Is commuting really as complicated as it seems?
#76
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 4,599
Likes: 158
From: Santa Fe, NM
Bikes: Vassago Moosknuckle Ti 29+ XTR, 90's Merckx Corsa-01 9sp Record, PROJECT: 1954 Frejus SuperCorsa
If you have the ability to shower near/at work, it can make life so much easier, especially in the Summer.
As others have mentioned, there is no secret handshake or hidden magic to commuting - just some common sense and a desire to do it. Welcome!
I tend to wear a variety of clothing - anything from running tops/shorts to old mountain bike shorts and mountaineering layers - all of which I just have anyway. I dispensed with my old "roadie" lycra gear because I no longer have the desire to wear it, though some prefer it. It is really wide open.
If I had limited funds, I'd prioritize safety lighting first, and a set of slick tires which will offer better ride quality and more efficiency for the distance you are riding.
Oh, and don't do anything to provoke Chipcom - once you've seen him in a dress, you will never be the same.
As others have mentioned, there is no secret handshake or hidden magic to commuting - just some common sense and a desire to do it. Welcome!
I tend to wear a variety of clothing - anything from running tops/shorts to old mountain bike shorts and mountaineering layers - all of which I just have anyway. I dispensed with my old "roadie" lycra gear because I no longer have the desire to wear it, though some prefer it. It is really wide open.
If I had limited funds, I'd prioritize safety lighting first, and a set of slick tires which will offer better ride quality and more efficiency for the distance you are riding.
Oh, and don't do anything to provoke Chipcom - once you've seen him in a dress, you will never be the same.
#77
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 9
Likes: 0
From: Midwest
Good luck. Not to be a downer, but as a non hard-core cyclist without dedicated gear already, I suspect that 13 miles on a mountain bike on busy roads in fall/winter on the east coast will be too much to handle for a new bike commuter. Not impossible, but I guarantee it will be difficult, unless you really, really enjoy being on your bike.
Thanks again for all of the encouragement - it's so easy to get swept up into thinking that you need more than you do (which creates opportunities to make excuses to never start). I'm going to keep reminding myself that this is good for my health and my wallet. And I will definitely keep reading to learn from all of you experienced riders.
#78
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 4,599
Likes: 158
From: Santa Fe, NM
Bikes: Vassago Moosknuckle Ti 29+ XTR, 90's Merckx Corsa-01 9sp Record, PROJECT: 1954 Frejus SuperCorsa
Here's a nice intro to cycling safety that is worth reading: https://bicyclesafe.com/
#79
That's a good point. While playing with google maps I was able to tweak the route a bit to include a bike path for about 5 miles of the route. That helps ease my traffic anxiety and the path is flat so it's less likely that I will exhaust myself too soon. The midwest has crazy weather sometimes but luckily we are heading into fall and I feel it's the perfect time to get started (even if it is just one way during the daylight hours... baby steps). I'm not so worried about rain as much as I worry about being cold (though I think I still have a little while before the bitter cold comes to Missouri... and by then I may have found a solution). One poster suggested finding wool sweaters at a thrift shop to wear - that's a great idea because I don't care so much about looking good as I do being comfortable.
Thanks again for all of the encouragement - it's so easy to get swept up into thinking that you need more than you do (which creates opportunities to make excuses to never start). I'm going to keep reminding myself that this is good for my health and my wallet. And I will definitely keep reading to learn from all of you experienced riders.
Thanks again for all of the encouragement - it's so easy to get swept up into thinking that you need more than you do (which creates opportunities to make excuses to never start). I'm going to keep reminding myself that this is good for my health and my wallet. And I will definitely keep reading to learn from all of you experienced riders.

I believe above is the best advice. You can always just walk your bike to the nearest LBS or call a friend if you have a problem. Get good tires and you won't get punctures. Play it safe is the big deal. Don't get over-confident. On a bicycle you are unlikely to get special treatment from cars, buses, trucks - stay clear of them.
#80
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 135
Likes: 0
From: Philadelphia
Weepingwillow, if you're worried about cold, then start to think now about your cold fingers/cold toes strategy. Wool socks from the thrift store on both hands and feet can suffice--but I'd get those NOW and carry them with you so you have them when you need them. (Cheap glove liners inside the wool socks can get you even further!) Later on you can figure out what precise type of glove/mitten/sock/bootie combination works for you. But there is nothing worse than frozen fingers and toes on your commute, and I find my fingers and toes get cold at temperatures when my core is quite comfortable. And it's always better to have to stop to take off extra clothing than try to warm up mid-ride, at least for the extremities. Also, speaking as a native midwesterner, check out hunting departments in stores like Meijers (not sure if they are in MO) or Kmart for inexpensive clothing options.
#81
Commuting by bike is as complicated as you make it to be. The level of complexity depends largely on your requirements for safety and comfort... and your needs for gadgetry and your fashion tastes
. The higher the requirements the higher the complexity. Take a fixie ninja biker: his/her commute is minimalistic because he/she doesn't care about safety and comfort. Take me with my dual horns, four waterproof panniers, several lights, reflective tape, dedicated commuter clothing and it's very complicated
But I like it!
A.
. The higher the requirements the higher the complexity. Take a fixie ninja biker: his/her commute is minimalistic because he/she doesn't care about safety and comfort. Take me with my dual horns, four waterproof panniers, several lights, reflective tape, dedicated commuter clothing and it's very complicated
But I like it!A.
#82
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,079
Likes: 1
From: Potashville
Bikes: Reynolds 531P road bike, Rocky Mountain Metropolis, Rocky Mountain Sherpa 10, Look 566
++1 on getting quality tires. When I started riding back in the 70s, tires were awful and flats were common. Now they are so much better.
13 miles is fairly long for a bike commute. I doubt you'll want to wear your office clothes - especially high heels - for that length of ride. Forget those picturesque images of Copenhagen or Amsterdam, those women are only riding 2 or 3 miles, at most. Inexpensive athletic clothing from TJ Max/Winners can work fine.
If possible, drive your intended routes very early in the morning before sunrise to see what sort of ambient lighting is about. If there are strong streetlights, you might be able to get away with those inexpensive clip-on LED lights. If not, you'll want to budget for something with at least 100 lumen output.
When the sun is low on the horizon, you'll need to think about whether oncoming motorists can see you with the sun in their eyes. Some sort of flashing light can make you more visible to them, or you can plan to ride earlier or later to avoid the problem.
Avoid cotton on damp days or if there's a strong probability of rain. I got hypothermia riding home in the rain in cotton pants and tee shirt once, years ago. Not fun. It loses all of it's insulating properties when it gets wet.
13 miles is fairly long for a bike commute. I doubt you'll want to wear your office clothes - especially high heels - for that length of ride. Forget those picturesque images of Copenhagen or Amsterdam, those women are only riding 2 or 3 miles, at most. Inexpensive athletic clothing from TJ Max/Winners can work fine.
If possible, drive your intended routes very early in the morning before sunrise to see what sort of ambient lighting is about. If there are strong streetlights, you might be able to get away with those inexpensive clip-on LED lights. If not, you'll want to budget for something with at least 100 lumen output.
When the sun is low on the horizon, you'll need to think about whether oncoming motorists can see you with the sun in their eyes. Some sort of flashing light can make you more visible to them, or you can plan to ride earlier or later to avoid the problem.
Avoid cotton on damp days or if there's a strong probability of rain. I got hypothermia riding home in the rain in cotton pants and tee shirt once, years ago. Not fun. It loses all of it's insulating properties when it gets wet.
#83
The Drive Side is Within


Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,344
Likes: 47
From: New Haven, CT, USA
Bikes: Road, Cargo, Tandem, Etc.
Amen, ditto, a mtb, 13 miles, busy roads, wow. Yeah, I am sure some of you man up and can do it but why torture yourself, at least get a quality machine that fits and put the correct tires on it and lights etc. For a mtb, get rid of the squishy, dangerous knobby tires and get it equipped with some decent street tires.
__________________
The bicycle, the bicycle surely, should always be the vehicle of novelists and poets. Christopher Morley
The bicycle, the bicycle surely, should always be the vehicle of novelists and poets. Christopher Morley
#84
Acts 2:38
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 500
Likes: 0
From: San Jose, CA
Bikes: '10 Marin Lucas Valley, '13 Scott Speedster 20
Some of this is from experience and some from necessity:
- If you're riding in the dark, make sure you can be seen and that you can see where you're going. Day-Glo safety vests are dirt cheap.
- Get reliable tires and learn how to change a flat BEFORE you get a flat OR make sure your cell phone is fully charged so you can be picked up.
- Target and WalMart carry all sorts of cheap non-bike specific workout clothing that will get you by until you can afford the overpriced stuff everyone else uses.
- Make sure the bike is tuned up so that it shifts and stops like it should.
- https://www.cyclistview.com/
- If you're riding in the dark, make sure you can be seen and that you can see where you're going. Day-Glo safety vests are dirt cheap.
- Get reliable tires and learn how to change a flat BEFORE you get a flat OR make sure your cell phone is fully charged so you can be picked up.

- Target and WalMart carry all sorts of cheap non-bike specific workout clothing that will get you by until you can afford the overpriced stuff everyone else uses.
- Make sure the bike is tuned up so that it shifts and stops like it should.
- https://www.cyclistview.com/
#85
Commuting by bike is as complicated as you make it to be.
You must find your own truth, Grasshopper.
#86
One of the things you will discover is that when you friends, family, and cow orkers will be stunned to discover that you are riding 13 miles a day and will feel concerned that you may not be safe, worry that you have suffered from an economic downturn or a dui, and will offer to give you rides.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
#88
One of the things you will discover is that when you friends, family, and cow orkers will be stunned to discover that you are riding 13 miles a day and will feel concerned that you may not be safe, worry that you have suffered from an economic downturn or a dui, and will offer to give you rides.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
Dont take it for granted, keep it as simple as you can and get the book, "Ride to Work."
#89
One of the things you will discover is that when you friends, family, and cow orkers will be stunned to discover that you are riding 13 miles a day and will feel concerned that you may not be safe, worry that you have suffered from an economic downturn or a dui, and will offer to give you rides.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
A few people will see you doing this and find inspiration and might just try it themselves.
Keep this up and that 13 mile ride will start to feel like a warm up and you might find yourself looking to ride longer and farther and people will be more amazed.
My long commute is 60 miles a day... it is often the best 4 hours of my day as much of it takes me through the countryside and I do look forward to seeing the city vanish into the distance behind me when I head out.
Sometimes I take the long way home and can turn my 100 km day into a 140 or 160 km day.
#90
I didn't get out yesterday, basically recovering from a stupid work week, today was nothing but cold drizzle. Went out anyway, learned it's time to get the next layer of Winter defenses in action, still enjoyed it.
#92
I scorn bike clothing! If you can't bike in jeans and a T-shirt, you're turning a commute into a hobby or a sport. If you want to do that, fine. But it's not necessary.
#93
Banned
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 8,701
Likes: 2,506
From: Mississauga/Toronto, Ontario canada
Bikes: I have 3 singlespeed/fixed gear bikes
I beg to differ. Jeans is just about the worst/most uncomfortable thing to wear when cycling any distance. I can't imagine riding in jeans when it's wet, cold, sleet, snow. In those conditions long cycling tights and a pair of shorts/knickers made of synthetic material will make your commute so much more pleasent. My commute is also part of my fitness training so in a way it is a sport to me.
#94
I beg to differ. Jeans is just about the worst/most uncomfortable thing to wear when cycling any distance. I can't imagine riding in jeans when it's wet, cold, sleet, snow. In those conditions long cycling tights and a pair of shorts/knickers made of synthetic material will make your commute so much more pleasent. My commute is also part of my fitness training so in a way it is a sport to me.
Sure the right tool for the job at hand is always best. But getting started in the best fashion you can is the key.
#95
I don't wear lycra shorts except for the hottest days in summer but I like bike specific clothing, or at least outdoor clothing, it's just more comfortable. I normally wear MTB shorts. I tried wearing regular shorts but some are just too uncomfortable: seams in the wrong places, stiff, etc. Sometimes I wear hiking shorts or beach shorts. And jeans in heat or rain are a torture. I don't even wear jeans shorts when walking in Summer.
In cold weather I wear warm, unpadded bike tights with the MTB shorts over them.
Normal clothing designed for slow walking doesn't work very well for cycling, even if it's just a 30 minute commute.
Perhaps if my bike riding was limited only to commuting I wouldn't buy any special clothing. Since I also ride longer rides on weekends and got into touring this year I need better clothing anyway. And a lot of it can be used for hiking as well.
In cold weather I wear warm, unpadded bike tights with the MTB shorts over them.
Normal clothing designed for slow walking doesn't work very well for cycling, even if it's just a 30 minute commute.
Perhaps if my bike riding was limited only to commuting I wouldn't buy any special clothing. Since I also ride longer rides on weekends and got into touring this year I need better clothing anyway. And a lot of it can be used for hiking as well.
#96
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 13,237
Likes: 75
From: Fallbrook,Calif./Palau del Vidre, France
Bikes: Klein QP, Fuji touring, Surly Cross Check, BCH City bike
Grow into it. Don't think you have to totally conquer all your bike needs in one swoop.. Yes, be sure you have all your needs taken care of such as maintenance issues and being ready on the road for any mechanical problems that might arise.. But, more than likely, if you keep your bike in good shape , you'll be ok. I agree with Chip's claim. Invest in a good lighting system.. And make your bike so that you'll be seen in low light conditions such as reflectivity. Other than that, you'll learn as to what your future needs will be and update your bike as needed..
. A concern you'll have to solve from the get -go. How much stuff do you need to carry. That will be something to chew over...
. A concern you'll have to solve from the get -go. How much stuff do you need to carry. That will be something to chew over...
__________________
Pray for the Dead and Fight like Hell for the Living

^ Since January 1, 2012
Pray for the Dead and Fight like Hell for the Living
^ Since January 1, 2012
#97
In my experience, synthetic clothing makes me sweat. Then it feels nasty and clingy and it stinks. Cotton breathes a lot better than any plastic material I've ever worn.
I think comfort is mainly in the mind - if you're convinced a material is going to be uncomfortable, it will be.
Last edited by ianbrettcooper; 09-20-10 at 05:56 AM.
#98
Senior Member

Joined: May 2007
Posts: 793
Likes: 0
From: Vancouver, Canada
Bikes: Brodie Force w/ Xtracycle, Dahon Helios, Merida Folding, Pacific Carryme, Softride Classic
If you have a cadence of 60 and below, normal, non-bike specific clothes are fine. If you tend to ride with a normal cadence of 80 and above, I find spandex\lycra more comfortable. I simply bought a pair of lycra leggings for $10 and wear those inside a pair of no name polyester shorts. My morning commute tends to be cooler this time of the year and the return ride home warmer. So I just wear the shorts on the way home. Neither of those are bike-specific (read: expensive) clothing. I did buy a pair of lycra\spandex arm warmers on sale for $18 at my local equipment store. These are very good for keeping the arms warm and getting more utility out of short sleeved garments yet providing the flexibility of removing them as the temperature changes.
The best thing one can do for regular commuting is to dress in layers so one can tailor their garments with the prevailing conditions. The more comfortable you are, the safer you are since you won't be as distracted especially in urban traffic.
The best thing one can do for regular commuting is to dress in layers so one can tailor their garments with the prevailing conditions. The more comfortable you are, the safer you are since you won't be as distracted especially in urban traffic.
#99
The drizzle wasn't as cold as I thought and riding in the rain can actually be an enjoyable experience... it reminds me of Portland, Seattle, and Vancouver and the people I love there who would not give this little spitting a second thought and ride anyway.
Used to hate the rain and said I would take our dry winter and extreme cold over cold and wet but that does not seem to be the case anymore.
Did some long rides this year and spent hours riding in the rain covering distances of 80-100km... it makes you appreciate the warmth you find when you get to your destination.
#100
Infamous Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 24,360
Likes: 6
From: Ohio
Bikes: Surly Big Dummy, Fuji World, 80ish Bianchi
__________________
"Let us hope our weapons are never needed --but do not forget what the common people knew when they demanded the Bill of Rights: An armed citizenry is the first defense, the best defense, and the final defense against tyranny. If guns are outlawed, only the government will have guns. Only the police, the secret police, the military, the hired servants of our rulers. Only the government -- and a few outlaws. I intend to be among the outlaws" - Edward Abbey
"Let us hope our weapons are never needed --but do not forget what the common people knew when they demanded the Bill of Rights: An armed citizenry is the first defense, the best defense, and the final defense against tyranny. If guns are outlawed, only the government will have guns. Only the police, the secret police, the military, the hired servants of our rulers. Only the government -- and a few outlaws. I intend to be among the outlaws" - Edward Abbey




