Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Review on the GMC Denali bicycle (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/237231-review-gmc-denali-bicycle.html)

gpsblake 11-23-06 12:26 AM

Saw a 99 dollar road bike at Toys-R-US in Columbia SC. I kid you not and they had both male and female road bikes. It had plastic finger shifters mounted on the handlebars and no quick release tires or quick release seat. Tires were 700x25 Schrader. Center pull brakes instead of side pull which was a huge surprise. They both needed to be adjusted in the brakes, no biggie though. Looks like the plastic finger shifters wouldn't last long but again, a simple replacement part.

99 bucks.

mastershake916 11-23-06 12:43 AM

I remember seeing a dodge branded bike a while back looking for a clearanced toys-"r"-us.
It was a road bike, had the classic steel frame, drop bars with brakes and extenders.

vrkelley 11-23-06 09:17 AM


Originally Posted by gpsblake
no quick release tires or quick release seat. Tires were 700x25 Schrader.

So the wheels and seat are less likely to be jacked AND you can probably refill those tires at most any gas station. so...Your point was?

CigTech 11-23-06 01:52 PM

Ok guys did the morning shift at the wifes store. At 5:30 tonight I'll be at my store. The best part is the double commute in one day.

CigTech 11-24-06 06:35 PM

On the way to work today, a SUV pulled up next to me and they said "Nice bike". I said thanks and told them they could go to Wal-Mart and get one for $158.11. Then one guy said that the bike looks like one of the 800 to 900 dollar bikes. Then The light changed and off we wnet to the next light about 1/2 mile up the road. I was doing 26.1 and kind of out run him to the light. the guy pulled up next to me and said "Man your fast" I told him that I did not want to be late for work then took off.

Denalis is still run flawless. Not a problem with it. So far I have 813.7 miles on it.

gpsblake 11-24-06 10:22 PM


Originally Posted by vrkelley
So the wheels and seat are less likely to be jacked AND you can probably refill those tires at most any gas station. so...Your point was?

No point, just describing the bicycle. I would consider the valves on that bike to a be a plus although I have read that a Schrader value on thin tires makes the rim weaker. I would prefer quick release seat and front tire just to transport the bike easier but it's no big deal to carry a wrench around either. I always carry a quick tool with me on my local rides.

This Toys R US bike wasn't on clearance either. Had no extenders but was a steel frame. Frankly, it weighs a lot.

I still think my bike is going to be the Walmart Schwinn Varsity for $199, mainly because I've had nothing but good experiences with the Walmart Schwinn's and you can't beat the return policy. One thing I forgot to mention, the Walmart Varsity comes with clips (leather), I would like to experiment with using clips on my pedals. However, the West Columbia Walmart has had 2 Denali's out for over six months (with one obviously returned) and I might try to negotiate a lower price and if I can get one for a good discount, I'll get the Denali and just do what CigTech did to make room for my light and gps unit.

I wouldn't tour with a road bike though but I figure for local rides where I avoid the dirt roads, it's worth a go to see an increase in performance.

voileauciel 11-26-06 10:04 PM

Cig,

Just wondering here: how is the wheelset holding up? I was actually thinking of buying one of these if only for the wheels (schraeder stem makes sense on long tours) and would like to keep a cheap set around as spares.

Man I wish I was in Florida.....

C

mastershake916 11-26-06 10:32 PM


Originally Posted by voileauciel
Cig,

Just wondering here: how is the wheelset holding up? I was actually thinking of buying one of these if only for the wheels (schraeder stem makes sense on long tours) and would like to keep a cheap set around as spares.

Man I wish I was in Florida.....

C

His says that they were doing good a while back.

CigTech 11-26-06 11:34 PM

There are holding up better than I thought they would. I just check them out yesterday and they are still round and true. And the rest of the bike is holding up better then I thought it would as well.

I just order some Tufo Valve Extender here is the web site:
http://www.biketiresdirect.com/produ...2337&c=5639835

CigTech 11-29-06 12:07 AM

Well, did the commute to work today. the breaks are still work better then I had hoped for after reading the online reviews. I did notice a little delay when shifting from 3rd to 2nd gears. So I have to check it out tomorrow. Other then that the Denali is way passed want I thought it was worth.

BTW, On the commute to work today a road a roadie into the ground. We had a tailwind of 12 mph gusting to 18 mph. and I passed him at 34.6 mph. Of course he tried to keep up but failed when I went to 7th gear (I only use the 48th chainring, So to me the Denali is only a 7 gear bike). When I got it up to 36.8 mph I left him behind in a hurry.

xpenny 11-29-06 01:10 AM

Cig, 1st , nice work on the review. No matter whatever specimen you
are experimenting on, it's the methodoglogy that speaks, which you get it I think. For
those who laugh at the nature of the bike, think about how much you've taken a price
tag for granted.

2nd, it's not about how much a bike is, it's about how much you can get out of it with the money.

3rd, I don't think the manufacturing difference between PR and TW is way dissimilar, like one of the poster mentioned. This is obviously biased, indicated by his political view IMO, and without support.
In fact, I know PR already overtook TW to be the main factory of High-end frames including carbon fiber. By "overtook" I mean the frames that can be made in TW can be made in PR as well. And obviously a larger number of this level of frames are made from PR due to the cheaper labor. You probably dont know much about bike industry.

4th, Cig, I don't agree with upgrading the denali with too high end components. I mean, it's definitely ligitimate and reasonable to, say, replace the wheelsets, crankset and derailer. But to a certain degree. Just to maximize the performance with this frame, you don't need to go with $800 components. there are tons of cheaper yet decent gadets out there that will make your denali a bulletproof. isn't that just what you want out of it?

Nice ressearch.

xpenny 11-29-06 02:46 AM


Originally Posted by fender1

So i guess I wonder what the point is? I see plenty of aluminum framed road bikes on e-bay that go between $100-$200. Sorry if I am comig off as a jerk, but the outcome has very little pratical real world application. Entertainement value, plenty.

Whether people will buy the bike in question is not the point. The point is, IMO, cig is trying to prove that the denali is not as crappy as 99.9% people expect at the first glance. And it actually has the potential to be upgraded.

barba 11-29-06 06:52 AM


Originally Posted by CigTech
BTW, On the commute to work today a road a roadie into the ground. We had a tailwind of 12 mph gusting to 18 mph. and I passed him at 34.6 mph. Of course he tried to keep up but failed when I went to 7th gear (I only use the 48th chainring, So to me the Denali is only a 7 gear bike). When I got it up to 36.8 mph I left him behind in a hurry.

You should get a pro contract.

CigTech 11-29-06 10:44 AM

I wanted to do the race to replace lance. But do to my synthroid, that I have to take, it would make it very hard to pass the drug test that the racers have to take.

xpenny 11-29-06 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by LóFarkas
Way to be an elitist asshat (oops, that's not pc, is it?)

Budget bikes are a whole different ball game and if you think that only $600+ bikes deserve to be on the road you're fool.

The thing is, you can't know the Lemond will be under you ass 10 years from now. It may get stolen, you may crash it and have to write frame+fork off. You also can't be sure that Cigtech won't clock up 20,000 miles before the denali falls apart.

Bottom line is, he's been an overall nice guy and you have not.

That's really speaking my heart out. those "elite" trying gain self-esteem by comparing their LeMond
with other's wally. There is no point at all. Their logic is like I've got more money, so I got an hummer, and it's more bomber proof than your dodge. So I am elite and your loser.

And notice that, there has been no reported problems from most of the components from the denali, which means, with some replacements, say the crankset and the DR, I think it's gonna last quite a while.

ModoVincere 11-29-06 12:15 PM

What's the mileage total up to?
My WW mtn bike commuter is over 1200 miles with no problems.

CigTech 11-29-06 02:53 PM

I now have 913.7 miles on the Denali.

The delayed shift from 3rd to 2nd was caused by sand in the derailer. So cleaned it out and all is good again.

I-Like-To-Bike 11-29-06 05:07 PM


Originally Posted by xpenny
And notice that, there has been no reported problems from most of the components from the denali, which means, with some replacements, say the crankset and the DR, I think it's gonna last quite a while.

WhaChu Talkin' 'bout? Cig Tech just reported a glitch caused by sand in the derailler. That would NEVER happen to a Lemond or similar REAL Bike owned by a REAL Cyclist, eh?

kilobytes1986 11-29-06 09:52 PM

my god, the ego.

squeakywheel 11-29-06 10:05 PM


Originally Posted by CigTech
I now have 913.7 miles on the Denali.

The delayed shift from 3rd to 2nd was caused by sand in the derailer. So cleaned it out and all is good again.

Don't tell me your bike computer costs more than your bike. ;)

lyeinyoureye 11-29-06 10:21 PM


Originally Posted by xpenny
Whether people will buy the bike in question is not the point. The point is, IMO, cig is trying to prove that the denali is not as crappy as 99.9% people expect at the first glance. And it actually has the potential to be upgraded.

It's not just that, it also comes with a warranty and is probably easy to return. Compared to an older, high end, Al road bike for the same price, it's an excellent value for someone getting their feet wet. If they go chasing older bikes w/o knowing what kind of problems to look for and expect, they can get screwed. Not that Wally's doesn't assemble more than their fair share of bikes incorrectly... But the warranty more than makes up for it.

Cyclaholic 11-29-06 11:13 PM

G'day Cig,

I'm thoroughly enjoying this nice little thread you got going, even though we don't have the bike you're riding here in our stores.

It took over 420 posts but I think you've just about 'dropped' the non-beleivers in the peloton and are leading the Denali fan club breakaway group :D

CigTech 11-29-06 11:47 PM


Originally Posted by squeakywheel
Don't tell me your bike computer costs more than your bike. ;)

No the computer I'm using is the Planet Bike Protege 8.0. It was only $16.99 + shipping. BTW it is a nice little basic bike computer.

CigTech 11-30-06 12:05 AM


Originally Posted by Cyclaholic
G'day Cig,

I'm thoroughly enjoying this nice little thread you got going, even though we don't have the bike you're riding here in our stores.

It took over 420 posts but I think you've just about 'dropped' the non-beleivers in the peloton and are leading the Denali fan club breakaway group :D

Hey Cyclaholic,

I don't know about leading a fan club, but I think your on to something there. :D

There is alot I want to due to the Denali to improve it, But I will wait until after the test of 2000 miles. Then I'm going to change the Chainrings to 53th/39th. It has a 48/38/28 chainrings. And kick up the Cassette to a 7 speed 13,14,15,17,19,21,24. From the 14/28 Cassette. Then add the Shimano ST-3300 7 speed Break/shafters. And drop in some light high speed hubs. Then I'll be back up to my reg. speeds. And put a one piece handbars.

Cyclaholic 11-30-06 01:18 AM


Originally Posted by CigTech
Hey Cyclaholic,

I don't know about leading a fan club, but I think your on to something there. :D

There is alot I want to due to the Denali to improve it, But I will wait until after the test of 2000 miles. Then I'm going to change the Chainrings to 53th/39th. It has a 48/38/28 chainrings. And kick up the Cassette to a 7 speed 13,14,15,17,19,21,24. From the 14/28 Cassette. Then add the Shimano ST-3300 7 speed Break/shafters. And drop in some light high speed hubs. Then I'll be back up to my reg. speeds. And put a one piece handbars.

Sounds good! though I reckon you'll get a heck of a lot more than 2000 miles out of the stock bike if you wanted to, the way you're going. I for one would love to see just how much life you can get out of her before a major component failed. You can go to the higher gearing as sprockets & chainrings wear out, speaking of which have you been keeping a check of chain wear? I for one am curious to see how these bottom end drivetrain components do under a serious rider like yourself - that would definitely be relevant information to many of us!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:49 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.