Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Anyone use a Flag or side projecting flag/reflector? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/821203-anyone-use-flag-side-projecting-flag-reflector.html)

Easy Peasy 05-27-12 10:36 PM

Anyone use a Flag or side projecting flag/reflector?
 
I see them on kids' bikes, carriers, utility bikes, but never on commuters. Reasons against using them?

SwampDude 05-27-12 11:00 PM

I only see them now on recumbents and trailers with kids on board. Common sense tells me the flags are a good idea for safety in traffic and in hilly terrain. But, they are not cool. So, if you're thinkin' about it, don't go there. You will be snickered off the street.

chefisaac 05-28-12 04:44 AM

hell about looking "cool" when commuting. It is all about survival. Big difference with commuting on weekend warriors and nice weather riders is that it is about survival when commuting, period!

AdamDZ 05-28-12 06:01 AM

I use a flag when pulling a trailer. And if I carry something large on my bike I have safety triangles that I mount as far to the sides as possible. One reason I don't like flags on my bike is that I forget and throw my leg around and knock the flags off.

Fargo Wolf 05-28-12 06:48 AM

I used to use a flag on my bike. The kids 6' kind. Worked like a hot damn too. My Dad on the other hand, had a different opinion and said flag disappeared when I stored it in the shed when i wasn't using it. :notamused:

Easy Peasy 05-28-12 12:21 PM

I guess you could angle the flag towards the back. That will lose height, but still get the attention of the driver behind.

Papa Tom 05-28-12 12:33 PM

I've never seen the flags you are describing, but I've thought about carrying one on my crossbar to whip out when I'm skirting a blind corner. I figured it might help a driver see me a few seconds earlier as he comes whipping around a curve with no expectation of a cyclist being on the road. Is the side-projecting flag you described one that mounts to the bike somewhere?

chaadster 05-28-12 02:04 PM


Originally Posted by Papa Tom (Post 14281756)
I've never seen the flags you are describing, but I've thought about carrying one on my crossbar to whip out when I'm skirting a blind corner. I figured it might help a driver see me a few seconds earlier as he comes whipping around a curve with no expectation of a cyclist being on the road. Is the side-projecting flag you described one that mounts to the bike somewhere?

http://urbanvelo.org/wordpress/wp-co...safetywing.jpg

Papa Tom 05-28-12 02:47 PM

Wow! That IS geeky, but I think it's awesome. I think a flag higher up on the bike would be more effective, though.

SwampDude 05-28-12 03:08 PM

The flag I used had a plastic mast about 5' tall. It fit into a bracket attached to the chainstay. The bracket made it easy to remove the flag for getting through my garage door, and to mount it for the next ride. The flag itself was safety orange, so it was highly visible. I think city traffic commuters would want something like this for an extra measure of safety. I received a lot of interesting remarks about the "funny" flag when I was flying one.

ckaspar 05-28-12 03:25 PM

Don't we look crazy enough on our bikes with our helmets and our high vis attire? Now you want to add a flag sticking off your bike? Lol

I only use one when I am towing my kid on her trail a bike. Never on the street. Just at the park and what not.

jsdavis 05-28-12 03:48 PM


Originally Posted by chaadster (Post 14282078)

IMO the best part of this is that it shows exactly how wide the vehicle is. From behind, a bicycle looks a lot narrower than it actually is especially if you have some wide bars. The bars on my commuter are around 650mm.

jsdavis 05-28-12 03:49 PM


Originally Posted by ckaspar (Post 14282337)
Don't we look crazy enough on our bikes with our helmets and our high vis attire? Now you want to add a flag sticking off your bike? Lol

I only use one when I am towing my kid on her trail a bike. Never on the street. Just at the park and what not.

No one is mandating helmets and hi-viz gear. You don't like it, don't wear it. For others, it gives them enough comfort to go out there and ride which is what matters.

GaryinLA 05-28-12 04:28 PM

Where can i buy that?

SwampDude 05-28-12 04:54 PM


Originally Posted by GaryinLA (Post 14282547)
Where can i buy that?

I think any full service bike shop or on- line retailer will stock the side clearance reflector and the tall flag.

xtrajack 05-28-12 05:42 PM

I use a flag on my bike. I have heard good things about it from family members who have seen me on the road.
I would rock a fllash flag (a side mount flag) if I could find one.

Easy Peasy 05-28-12 07:16 PM

Where did you buy that side mounted reflector/flag? Thanks.

Papa Tom 05-28-12 07:28 PM

But what if you just narrowly miss hitting a squirrel or a kitten while you're riding and then the danged flag rips its poor little ears off?

Seriously, though. At that low height, it seems like it might be a magnet for fallen tree branches or even shrubbery jutting out into the path.

chaadster 05-28-12 10:00 PM


Originally Posted by GaryinLA (Post 14282547)
Where can i buy that?

It's commonly called a "safety wing reflector," and it folds back and in upon obstacles; it is not fixed in the extended position. See:

http://www.amazon.com/CRSWING-Safety.../dp/B003E6L2SQ

chaadster 05-28-12 10:04 PM


Originally Posted by Papa Tom (Post 14283237)
But what if you just narrowly miss hitting a squirrel or a kitten while you're riding and then the danged flag rips its poor little ears off?

Seriously, though. At that low height, it seems like it might be a magnet for fallen tree branches or even shrubbery jutting out into the path.

http://www.cantitoeroad.com/image/pr...ety_wing_2.jpg

zonatandem 05-28-12 10:14 PM

Back in 1978 used an fluorescent orange flag on 5 ft fiberglass mast on rear of our tandem.
Got hit head-on by a kid driving car solo for the first time making a left turn at a stop street.
He stopped and drove straight into us. Claimed he did not see us.
Hospital visit and $2,200 worth of damage to our custom tandem.
Yes, he got a citation.

ckaspar 05-28-12 10:15 PM


Originally Posted by jsdavis (Post 14282424)
No one is mandating helmets and hi-viz gear. You don't like it, don't wear it. For others, it gives them enough comfort to go out there and ride which is what matters.

I was just fooling'

Easy Peasy 05-29-12 04:50 PM

Thanks for the info and link Chaadster.
I typically carry panniers off my rack, so I'll have to figure out where to mount it.

Easy Peasy 05-29-12 09:36 PM

I have these panniers on all the time, each with a reflective white patch. The safety wing reflector would extend past the left pannier, but do you think it would add much?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...b/IMG_1897.jpg

rumrunn6 05-30-12 10:56 AM

I started with a flag and had many good arguements for them but then when I got strobes I was satisfied that Ino longer needed the flag. aside from the typical rear rack strobe I also have one on my left drop bar.

Fargo Wolf 05-30-12 04:23 PM


Originally Posted by rumrunn6 (Post 14290058)
I started with a flag and had many good arguements for them but then when I got strobes I was satisfied that Ino longer needed the flag. aside from the typical rear rack strobe I also have one on my left drop bar.

The flag helps in heavy, traffic I've found. With it, drivers actually gave me one full lane when they passed. I need to get another one.

Giro 05-31-12 09:01 PM

Two other commercial products: Flash Flag and The Whizzzz Windmill Bicycle Reflector
 
3 Attachment(s)
There are two other commercially available products in North America, the Flash Flag and The Whizzzz Windmill Bicycle Reflector. Both can be folded flat against the bike when you do not want them extended.

I've used the Flash Flag and although the vendor unfortunately has medical problems at present, he is continuing to sell the Flash Flag:
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=253536
The flag is also reflective for night riding and wraps around the flagpole, permitting it to spin 360 degrees, completely around the flagpole. The compression spring connection at the base results in the entire flagpole oscillating about while you bike, perhaps attracting attention The spring also allows you to use the hook on the flagpole to clip it out of the way when you do not want to use it. One time the oscillations resulted in my flagpole working itself off the spring, so I'd check the connection or add some tape or a screw to secure the flagpole to the spring.

The Whizzzz Windmill Bicycle Reflector is available through Amazon and maybe elsewhere. I have not used it, but the spinning reflector might be conspicuous at night:
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=253540 And if one isn't enough, mount three of them^. http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=253541

These type of flags are termed lateral or horizontal flags or spacer bars in the bicycling literature. In Swedish, varselpinne or stingpinne LINK (http://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varselpinne).

syciprider 06-01-12 12:21 AM

Not for me thanks

Ray R 06-01-12 11:01 AM


Originally Posted by chaadster (Post 14283725)
It's commonly called a "safety wing reflector," and it folds back and in upon obstacles; it is not fixed in the extended position. See:

http://www.amazon.com/CRSWING-Safety.../dp/B003E6L2SQ

I've been using these for 20 years, bought mine in Europe. "Abstandshalter" auf deutsch. Good to know they're available in the U.S. now.

mechanicalron 06-01-12 09:42 PM

I use bottle rockets and water wings!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:27 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.