So I finally bit the bullet and bought by Felt Z-35...the seat is awful! Could you guys/gals recommend some seats that are somewhat comfortable? Anyone have any experience with Selle San Marco seats? The Caymano FX seat looks pretty comfy and the description of it talks about comfort so I was thinking about going this route, but before I spent the money I thought I would ask around here. So thanks in advance for the input guys/gals...

I could make a suggestion. But because everything else is carboniferous - a Brook's B17 would be out of the question. Even hopelessly overpriced with titanium-rails.

search for "who rides what saddle - popularity contest" (or similar) thread in the road cycling forum. Lots of short reviews and recommendations there.

Try looking at a Selle SMP. But like your bike they aren’t cheap.

Everyone's sitbone area is a little different, but FWIW I like WTB saddles, they've always fit me comfortably and come in several price ranges.