Beginners bike
#1
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Beginners bike
I'm a beginner bike rider (Haven't riden a bike in 10 years). I am planning on riding about 8 miles a day back and forth to work. I'am a 32 yr old male looking to get some physical activity into my life. Since I am a beginner, I am looking for a road bike on a budget ($300-500), with an ambition to upgrade in future if I end up liking it. After some online research and visiting a couple shops I am down to two choices:
1. Giant Escape 3 giant-bicycles.com/us/escape-3-2016 $360
2. Trek fx 2 trekbikes.com/us/en_US/bikes/city-bikes/fitness-bikes/fx/fx-2/p/1323010-2017/ $520
Both have good reviews and is good for beginners. I rode both and felt the Trek to be smoother in terms of gear ****ing, lighter and better gripping handles. That being said, Giant was not bad by any means. I just felt a bit more smoother with Trek.
Should I spend the extra 160 bucks and get the trek bike or save the money and stick with Giant? Advise please.
1. Giant Escape 3 giant-bicycles.com/us/escape-3-2016 $360
2. Trek fx 2 trekbikes.com/us/en_US/bikes/city-bikes/fitness-bikes/fx/fx-2/p/1323010-2017/ $520
Both have good reviews and is good for beginners. I rode both and felt the Trek to be smoother in terms of gear ****ing, lighter and better gripping handles. That being said, Giant was not bad by any means. I just felt a bit more smoother with Trek.
Should I spend the extra 160 bucks and get the trek bike or save the money and stick with Giant? Advise please.
#2
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,687
Likes: 297
The Giant has a freewheel hub, which is a poorer design than the 8-speed cassette hub on the Trek.
For utility riding, get a utility minded bike. Apart from gears, to me that means fenders and a rack.
Me, I'd look for a disc brake bike for a commuter. Better performance in rain, takes less hand effort. If you keep adding mileage, your rims last longer.
Don't buy a bike with upgrades already in mind.
Bike parts are a lot more expensive when bought piecemeal than when bought bolted to a bike.
A thorough upgrade at shop prices will cost considerably more than buying the bike you want in the first place.
A better option if you want to start "cheap" is to go for a second bike. Your first bike becomes the rain, or the backup bike. Maybe even the winter bike if you live someplace where winter actually means something.
For utility riding, get a utility minded bike. Apart from gears, to me that means fenders and a rack.
Me, I'd look for a disc brake bike for a commuter. Better performance in rain, takes less hand effort. If you keep adding mileage, your rims last longer.
Don't buy a bike with upgrades already in mind.
Bike parts are a lot more expensive when bought piecemeal than when bought bolted to a bike.
A thorough upgrade at shop prices will cost considerably more than buying the bike you want in the first place.
A better option if you want to start "cheap" is to go for a second bike. Your first bike becomes the rain, or the backup bike. Maybe even the winter bike if you live someplace where winter actually means something.
#3
Forum Moderator
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 22,908
Likes: 10,337
From: Kalamazoo
Welcome to Bike Forums geny.anthony.
As this is the Introductions forum, where you are supposed to only introduce yourself, you aren't likely to get many answers here. I suggest posting your questions in our General Cycling forum. General Cycling Discussion - Bike Forums
As this is the Introductions forum, where you are supposed to only introduce yourself, you aren't likely to get many answers here. I suggest posting your questions in our General Cycling forum. General Cycling Discussion - Bike Forums
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 1,642
Likes: 5
From: Brisbane Aust
Bikes: Giant ToughRoad Giant talon
Hi geny, welcome to the forum. Since you are a beginner it probably doesn't make a lot of difference, but if you are serious about riding, I would suggest you get the more expensive one, it will be a better bike. I think we need to look ahead and consider the psychology of a new rider. It's more than likely that being your first bike you'll come to love it and want to hang onto it, ride it into the ground basically. I know I did and I know others who still have and ride their first. In a years time or 2 that extra few hundred dollars will seem like nothing but the pleasure of having a bike of higher quality will never leave you. Good luck either way.





