Thoughts on Fitness Trackers
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 2
From: Canada
Bikes: Maxim, Rocky Mountain, Argon 18, Cervelo S2 Team
Thoughts on Fitness Trackers
Been using a FIT bit last while just for general non cycling fitness. as i like to track my steps and sleep when not biking and not have to put on a strap when just doing every day stuff. Just recently. my Fitbit stopped working, this is 3rd time. thinking of getting a different brand.
what would be the best one to get? and reliable etc?
I am thinking the Garmin Vivofit as it can connect with my Garmin Connect etc.
looking for one that tracks sleep, general HRT, steps for sure.
All recommendations open. thanks
what would be the best one to get? and reliable etc?
I am thinking the Garmin Vivofit as it can connect with my Garmin Connect etc.
looking for one that tracks sleep, general HRT, steps for sure.
All recommendations open. thanks
#3
Full Member

Joined: May 2015
Posts: 277
Likes: 281
I know you didn't ask a general question but I'll offer a general answer. Unless you're training for the Tour de France and want equipment to monitor your training, I don't think there's much difference between fitness trackers. All of the possibilities in $100-$300 price range are imprecise, particularly with regard to HR monitoring. I would just focus on the features you want and find one that offers the most for the $$$.
#5
I bike, hike and walk and find the fitbit one to be an excellent activity tracker. I've not done much sleep tracking, mostly because the best tracking requires wearing the device on your wrist and that won't work with my sleep positions.
I have a HRM strap that I use with my Garmin 520. Fitness trackers are generally pretty bad at tracking heart rate.
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
From: Latham NY
Bikes: 03 Marin Bear Valley, 1999 GT ZR2000, Raleigh M80(converted to single speed), 2017 Masi Gran Corsa disc.
Stay away from the Samsung Gear Fit 2. I have one, and using it as a connected device, counting steps is fine. But as far fitness tracking it sucks. It has an "auto detect workout" feature. I have been on my lawnmower drinking a beer and it will detect bicycling. I have been on 40 mile bike rides and it never detected the ride. I was also using it when I first started riding my trainer last winter. It would tell me that I was at my resting HR for 30-35 minutes of the ride, then out of nowhere it would start tracking my actual HR. I have tried to live with it and deal with the issues. But now I mainly use it as a connected device for my phone.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
squirtdad
Training & Nutrition
7
02-08-17 06:31 PM







