I've got a Specialized Crosstrail, Sport Disc version, and the pedals it came with just aren't up to the level of the rest of the bike, they're just the cheapest no-name things the store could put on, you see the same ones on almost every bike that's priced below $8-900 so they must buy them in bulk. Anyway, I'm looking for a new set of flat pedals for my hybrid and seek your advice, please do not recommend any kind of clipless as I'm aware of that type and it isn't a consideration.

Thanks gang

I use XPEDO pedals on my road and 'fitness' bikes. They are lightweight, with sealed bearings. The platform is a generous size for good traction in any weather. Plus, I think they look really good.
https://www.xpedo.com/products/pedals...100/mx-force-3

I've done considerable window "e-shopping" and have decided on the Shimano Saint pedal. Be careful because you can end up shopping these things to death. There are hundreds of companies selling their own pedals and you can pick about any size weight and design you want. Personally I think many of the pedals offered are just "boutique" stuff and really no worse or better than most everything thing else out there. Granted I haven't tried them all but just be careful, you can spend a ton of time researching pedals and still be confused and not know what you want.

What do you look for in a good flat pedal?

I ran the cheap standard nylon pedals for several years on my 2003 Giant Sedona, and they held up to my 300+ pounds, and were lighter than more expensive metal pedals. I finally replaced them last year when the little nubs were worn so short that my foot started slipping.

I am currently using these, which are pretty grippy. Amazon.com : XLC Alloy Comfort Pedal : Bike Pedals : Sports & Outdoors

I picked up a pair of these last year when they were on sale for $30 shipped. They have sealed bearings and all replacement parts available too!
The Shadow Conspiracy Ravager Alloy - iMiNUSD