Which one is best ?
#1
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Which one is best ?
No 1#
Frame & size: 6061 alloy, 17"
ForK: SR SUNTOUR XCM (100MM, HLO)
F/D: Shimano M191
R/D: Shimano M360
Shifter: Shimano M310 (24 speed)
Cassette: Shimano HG-200
Crank: Shimano TY501
Hub: Quando
Tyre: Maxxis Pace 1.95X26
Pedal: Wellgo
Brake: Shimano M315 Hydraulic Disk brake with 160mm rotor
OR
No 2 #
Frame - 6061 Alloy
Transmission – 24 Speed Shimano
Front Derailleur – Shimano Tourney
Rear Derailleur – Shimano Acera
Shifter – Shimano M315
Crank – Shimano FC-170/Ty-301
Cassette – Shimano HG-200
Handle Bar – Alloy, Length: 680mm
Stem – Alloy, Ahead type
Suspension - 26" SR Suntour XCM 100mm
Head Set – FSA
Brake set –Tektro Disc Brake with Shimano levers
BB – Chinhaur
Chain – 8 Speed KMC
Rim – 26” Alloy Double Wall
Seat post – 27.2mm
Hubs – Quando 36h QR Type
Tires - 26" x 2.1 Meghna Skin wall
Need your expert opinion ?
Frame & size: 6061 alloy, 17"
ForK: SR SUNTOUR XCM (100MM, HLO)
F/D: Shimano M191
R/D: Shimano M360
Shifter: Shimano M310 (24 speed)
Cassette: Shimano HG-200
Crank: Shimano TY501
Hub: Quando
Tyre: Maxxis Pace 1.95X26
Pedal: Wellgo
Brake: Shimano M315 Hydraulic Disk brake with 160mm rotor
OR
No 2 #
Frame - 6061 Alloy
Transmission – 24 Speed Shimano
Front Derailleur – Shimano Tourney
Rear Derailleur – Shimano Acera
Shifter – Shimano M315
Crank – Shimano FC-170/Ty-301
Cassette – Shimano HG-200
Handle Bar – Alloy, Length: 680mm
Stem – Alloy, Ahead type
Suspension - 26" SR Suntour XCM 100mm
Head Set – FSA
Brake set –Tektro Disc Brake with Shimano levers
BB – Chinhaur
Chain – 8 Speed KMC
Rim – 26” Alloy Double Wall
Seat post – 27.2mm
Hubs – Quando 36h QR Type
Tires - 26" x 2.1 Meghna Skin wall
Need your expert opinion ?
#2
They look like entry-level hardtail MTB's. All else being equal, the first one has hydro brakes, the second does not specify, so I assume it's mechanical. I'd go with the first.
#4
Old Fart
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 3,348
Likes: 3
From: Bumpkinsville
Bikes: '97 Klein Quantum '16 Gravity Knockout
Looks like the most expensive part between the two of 'em is the hydro brake levers on no. 1! My take is that they are cheap low-quality bikes, thrown together with disc brakes as the main selling point.






