40 mile one-way commute - Is it doable
#27
Thread Starter
Member
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 30
Likes: 0
From: Murfreesboro, TN
Bikes: 1996 Litespeed Ultimate
This, I think, will be where my grand plan will break down. If I leave work at 4:30, I will get home just before 8:00. That leave me an hour to cook, clean, and keep my girl happy before I need to go to bed to wake up for the next ride. One-way does seem much more doable, but we'll see.
#28
Senior Member
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 8,896
Likes: 7
From: Raleigh, NC
Bikes: Waterford RST-22, Bob Jackson World Tour, Ritchey Breakaway Cross, Soma Saga, De Bernardi SL, Specialized Sequoia
Try it and see how it works out for you. A lot depends on your fitness and toughness. I commute about 4 days/week 22 miles round trip, and it takes a lot of perseverance to ride many days. Assuming you have the fitness and mental toughness, I would think you would need:
- A relatively light, fast road bike so you can maintain the highest average speed that is sustainable. If you can average 16 mph (which could be tough commuting), that's still 5 hours or riding each day.
- A top-notch lighting system, front and rear. Riding 5+ hours a day will require that you have reliable lights capable of holding a long charge. They also need to be bright since you would need to commute a lot in the dark.
As others mentioned, a more doable way to commute at that distance would be combine cycling with mass transit, car-pooling or driving on some days. The thing about bike commuting that if often underestimated is the wear-and-tear it puts on your body riding day after day. I'm probably a lot older than you (57), but have found that I need to ride at an easier pace commuting than I do for most rec rides or I just wear myself down.
- A relatively light, fast road bike so you can maintain the highest average speed that is sustainable. If you can average 16 mph (which could be tough commuting), that's still 5 hours or riding each day.
- A top-notch lighting system, front and rear. Riding 5+ hours a day will require that you have reliable lights capable of holding a long charge. They also need to be bright since you would need to commute a lot in the dark.
As others mentioned, a more doable way to commute at that distance would be combine cycling with mass transit, car-pooling or driving on some days. The thing about bike commuting that if often underestimated is the wear-and-tear it puts on your body riding day after day. I'm probably a lot older than you (57), but have found that I need to ride at an easier pace commuting than I do for most rec rides or I just wear myself down.
#29
Because I thought I could
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 969
Likes: 0
From: Wash DC Metro
Bikes: November, Trek OCLV, Bianchi Castro Valley commuter
...I also have decent (not great) lights, so I appreciate the advice on getting better ones. One of the primary reasons for not driving is to save on gas, so I don't want to drop $150 on a set of really expensive ones. What I have are a pair of knock-off tactical flashlights with bike mounts. They are each brighter than my 1-watt cateye that was $40 even though they cost like $10 for the pair. They are the best "see" lights I've ever had, but still may not be adaquate for a country road at 4am. I might order a set of the non-knock-offs to add more lumens but still split the difference between cycling-specific lights.
I am mot curious about the idea that this will have zero training benefit. I appreciate the idea that I might not want to ride on the weekends, but frankly, most weekends I ride about 40-50 miles once or twice, so if I am doing that up to six times a week I am really improving my milage. Also, while there will be about 10 miles each way that are city, "junk" miles, 30 each way are on about the same kind of roads I ride when I train anyways. Does this change your assessment, or is it mostly due to riding while waking up and being more focused on getting from point A to B than on a good training ride?
I am mot curious about the idea that this will have zero training benefit. I appreciate the idea that I might not want to ride on the weekends, but frankly, most weekends I ride about 40-50 miles once or twice, so if I am doing that up to six times a week I am really improving my milage. Also, while there will be about 10 miles each way that are city, "junk" miles, 30 each way are on about the same kind of roads I ride when I train anyways. Does this change your assessment, or is it mostly due to riding while waking up and being more focused on getting from point A to B than on a good training ride?
And plan on increased physical and mental wear and tear. I am about tarwheel's age and although I've been a year-round 4K miles commuter and rec rider, I've definitely felt the jump from 8-10 miles to 24-25 daily, and take it easy (which for my distance doesn't add that much time) when I need it.
I use my road bike on some commutes (12 mi each way) and what I've found useful: trigeek behind seat bottle carrier; I use one (modified) to hold my 24oz Nissan Thermos coffee thermos. Profile Design aerobar computer/light mount and a spare handlebar mount (Dinnotte 600L) so I can easily move my big headlight between bikes. Crudbuster clip on fenders (UK, check ProBikeKit and the other UK vendors and, yes, they fit 23mm tires) to keep muck off me and the drivetrain when the no-rain-until-evening forecast is off. Debating replacing the backpack with a (shudder) seatpost rack and trunk bag or small panniers.
I think a long commute is great for sub-FTP "sweet spot" training. I try to go at 90-95% FTP for 10-15 minutes and use traffic lights (I have 2-3 long ones each way) for recovery. May start doing sets of shorter harder intervals on the way home some days if I think I won't be too busy that evening. Good luck!
Last edited by ks1g; 03-28-11 at 10:36 AM. Reason: spelling, add comment on rest and recovery
#30
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 2,299
Likes: 16
One more thing, be prepared to be hungry at work. Not just a little hungry. The kind of hunger that makes you eat a second breakfast when you get in and yearn for lunch by 10am, then a second lunch by 2pm. 80 miles/day will require an extra 2000+ calories. On day one, you'll probably have that in reserve so it'll be no big deal, but by your second week, you'll be foraging all the time.
#31
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 4,599
Likes: 158
From: Santa Fe, NM
Bikes: Vassago Moosknuckle Ti 29+ XTR, 90's Merckx Corsa-01 9sp Record, PROJECT: 1954 Frejus SuperCorsa
Yeah, the distance is not a problem in general, but doing it at 4am might be. And I can take the bus in to the city and ride it home so I only do it on direction while I get used to the increase in mileage.
Are there any specific concerns about riding in pre-dawn dark? I have decent lights, planning on getting more, but do you find that people are less aware of you? More/less cautious? etc.
Are there any specific concerns about riding in pre-dawn dark? I have decent lights, planning on getting more, but do you find that people are less aware of you? More/less cautious? etc.
A good headlight that allows you to see the road clearly for some distance is also a good thing to have, particularly for a ride of that length.
It is easy to "zone out" and get into a trance-like state, especially in the morning, riding through the tunnel of light. Having good forward visibility with good illumination helps avoid the tunnel syndrome.
I'd say the commute is doable as you state, but definitely a challenge.
Last edited by canyoneagle; 03-28-11 at 11:10 AM.
#32
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 4,144
Likes: 3
From: Burnaby, BC
One more thing, be prepared to be hungry at work. Not just a little hungry. The kind of hunger that makes you eat a second breakfast when you get in and yearn for lunch by 10am, then a second lunch by 2pm. 80 miles/day will require an extra 2000+ calories. On day one, you'll probably have that in reserve so it'll be no big deal, but by your second week, you'll be foraging all the time.
#34
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 5,720
Likes: 111
From: North of Boston
Bikes: Kona Dawg, Surly 1x1, Karate Monkey, Rockhopper, Crosscheck , Burley Runabout,
My ride is 18 miles one way. I make 2 -6 trips per week. I leave my car at the office and pedal home, and then ride back to work in the AM. Might want to try that way first.
#35
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 2,053
Likes: 0
From: Alexandria, VA
Bikes: Trek 830 Mountain Track Drop bar conversion
Circumstances are what they are, I guess, and different strokes for different folks and all that, but I would never live 40 miles from work. Good luck to the OP working something out, though.
#36
#37
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 6,431
Likes: 44
From: Minneapolis, MN
This, I think, will be where my grand plan will break down. If I leave work at 4:30, I will get home just before 8:00. That leave me an hour to cook, clean, and keep my girl happy before I need to go to bed to wake up for the next ride. One-way does seem much more doable, but we'll see.
#39
The best time of year for me is when I get up at dawn and start my commute to the frame shop... after I ride the 10km it takes to get out of the city I have another 40km of wide open roads and fresh air and if I don't stop for coffee at the midpoint can do this in under 2 hours.
From home to the midpoint is a net climb and the last 25km drops me back down very gradually while the ride home is just the opposite... when I hit the 25 km mark I am usually tired of what seems like an endless climb and can look down on my city and can really pick up the pace if I want to... can often maintain speeds close to 40kmh over that home stretch as it's a steeper grade.
Sometimes I sleep over if I end up working really late but on many weeks I will ride home and can only think that other people might spend an hour driving home in their car and spend a few hours glued to the television or hitting the gym to stay fit while I spend a few hours riding home.
I try and knock down a metric or century on the weekends so might ride as much as 700km in a week which gets me in great shape for touring.
From home to the midpoint is a net climb and the last 25km drops me back down very gradually while the ride home is just the opposite... when I hit the 25 km mark I am usually tired of what seems like an endless climb and can look down on my city and can really pick up the pace if I want to... can often maintain speeds close to 40kmh over that home stretch as it's a steeper grade.
Sometimes I sleep over if I end up working really late but on many weeks I will ride home and can only think that other people might spend an hour driving home in their car and spend a few hours glued to the television or hitting the gym to stay fit while I spend a few hours riding home.
I try and knock down a metric or century on the weekends so might ride as much as 700km in a week which gets me in great shape for touring.
#40
I used to commute 17 miles each way. But I found myself wanting more time for life.
__________________
"He who serves all, best serves himself" Jack London
#41
curmudgineer
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 4,417
Likes: 113
From: Chicago SW burbs
Bikes: 2 many 2 fit here
Time spent bike commuting is not a total loss of time. A) you need to spend time exercising anyway B) you need to spend time getting to and from work anyway C) some of us (maybe just I?) have at-home activities we like to do during the weekend and/or don't have a big yen for major leisure cycle outings, at any rate.
#42
aka: Mike J.
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 3,405
Likes: 60
From: between Milwaukee and Sheboygan in Wisconsin
Bikes: 1995 Trek 520 is the current primary bike.
I'll vote for the Park'n'Pedal option. I've got a 43 mile each way commute currently and have been looking at options. I've got two Park'n'Ride lots within 15-18 miles from work so I'll probably pick the one with the nicer route.
Also keep an eye open for symptoms of over-training, exhaustion, crankiness due to fatigue. Would be a shame to loose your job due to a side effect of over-training.
Also, if you do crank out the whole distance, keep track of your hydration, especially once the warm weather hits.
And road hazards include critters which are especially active in the pre-dawn hours.
Have fun, be safe, and post some commute reports along the way.
Also keep an eye open for symptoms of over-training, exhaustion, crankiness due to fatigue. Would be a shame to loose your job due to a side effect of over-training.
Also, if you do crank out the whole distance, keep track of your hydration, especially once the warm weather hits.
And road hazards include critters which are especially active in the pre-dawn hours.
Have fun, be safe, and post some commute reports along the way.
#43
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 6,431
Likes: 44
From: Minneapolis, MN
Time spent bike commuting is not a total loss of time. A) you need to spend time exercising anyway B) you need to spend time getting to and from work anyway C) some of us (maybe just I?) have at-home activities we like to do during the weekend and/or don't have a big yen for major leisure cycle outings, at any rate.
#44
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 255
Likes: 1
From: Northeastern USA
Bikes: 2007 Bianchi Castro Valley, 1985 Specialized Sequoia
I have an 18 mile commute each way. I only do it 5 days a week during the nicest weather and when feeling the looniest (or when the car is at the shop). I used to have a buddy with a pickup truck who would drive me in, and I'd ride home -- that was the best. I didn't find weather or fatigue to be the biggest issues, but I don't commute year-round.
The biggest issue I find is lighting the road at 5:15 a.m. when the sunrise isn't until 6-something a.m. Also, my cycling budget is small (my wife thinks it's huge, but she has no idea the crazy gear I covet) so I've never bought the $200 lights that light up the road. I run a dynohub lighting setup which isn't super-bright but does have the advantage of no batteries. Peter White is the best web resource for that stuff. But I'd recommend a headlamp, especially to spot the bravest critters that may cross your path in the pitch dark. Plus a headlamp is an extra light placed nice and high up to be seen, and is very useful for changing flats or doing emergency repairs in the pitch black.
40 miles seems like an awful lot, though. However, when I do ride in in the morning I often feel more alert and refreshed for my work day. My workday starts at 7:15, ends at 3:00-4:00 depending. For me the ideal commute would be 10 miles, give or take a coupe of miles here or there... all downhill (both ways). I can dream, can't I?
The biggest issue I find is lighting the road at 5:15 a.m. when the sunrise isn't until 6-something a.m. Also, my cycling budget is small (my wife thinks it's huge, but she has no idea the crazy gear I covet) so I've never bought the $200 lights that light up the road. I run a dynohub lighting setup which isn't super-bright but does have the advantage of no batteries. Peter White is the best web resource for that stuff. But I'd recommend a headlamp, especially to spot the bravest critters that may cross your path in the pitch dark. Plus a headlamp is an extra light placed nice and high up to be seen, and is very useful for changing flats or doing emergency repairs in the pitch black.
40 miles seems like an awful lot, though. However, when I do ride in in the morning I often feel more alert and refreshed for my work day. My workday starts at 7:15, ends at 3:00-4:00 depending. For me the ideal commute would be 10 miles, give or take a coupe of miles here or there... all downhill (both ways). I can dream, can't I?
#45
Well, he's talking about 3 days per week, weather-permitting. So, his car commute is an hour or so, let's say, that's 5 days X 2 hrs = 10 hours-commute-per-week.
Changing 3 days to bike would be 3 days X 6 hours + 2 x 2 = 20 HCPW.
Wow, that does sounds like a lot. Probably better option is to switch on/off by week .. i.e. 2 days one week, 3 days the next .. or something like that. Best of luck, hope it works out!
#46
Senior Member

Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 12,948
Likes: 9
From: England
I think a 2x40 miler is too much to do every day. Think about doing a bus/car and bike combo most days and a full run once or twice a week.
A Ti Lightspeed sounds good, consider fitting aerobars and a saddlebag for self-sufficiency.
You need to double up on lights, esp in case your batteries run dry.
A Ti Lightspeed sounds good, consider fitting aerobars and a saddlebag for self-sufficiency.
You need to double up on lights, esp in case your batteries run dry.
#47
Yeah, the distance is not a problem in general, but doing it at 4am might be. And I can take the bus in to the city and ride it home so I only do it on direction while I get used to the increase in mileage.
Are there any specific concerns about riding in pre-dawn dark? I have decent lights, planning on getting more, but do you find that people are less aware of you? More/less cautious? etc.
Are there any specific concerns about riding in pre-dawn dark? I have decent lights, planning on getting more, but do you find that people are less aware of you? More/less cautious? etc.
#48
How much mileage can you subtract by a bus ride? Are all your city busses outfitted with bike racks like here in Jax, fl? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDlP3YPiCik
#49
It sounds pretty ambitious to me. But then some others have made it work, so maybe it's possible for you.
I think I would explore the possibility of driving part way by car and unloading the bike for the rest of the trip. Maybe you could gradually extend the distance of each bicycle portion until you find either that you don't need the car anymore or where best to make the switch. This gives you better options for when the weather turns ugly, too. I ride everyday no matter what, but only 1/4 of what you are contemplating. Don't know if I could tough out 4 times as long in some of the conditions I've experienced.
And be sure to post your mileage in the mileage tread if you decide to do it.
I think I would explore the possibility of driving part way by car and unloading the bike for the rest of the trip. Maybe you could gradually extend the distance of each bicycle portion until you find either that you don't need the car anymore or where best to make the switch. This gives you better options for when the weather turns ugly, too. I ride everyday no matter what, but only 1/4 of what you are contemplating. Don't know if I could tough out 4 times as long in some of the conditions I've experienced.
And be sure to post your mileage in the mileage tread if you decide to do it.
#50
Senior Member


Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 6,916
Likes: 1,260
I'm with the naysayers. The kind of individual who can manage an 80 mile round trip 3x/wk doesn't post to BF asking about it. S/he does it and posts here to tell us how it's done. No harm in trying, however. If you think it will take 3 hours though I would allow 3.5. Four would even be better at first. If you owned a business I'd say you had a shot at something but... intern in city government? You will either be an ex-intern and budding junior cyclocross champion or a sorer but wiser bike/car/mass transit advocate on the way up the career ladder in city government.
H
H



