If shortening stem by 10-20mm....
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Posts: 326
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 182 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
If shortening stem by 10-20mm....
In theory at least, does shortening the stem by 10-20mm require other changes to the fit (e.g. saddle height and fore/aft) ?
The story: I've worked with a pro bike fit to get to my current position. It's taken a while to get a fit where there is no achilles pain or anterior knee pain. I can ride around 200 miles (so far) without much issue other than a bit of back soreness. I think I'm a bit too stretched out.
I have noticed that on long rides I find myself holding the tops and the ramps/shoulders in order to give my core/back a rest and achieve a more upright position.
When I'm holding on the hoods or hooks, I'm in an optimal "regular" fit position, i.e. looking down I'll see the bar tops superimposed over front hub. But when I'm riding on the tops or ramps, I see the front hub closer to me.
My current stem is 130mm. I'd like to try a 120mm or even a 110mm to see if this more upright position lets me spend more time on the hoods or hooks: it is nice to be able to reach the brakes when riding
I want to know - at least in theory -will I need adjustments made to saddle height and fore/aft if I am shortening my stem.
I ask because I want to know if I should pay for another fit along with the stem change.
thank you.
The story: I've worked with a pro bike fit to get to my current position. It's taken a while to get a fit where there is no achilles pain or anterior knee pain. I can ride around 200 miles (so far) without much issue other than a bit of back soreness. I think I'm a bit too stretched out.
I have noticed that on long rides I find myself holding the tops and the ramps/shoulders in order to give my core/back a rest and achieve a more upright position.
When I'm holding on the hoods or hooks, I'm in an optimal "regular" fit position, i.e. looking down I'll see the bar tops superimposed over front hub. But when I'm riding on the tops or ramps, I see the front hub closer to me.
My current stem is 130mm. I'd like to try a 120mm or even a 110mm to see if this more upright position lets me spend more time on the hoods or hooks: it is nice to be able to reach the brakes when riding
I want to know - at least in theory -will I need adjustments made to saddle height and fore/aft if I am shortening my stem.
I ask because I want to know if I should pay for another fit along with the stem change.
thank you.
#2
old fart
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: PA-US
Posts: 379
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 119 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
In theory at least, does shortening the stem by 10-20mm require other changes to the fit (e.g. saddle height and fore/aft) ?
The story: I've worked with a pro bike fit to get to my current position. It's taken a while to get a fit where there is no achilles pain or anterior knee pain. I can ride around 200 miles (so far) without much issue other than a bit of back soreness. I think I'm a bit too stretched out.
I have noticed that on long rides I find myself holding the tops and the ramps/shoulders in order to give my core/back a rest and achieve a more upright position.
When I'm holding on the hoods or hooks, I'm in an optimal "regular" fit position, i.e. looking down I'll see the bar tops superimposed over front hub. But when I'm riding on the tops or ramps, I see the front hub closer to me.
My current stem is 130mm. I'd like to try a 120mm or even a 110mm to see if this more upright position lets me spend more time on the hoods or hooks: it is nice to be able to reach the brakes when riding
I want to know - at least in theory -will I need adjustments made to saddle height and fore/aft if I am shortening my stem.
I ask because I want to know if I should pay for another fit along with the stem change.
thank you.
The story: I've worked with a pro bike fit to get to my current position. It's taken a while to get a fit where there is no achilles pain or anterior knee pain. I can ride around 200 miles (so far) without much issue other than a bit of back soreness. I think I'm a bit too stretched out.
I have noticed that on long rides I find myself holding the tops and the ramps/shoulders in order to give my core/back a rest and achieve a more upright position.
When I'm holding on the hoods or hooks, I'm in an optimal "regular" fit position, i.e. looking down I'll see the bar tops superimposed over front hub. But when I'm riding on the tops or ramps, I see the front hub closer to me.
My current stem is 130mm. I'd like to try a 120mm or even a 110mm to see if this more upright position lets me spend more time on the hoods or hooks: it is nice to be able to reach the brakes when riding
I want to know - at least in theory -will I need adjustments made to saddle height and fore/aft if I am shortening my stem.
I ask because I want to know if I should pay for another fit along with the stem change.
thank you.
Saddle height and fore/aft is a separate deal, and the first step to the correct fit. If yours feels comfortable where it is, don't foock with its position.
In your case, there are 3 things you may want to try:
1. shorter stem;
2. handlebar with a shorter reach;
3. raise the stem a bit (by adding a spacer underneath or by using a stem with a different angle).
Whether or not your line of sight places the front hub in front or behind of the handlebar is entirely irrelevant, although this contradicts the "old wives" approach to stem length I recall applied back in the mid-60s. The proportion between your torso length, arm length, and neck length is unique, which is ignored by the above "rule of thumb".
#3
Senior Member
I am going to ask the obvious, does your current fitter allow you to ask their advice after the fit? Bike fit is an on going process that requires follow up. They shouldn't need to charge you for the inquiry. If you change your stem, it absolutely effects your other contact points. It might be a simple adjustment like flipping a stem over to shorten your reach and give you more elevation. In any case, a pro fit cost should allow for continued correction advice.
#4
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Posts: 326
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 182 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I can go to him for this, but 1) I don't want to bother him yet again if I can trial this small change in stem length without messing with saddle height/fore aft, and 2) he is a little dogmatic - naturally, given his experience - and I am a little pig-headed, so if I tell him that I want to try a change in the fit he might say, "no, that (changing crank arm length, stem length etc) isn't the problem, you need to (strengthen your core, move saddle slightly aft, etc), and I'll think to myself"yes you know tons more than me, but I know my body and I want to try my solution first."
Hope that makes sense
Last edited by Flounce; 03-26-17 at 02:37 PM.
#5
Senior Member
Ok. I had an accountant like that.
You will probably end like us, with a box of stems of various sizes.
I would then recommend aquiring an adjustable angle stem in the length that approximates your final lenght. performance bike might be a good source. Play with various angles. Look at an online stem angle calculator that relates stem angle to total reach. After trying different angles, buy the stem that best reflects the final position.
You will probably end like us, with a box of stems of various sizes.
I would then recommend aquiring an adjustable angle stem in the length that approximates your final lenght. performance bike might be a good source. Play with various angles. Look at an online stem angle calculator that relates stem angle to total reach. After trying different angles, buy the stem that best reflects the final position.
#6
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,534
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Mentioned: 115 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3889 Post(s)
Liked 1,938 Times
in
1,383 Posts
Rather than sit more upright, my advice is always to get stronger and thus remain in the lower and faster position. Just takes some core work, which does not mean crunches! This is a very good book which I've used:
https://www.velopress.com/books/tom-...ore-advantage/
I worked my way though all the programs in the course of a year. It helped. Takes about 20 minutes to do a set of exercises.
There's also flattening your back:
https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycli...discovery.html
https://www.velopress.com/books/tom-...ore-advantage/
I worked my way though all the programs in the course of a year. It helped. Takes about 20 minutes to do a set of exercises.
There's also flattening your back:
https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycli...discovery.html
__________________
Results matter
Results matter