I'm looking for a commuter for a short commute to school and work but also something I can ride out to the lake on the weekends, which is about 20 miles round trip. It looks like to me a like a cross bike would fit that role nicely. Would that be a good bike for that?

I like the idea of brakes on the flats. Is it possible to put some Avid BB7's or BB5's on there and still use the flats levers?

I've been around long enough to see alot of negativity to Bikes Direct. How reliable are they?

The Fantom Cross Pro is essentially the same as the Fuji Cross (I think there are 3 levels of the bike on both brands.)

I came very close to buying one for my commuter - I ended up with a Kona Jake the Snake (deal I couldn't pass up), but either one would make a great commuter. I swapped out the knobbies for slicks, added fenders, rack, light kit and an Airzound, and it's an awesome setup.

The main limitation of bikesdirect is assembly and proper fitting. If you are sure of the bike size you need, it can be a great deal. You still need to either pay someone to assemble it and tune it up or else pay for tools and a bike stand to do it yourself.

I own a Windsor Tourist from bikesdirect and my experience with them has been OK. They shipped the bike one day after receiving my order and the bike is what it was claimed to be. The only real complaint I have is that my bottom bracket went bad after 600 km of riding. The Windsor Tourist uses "Chin Haur" brand bottom bracket and headset, along with no-name brand hubs and rims. I replaced the bottom bracket with one made by Shimano, and didn't bother trying for a warranty replacement. In your case, the Fantom Cross Pro comes with higher quality name brand hubs, bottom bracket, headset, etc. Plus full Ultegra set of components. It seems like a pretty good deal.

Others might poo-poo this bike, but I think it is a lot of bike for the money! I think the plus side of having to assemble it, is knowing more about your bike. The components of the bike are quite high. Unless the frame is total crap, which I don't think is the case, this set-up is a steal.

Thanks for the opinions. My thinking is that for all the quality components I get I can replace the frame in a couple of years if I need to.

I own a Fantom Cross Pro (2007 model) Very nice bike.
No you cannot mount disc brakes on it - no bosses for disc.
It has held up very well, though it does not get a lot of use. I put on 25c tires, lights, and use it on nice days for commuting.
my only beef was the bars seemed kinda narrow for a large 61cm frame.

By the way, the Bikes Direct frames are VERY nice. The Phantom Cross has a VERY stiff chassis, very nicely formed tubes. The chain & seatstays are essentially straight, no flex, but not the best heel clearance either. My toes naturally turn out some, so heels are a bit in while clipped in, and I occasionally brush the frame.

Make sure you order the right size! They do have a 30-day return policy, and you can call or email them about sizing if you are unsure.

It is a LOT of bike for the money...

Tip: Cycle Spectrum is part of the Bikes Direct empire. See if you have one close & try them out. They have the added advantage of free lifetime service if you buy there.

Cheers