Mid drive
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 730
Likes: 107
From: western Massachusetts (greater Springfield area)
Bikes: Velosolex St. Tropez, LeMond Zurich (spine bike), Rotator swb recumbent
Mid drive
I have a Rotator SWB that I bought used. It has a mid drive, with a 5 speed mid and 7 speed rear cluster (mid is fixed, rear is a freewheel). It uses twist shifters, the front has a 7 speed but only uses 5 of them.
I think it is great. The mid shifts much better than the front on a traditional setup, and you can shift either one depending on where you are on the respective clusters, until you get to the highest or lowest gears.
I can see why this would not work on a DF, but wonder why it is not more popular on recumbents.
I think it is great. The mid shifts much better than the front on a traditional setup, and you can shift either one depending on where you are on the respective clusters, until you get to the highest or lowest gears.
I can see why this would not work on a DF, but wonder why it is not more popular on recumbents.
#3
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 12,548
Likes: 797
From: Middle of da Mitten
Bikes: Trek 7500, RANS V-Rex, Optima Baron, Velokraft NoCom, M-5 Carbon Highracer, Catrike Speed
The difference isn't huge, but if you do the math, small drive wheels mean less total gear range. If the range becomes an issue, the answer is to take 'extreme measures.' That can mean a Capreo 9T gear in back, or adding internal gearing at the hub or the bottom bracket, or in the case of Rotator a mid-drive with more gears.
#5
Member

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
From: Columbus, OH
Bikes: Haluzak, Lemle, Longbikes Slipstrem, Longbikes Jetstream, & Roulandt
mid drive Dragonflyer
I like the mid drive on my Dragonflyer as it makes up for having 20 inch wheels all around. It's quiet, is at the midpoint of the trike allowing for have the pivot point for the shock in the middle of the trike. Seems to have enough gears as I can get up most hills in my area without stopping. 3 in the front and 8 in the rear.The trike has a few years on it but was a bit ahead of the rest at that time.
#6
Senior Member

Joined: May 2003
Posts: 4,054
Likes: 164
From: Mountain Brook. AL
Actually the Rotator mid drive cassette is mounted on a pair of sealed bearings with an ID of 10mm. The shaft is a 10mm axle cantilevered off the main
tube and held by a small tube welded at a 90D angle to the main tube with an internal 10Mx1.0 thread. The cassette splined carrier is standard Shimano
splines and the sealed bearings are at either end of the splined carrier. Inboard of the mid-drive cassette is the drive cog for the rear wheel cassette.
All of these cogs can be obtained by looking for cassettes held together with screws and not using carriers for the larger cogs. These used to be available
for $5-10 from Nashbar but have gone up the past few years. The better known Shimano/Sram cassettes all use carriers for the larger cogs and are not
suitable cog donors. You need to rummage for off brand 7-8-9 speed cassettes without large cog carriers. Rotator used standard 10Mx1.0 solid axles for
their mid-drives and had to shim the middle of these with a wraparound shim glued to the shaft for them to fit well into the bearings. It only takes a few
degrees of skew in the axle to allow the rear chain to derail under torque.
The axles had an actual diameter closer to 9.5mm where the bearing fit and 9.8mm at the threads, at least on my axle. The skew angle problem necessitated
manufacture of a new axle at home. First attempt with carbon steel solved the skew angle problem but broke after 800 miles. Second axle out of 4140 lasted
5500miles, and the 3d axle also 4140 is still on the bike after 13,000 miles. I lengthened the axle so I could put a nut on the L side of the mounting tube to snug
up the axle and made wrench flats on it for easier removal 'if it breaks'. The axle is under
a lot more torque than you would think, as both breaks occurred with strong accelerations, fortunately not too far from home.
The Sunset looks more like an idler set up than a Rotator/Trek style middrive.
tube and held by a small tube welded at a 90D angle to the main tube with an internal 10Mx1.0 thread. The cassette splined carrier is standard Shimano
splines and the sealed bearings are at either end of the splined carrier. Inboard of the mid-drive cassette is the drive cog for the rear wheel cassette.
All of these cogs can be obtained by looking for cassettes held together with screws and not using carriers for the larger cogs. These used to be available
for $5-10 from Nashbar but have gone up the past few years. The better known Shimano/Sram cassettes all use carriers for the larger cogs and are not
suitable cog donors. You need to rummage for off brand 7-8-9 speed cassettes without large cog carriers. Rotator used standard 10Mx1.0 solid axles for
their mid-drives and had to shim the middle of these with a wraparound shim glued to the shaft for them to fit well into the bearings. It only takes a few
degrees of skew in the axle to allow the rear chain to derail under torque.
The axles had an actual diameter closer to 9.5mm where the bearing fit and 9.8mm at the threads, at least on my axle. The skew angle problem necessitated
manufacture of a new axle at home. First attempt with carbon steel solved the skew angle problem but broke after 800 miles. Second axle out of 4140 lasted
5500miles, and the 3d axle also 4140 is still on the bike after 13,000 miles. I lengthened the axle so I could put a nut on the L side of the mounting tube to snug
up the axle and made wrench flats on it for easier removal 'if it breaks'. The axle is under
a lot more torque than you would think, as both breaks occurred with strong accelerations, fortunately not too far from home.
The Sunset looks more like an idler set up than a Rotator/Trek style middrive.
#7
#10
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 730
Likes: 107
From: western Massachusetts (greater Springfield area)
Bikes: Velosolex St. Tropez, LeMond Zurich (spine bike), Rotator swb recumbent
Actually the Rotator mid drive cassette is mounted on a pair of sealed bearings with an ID of 10mm. The shaft is a 10mm axle cantilevered off the main
tube and held by a small tube welded at a 90D angle to the main tube with an internal 10Mx1.0 thread. The cassette splined carrier is standard Shimano
splines and the sealed bearings are at either end of the splined carrier. Inboard of the mid-drive cassette is the drive cog for the rear wheel cassette.
All of these cogs can be obtained by looking for cassettes held together with screws and not using carriers for the larger cogs. These used to be available
for $5-10 from Nashbar but have gone up the past few years. The better known Shimano/Sram cassettes all use carriers for the larger cogs and are not
suitable cog donors. You need to rummage for off brand 7-8-9 speed cassettes without large cog carriers. Rotator used standard 10Mx1.0 solid axles for
their mid-drives and had to shim the middle of these with a wraparound shim glued to the shaft for them to fit well into the bearings. It only takes a few
degrees of skew in the axle to allow the rear chain to derail under torque.
The axles had an actual diameter closer to 9.5mm where the bearing fit and 9.8mm at the threads, at least on my axle. The skew angle problem necessitated
manufacture of a new axle at home. First attempt with carbon steel solved the skew angle problem but broke after 800 miles. Second axle out of 4140 lasted
5500miles, and the 3d axle also 4140 is still on the bike after 13,000 miles. I lengthened the axle so I could put a nut on the L side of the mounting tube to snug
up the axle and made wrench flats on it for easier removal 'if it breaks'. The axle is under
a lot more torque than you would think, as both breaks occurred with strong accelerations, fortunately not too far from home.
The Sunset looks more like an idler set up than a Rotator/Trek style middrive.
tube and held by a small tube welded at a 90D angle to the main tube with an internal 10Mx1.0 thread. The cassette splined carrier is standard Shimano
splines and the sealed bearings are at either end of the splined carrier. Inboard of the mid-drive cassette is the drive cog for the rear wheel cassette.
All of these cogs can be obtained by looking for cassettes held together with screws and not using carriers for the larger cogs. These used to be available
for $5-10 from Nashbar but have gone up the past few years. The better known Shimano/Sram cassettes all use carriers for the larger cogs and are not
suitable cog donors. You need to rummage for off brand 7-8-9 speed cassettes without large cog carriers. Rotator used standard 10Mx1.0 solid axles for
their mid-drives and had to shim the middle of these with a wraparound shim glued to the shaft for them to fit well into the bearings. It only takes a few
degrees of skew in the axle to allow the rear chain to derail under torque.
The axles had an actual diameter closer to 9.5mm where the bearing fit and 9.8mm at the threads, at least on my axle. The skew angle problem necessitated
manufacture of a new axle at home. First attempt with carbon steel solved the skew angle problem but broke after 800 miles. Second axle out of 4140 lasted
5500miles, and the 3d axle also 4140 is still on the bike after 13,000 miles. I lengthened the axle so I could put a nut on the L side of the mounting tube to snug
up the axle and made wrench flats on it for easier removal 'if it breaks'. The axle is under
a lot more torque than you would think, as both breaks occurred with strong accelerations, fortunately not too far from home.
The Sunset looks more like an idler set up than a Rotator/Trek style middrive.
#11
I'm not sure just what all goes on there. The description reminds me of the drivetrain on da Vinci tandems. The claimed advantage of the system is captain and stoker can coast while the other is pedaling. However, one consequence is that the "front" is a half-size set of chainrings with 4 cogs on it instead of the normal two. So it's a fourple instead of a triple.
Drivetrain Info - da Vinci Designs
Drivetrain Info - da Vinci Designs
__________________
"be careful this rando stuff is addictive and dan's the 'pusher'."
"be careful this rando stuff is addictive and dan's the 'pusher'."
#12
I'm not sure just what all goes on there. The description reminds me of the drivetrain on da Vinci tandems. The claimed advantage of the system is captain and stoker can coast while the other is pedaling. However, one consequence is that the "front" is a half-size set of chainrings with 4 cogs on it instead of the normal two. So it's a fourple instead of a triple.
Drivetrain Info - da Vinci Designs
Drivetrain Info - da Vinci Designs
To address Mike W's original question: "[I] wonder why it is not more popular on recumbents."
Recumbents are already a small niche market product, requiring a custom frame, seat, and some accessories. To add custom drivetrain components simply adds cost and difficulty to an already costly and difficult-to-manufacture product. In short, mid-drives aren't more popular because the benefits aren't worth the costs.
FWIW: the Aerocoupe trikes I built used a modified tandem crankset to create a sort-of mid-drive arangement. Modifying the crankset was a significant investment in time and tooling.
Best view: (from river12 )
__________________
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..
#13
Senior Member


Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 30,225
Likes: 649
From: St Peters, Missouri
Bikes: Catrike 559 I own some others but they don't get ridden very much.
Reminds me of the birdcage Masarati sports cars of the 60's. The space frame chassis was fabricated from multiple pencil diameter tubes. The joke was they removed one tube at a time until it broke then added the last tube back.
__________________
My greatest fear is all of my kids standing around my coffin and talking about "how sensible" dad was.
My greatest fear is all of my kids standing around my coffin and talking about "how sensible" dad was.
#14
Thanks. It was a beast to fabricate, though, with all those small tubes.
__________________
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..
#15
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 288
Likes: 12
From: Vacouver Island B.C. Canada
Bikes: Catrike Trail/Catrike Expedition
ROTATOR trike WITH MID DRIVE
My 1st trike I think was called a Rotator Comfort3. With the mid drive(6) and rear Derailluer(8)and the crank had a single gear(34T), it was a great tour machine. I rode the Icefield Parkway Alt., Vancouver Island, Gulf islands and the Sunshine Coast with that beast. Now I'm riding my 2nd Catrike 8yrs later but still recall those days, especially getting used to riding with all kinds of traffic, I thought I was low to the ground then....
#16
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 730
Likes: 107
From: western Massachusetts (greater Springfield area)
Bikes: Velosolex St. Tropez, LeMond Zurich (spine bike), Rotator swb recumbent
That is very similar to what I have, although I have 5 and 7 rather than 6 and 8. I srikes me that the mid derailleur is a lot more vulnerable on a trike than a 2 wheeler though!
I think the biggest advantage is that all shifting is done with "rear" derailleurs that move the unloaded side of the chain, and therefore shift more quickly and reliably than any (mechanical) front derailleur I have ever used. There are so many combinations with so much overlap that I just shift whichever will keep both as close to the center as possible.
I think the biggest advantage is that all shifting is done with "rear" derailleurs that move the unloaded side of the chain, and therefore shift more quickly and reliably than any (mechanical) front derailleur I have ever used. There are so many combinations with so much overlap that I just shift whichever will keep both as close to the center as possible.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
pianobike
Road Cycling
2
11-23-13 07:23 PM








