Now I'm confused, is the NYPD against us or for us

Don't kid yourself. That had nothing to do with being "for" cyclists and everything to do with abuse of power. That was ridiculous.

I feel so dirty after watching this. I have to take a shower now and wash my eyes with rubbing alcohol.

What the hell. This will probably get moved to P&R? Freedom of speech must not mean much anymore.

Also, you're not required to show ID upon request unless you've broken a law (this might be dependent on state law.)

I'm surprised they didn't go up into the building and arrest the guy doing the filming. Didn't NY (and a buncha other states) pass laws against filming the police while they're on duty?

That was one of the funniest videos I've seen in a long time. I feel bad for that guy getting arrested since all he made was a joke, but everything that was said was cracking me up... Great vid

The video guy was a fool for announcing his presence.
Generally, cops misuse anti-wiretapping laws to punish people for filming them.

Yep. It's covered under an old Wiretapping law. Cops are pathetic now adays. The real charge should be "Embarassing an officer"

+ one-half. I actually did take a shower after watching this vid, but I'm passing on the rubbing alcohol.

They should have arrested him for not turning his phone sideways and making me watch it in elevator-vision.

Made me sick to my stomach. Had a similar situation in my youth where a beat cop tried to confiscate my bike. Abuse of power is right on the money.

That being said the pedestrian w/t comments should've just kept on walking w/o saying a word to the cyclist. Cyclist had been stopped by the cops. He and they were in conversation and pedestrian dude kept interrupting to get in the last dig. That distracted the situation and he was interferring w/a legal process as ridiculous as it all looks. The cop was correct in going after the guy to isssue a summons. The mistake the guy made was continuing to talk to the cop as if he had the upper hand. He pricked the guys ego and at that point the cop wasn't going to let him just walk away w/o a ticket.

When dealing w/law enforcement people it's always best to surrender completely and give them total control. Their training is to never allow an 'actor' to assume power in a given situation. That's why they make people sit down or lay on their stomachs, etc. The sad thing is the Ped may have squawked himself into a resisting arrest charge too as he failed to give the cop his ID at first.

That confrontation could've blown up into a full-scale riot very easily and demonstrates the heightened contention that exists between normally lawfull citizens and the PD in Anytown, USA.

That is incorrect.

In any state, you must show ID to any officer that requests it. Failure to do so is a crime.

I've seen several people get arrested for failure to show ID.

The bottom line is if you act like an ass, like this guy did, you are going to get some negative attention. He should have minded his own business and not continually interrupted the officer/cyclist conversation.

my understanding of the most recent supreme court ruling is that you must identify yourself, but there is no requirement to produce ID. As a practical matter, I'm not sure that's enough to keep you out of jail though.

If a cop wants you to go to jail, the only thing that will stop him is if you're a cop too.

How do you identify yourself without producing ID? I guess they could run your name, DOB, DL# and/or SSN through the computer to verify, but if not you could say you're anybody.

I've heard of people being taken to the station to be fingerprinted to verify identity before they were let go.

Trust me. Being a cop won't stop you from going to jail. It usually makes matters worse. I know of a few guys who tried flashing their badge to get out of things, only to find themselves in deeper **** than when they started.

So the guy makes a joke to the cyclist being stopped and the cops don't like it. The cyclist didn't get all bent out of shape and even joked back, but the cop gets upset?

From there it was both hysterical and sad at the same time. I would love to know how things play out.

Nice job correcting someone with false information.

As either a class B or C misdemeanor or a lower level offense in most areas, failure to identify to a police officer can occur with two different distinctions. The first includes refusing to provide your name, address or other requested information when you have been lawfully arrested or detained, or when a police officer has reason to believe you may be a witness to any type of criminal offense. The second distinction includes the same circumstances but it is more specific to if you provide the wrong personal information to an officer.

Yep, that's what they do if you don't have ID. One day I was walking from the convenience store to my apartment across the street. A cop stopped me in the parking lot. Wanted my ID. Claimed he was looking for someone who looked like me. He offered me a trip to police HQ if I didn't have an ID.

After he ran the ID, he owed that he was looking for someone who was shorter, hairier, stockier and younger than me.

Isn't ego a wonderful thing?

my wife and I watched this a few times, and we are still amazed by the behavior of everyone. I don't think AZ cops are any different, but I can't fault them. I am entertained that the bicyclist just sat there patiently while he was ignored the whole time. I suppose that goes to show that you should never be in a hurry when cops are involved

Welcome to New York, New York. Spent alot of time on Manhattan as I've relatives there. This is pretty standard behavior in the neighborhoods. Someone gets a ticket and it turns into a block party.

Guess he should have kept his mouth shut.

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

Guess what "identification" is.

"Riding on the sidewalk? Man, you a grown man. Don't you know that's against the law?

That's comedy gold, right there.