cyclinoliv

I live in Dublin, Ireland, and commute by bike a couple of times a week. I live 25km from the office. It turns out the legendary Irish rain is pretty efficient at penetrating virtually anything I wear during this ~1h long commute. The most significant problem is that after a few miles my shoes turn into small bathtubs. I need something that'll keep my feet dry, even when I'm getting drenched by the bucket!

I currently use:
- Northwave Spike shoes (https://www.chainreactioncycles.com/M...?ModelID=35518)
- some BBB waterproof overshoes (I believe these are the ones: https://www.chainreactioncycles.com/M...?ModelID=45050)

I'm hesitating between two options:
- get some sealskinz socks, and buy a second pair of shoes. Let the shoes get wet and alternate between the two pairs, while the socks do the waterproofing job.
- get some winter boots (shimano mw80).

I'm interested in your opinions and suggestions. I have one relatively soft constraint: I prefer SPD shoes (I find them more suitable for commuting).

MichaelW

Sealskinz work best when you stop water running down the top by use of over-pants.

Rowan

The dedicated waterproof boots might work quite well for you. I have a pair of Gaernes and they have been good in light rain, but I've never really tested them in heavy, heavy rain. I must admit to having lusted after the Shimano MW80s that you mention.

I've also not tried seal skinz, so can't offer a comment there. I have used neoprene-style gloves and... read the next paragraph.

What I have found on randonnees is that, like jackets, the water that you generate in sweat will leave your shoes wet, or at least damp, irrespective of how efficient your booties are in keeping the rain out.

womble

I found that Sealskinz under water resistant softshell trousers were great for keeping my feet dry during wet, winter London commutes.

abdon 

How often are you drenched to the bone?

I like riding in the rain. Anything but a downpour and the sealskinz works just fine. Heck, if you wear rain gear pants that cover the top of the socks your feet will be dry.

sealskinz socks and rain gear would probably work best for you.

BlazingPedals

If you use sandals, you won't have a problem with your shoes filling with water. Some folks use them even in the winter here (as in, snow not rain.)

pablosnazzy

wool socks. i learned this from a river guide. wool socks are where it's at. no matter how wet they get, somehow your feet stay warm and appear dry.

TMB

Fenders, with a front mudflap.

cyclinoliv

Thanks guys for all the suggestions. Keep'em coming!

ItsJustAHill

I've used the Shimano MW80s in some very heavy rain, with wool socks. Stayed warm & dry, with the help of waterproof pants.

BarracksSi

A second pair of shoes at work.