Then there is George Carlin's solution. " Stick a bay leaf under each armpit . It won't stop you from perspiring but you smell like SOUP."

I know I'm resurrecting a bit, but I just happened upon this thread.

I'm not crazy, but milk of magnesia is the greatest deodorant ever. I don't remember how I found out you could use it for that, but you can, I believe because it changes the skin's pH. I can go 48 hours without showering and no stink; 24 hours with exercise is no problem. I had already started using Crystal deodorant, which takes about a week for your body to adjust to, so I didn't have to get used to it. Not sure how it works cold turkey, and it didn't work for my wife as well. It must depend on your body's pH. Just put it on right after a shower or you clean your pits.

Okay, I'm late to the party, but I'll throw my 2c worth in too.

My wife was out of town for a few months (2 weeks would be enough), so I used that time to adjust my body to no shampoo and no soap. I do wash my hands with soap, but that's all.

You'll feel greasy for a few days, but it passes. It is supposedly better for your body, and you skin adjusts to not having the protective oils stripped every time you shower. So, I shower twice a day most days (once on days without a workout).

I'm clean and don't stink. My wife comes home tomorrow. I don't think she'll notice a difference.

I haven't used antiperspirant in over a decade, but I still used deodorant until recently. No more.

I've used precisely 2 kinds of deodorant my entire life. I used the spray on Right Guard until I was 18, and then switched to Speed Stick. I've been using that for the last 32 years. For the commuting duty I keep one at work. Wouldn't use anything else.

I had a friend try the 'no shampoo and deodorant' thing that's been so seemingly popular recently. She swore up and down that after a week she had 'normalized' and had never felt fresher. Of course, her hair was a good bit greasier than usual, and her smell had changed, not bad, but different.

I'm pretty sure the 'normalization period' is all about getting used to how your body feels without soap, shampoo or deodorant.

Women usually take longer than a week to normalize for shampoo because they do do much stuff to their hair with chemicals and stuff. Normalization is a real thing that does happen, and has nothing to do with getting used to stuff you normally find objectionable. It's all about the natural oils in your hair. Standard shampoo strips it with industrial cleaners. Your body works extra to replace it.

Many find that scalp and hair issues go down considerably without shampoo. Although I'm a guy with short hair, I am among those. I do use a Thai deodorant stone, which seems like it will last forever. it doesn't cake up or steak or anything. I might try going without some day. I think one's diet has something to do with how easy this is to do. I don't think I would be as successful if I ate like I used to.

Here's a blog about another guy who do it and received a lot of attention:
https://freetheanimal.com/2010/12/a-m...mpoo-free.html

Everyone says that, but nobody ever provides any evidence aside from anecdotes about how many compliments they get.

I'm analytically minded, and tend to favour a high standard of evidence. You can experiment for yourself pretty easily though, at least with deodorant. You do have two armpits that tend to sweat the same amount. Try two deodorants side by side and see what happens.

My own personal observations have led me to favour Mitchum; I've found it stops odor, keeps me reasonably dry and doesn't leave much in the way of residue. The deodorant stone was no better than the control, even after a week of 'normalization'.

I don't know how to do a comparable test for shampoo, but trust me, I'm working on it.

What kind of evidence are you looking for? Anecdotal is all your going to get obviously. I'm married, and my wife can't tell the difference in smell except there is no shampoo smell. People putting their nose in your head and taking a big whiff and comparing that to before is about all you can do. Same with skin. You are better able to smell your skin, but the same thing applies. Last time I took the shears to my hair I kept some to smell, and it is just no smelly smell at all. Likewise many, if not most, do encounter noticeable hair problems when first going shampooless, and it follows a pretty predictable problem of increased oil. The more product the one has been using, the more likely the problems will be extended.

There are other things like this as well. I used to use shaving cream when I shaved, but I always just shave dry now no problem. But when I first was doing it, it was a little more difficult/rough on my skin. (Like what is explained here: https://www.lewrockwell.com/tucker/tucker65.html)

Mitchum is what I used for years also, until I tried the deodorant stone. The Mitchum worked really well for me. I've been using the deodorant stone for some time now, and it has worked great. I didn't test it against anything, or nothing, but I was paranoid for weeks and kept smelling my pits, as well as my shirts. I'm now a believer, and I can't imagine when it will need replaced.

i get the rash too. i have narrowed it down to the aluminum ingredient that is part of the antiperspirant in most deodorant/antiperspirants out there on the market. i can use just deodorant sticks/gels without much problem, and i currently use Toms. however, i notice this only lasts half of the day, and i do stink when i exercise and ride hard. i think i am going to switch over to isopropyl and see how that works. do you use it once in the morning, or do you apply throughout the day? thanks, this has been very interesting and informative!

I think anything that isn't an antiperspirant has to be applied directly after a shower when bacteria has been cleaned off. Not sure about alcohol though, that also seems like it might be rough on the skin. I'm telling you though, magnesium hydroxide (er, milk of magnesia) is the best thing ever.

I often get rash from deodorants too. I've been using alcohol and Purell hand sanitizer on the armpits with great results for the last few months. I apply alcohol after the shower, before the ride and after I clean up after the ride. Then the hand sanitizer. Both kill bacteria effectively, it seems. I can actually get through the day reapplying the Purell stuff once or twice without using any deodorant. And no rash. Just don't apply any of those on warm skin right after shower, let it cool of or it may itch.

I've used UARMSOL deodorant for many years now, it's a fine powder deodorant i carry it in small jar and I have had no problems with it. Now I have no more armpit odours. Even when I sweat I don't have any odours, this deodorant works great and I'm loving it. I can't go out in the day without putting it on. I used to have very funky like cockroach smell, now no more. Even when I sweat my armpits don't have any smell. I applied 1 pinch and it's all to it for the whole day without worries about any smell afterwards, or any mess of stickiness. There's no after sport smell or odour masking. I would recommend it to anyone who has underarm odour.

+1 more for alcohol

I use it on my whole body when I get to work. I would imagine that hand sanitizer would work well too.

With the deodorant powder I don't need to apply anything extra. Since I have very hairy armpit, the powder works even better ! No need to waste money on anything else.

I got lucky right off with the deodorant crystal you find in stores like Whole Foods. It's in a typical roll-on container and works fine for me. I tried a few of the so-called natural ones like Tom's and Jason, but they left me stinky too soon (before the end of a workday--yike). I'd like to try going at least without shampoo in the future.

It's a deodorant powder by dermacop, uarmsol works the best without clogging or preventing sweating, no odour masking and no chemicals.

Apparently, if people sweat that bad, you clamp your T4 or T5 nerve (this has to be done by a surgeon, just in case someone thought about getting their bulldog clips out!) but you can stop sweating under your armpits. Save son buying deodarant! Link Here

Every person I have met who says "I just don't need deodorant," really, really did.

With my wife's prompting, I started using a deodorant crystal (bare crystal at home, roll-on style for travel) and it's worked great. No shirt stains that I can see, no extra gunk like those gel antiperspirants. You wouldn't even know it was there if it weren't for the lack of smell.

I actually dumped all deodorants. I haven't used any in many months. Purell Hand Sanitizer is the best damn deodorant on this side of the Milky Way. Works a whole lot better than any deodorant I ever used before. I reapply once a day.

Cool, a zombie thread.

I've used the Crystal Stick for many years and really like it. The stick itself lasts a long time, too.

I use the rollers and make sure to switch them periodically. Call me crazy, but if I use the same time for too long I swear it loses effectiveness. An added benefit, other than them working well is that they are both small and light. Small enough in fact, to go in a saddle bag for example.

Resurrected by a Dermacop™ shill, no less.

Zombie thread just made me spend $8 on Amazon for a deodorant rock, lol. We will see how it works...