed wheelsets, since everything is going 11 speed. Buy a 10 speed wheelset for your 8 speed cassette, then add in the ultegra RD and veloce brifters and you have a real freshening up of a nice 80's steel ride.

Good point on Ultegra.

Makes me wonder why one would go to DA now that 6800 is out there.

Loads of trickle down value at that price point.

Italuminium 04-12-14 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by gomango (Post 16664751)
The sweet spot for me is still 10 speed Chorus. Great performance, looks good and cheap.

Deals are out there on lightly used Chorus groups.

threw in my hat on just such a gruppo today :) Maladvertised, so I might just score a deal there. I've done it twice before, netting a Daytona group and a real nice Centaur one with Daytona/CXP33 wheels.

gomango 04-12-14 02:40 PM


Originally Posted by Italuminium (Post 16664897)
threw in my hat on just such a gruppo today :) Maladvertised, so I might just score a deal there. I've done it twice before, netting a Daytona group and a real nice Centaur one with Daytona/CXP33 wheels.

I hope you get it.

The deals do pop up, so we'll cross our fingers.

I am assuming this is for your fancy new Somec frameset?

Italuminium 04-13-14 01:16 AM


Originally Posted by gomango (Post 16664925)
I hope you get it.

The deals do pop up, so we'll cross our fingers.

I am assuming this is for your fancy new Somec frameset?

Yes, for the Somec. Definitely not a frame to build up with parts bin deore/tiagra :)

gomango 04-13-14 05:27 AM


Originally Posted by Italuminium (Post 16665913)
Yes, for the Somec. Definitely not a frame to build up with parts bin deore/tiagra :)

Do you have a special wheelset in mind?

Does the owner of the groupset also have an appropriate wheelset?

Never hurts to ask them.

Italuminium 04-13-14 07:41 AM


Originally Posted by gomango (Post 16666023)
Do you have a special wheelset in mind?

Does the owner of the groupset also have an appropriate wheelset?

Never hurts to ask them.

yeah, I learned that asking people what they haven't put online yet pays off! the other day I bought an Icarus front hub, and asked if he had any more Campy MTB stuff lying around. Turned out he only posted the BB's and headsets he had, but not the brake parts, since "nobody runs canti's anymore". That got me some perfect Icarus levers too.

Wheelset is undecided yet: I do have a nice set of Zonda's I can swap in, or a more classic combo of Daytona hubs and Mavic rims. I also picked up a pair of 20/24 Novatec hubs, just because they were cheap and local. I could build those into a pair of mock Shamals with some shiny 38 mm rims.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:08 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.