I would probably get a 2016 TCR Advanced 3 for 1600 MSRP over a 105 Caad12, its pretty much the same price but TCR is carbon.

did CD get the caad12 frame lighter than the Trek ALR?

Tour Mag specs & results:

26 grams lighter, frame and fork combo, not sure which size they used.

If someone could translate.

Cannondale IS the segment leader in aluminium road bikes.

As for longevity, thus far I've done 16,500Km and 17,00Km on my CAADs, respectively and I'm not a light rider. They do last and are grouse bikes. I would much prefer a CAAD than a low-mid range carbon bike...

If the CAAD12 is as much an improvement over the CAAD10 as I've been led to believe, it is a great rig.

cheers

Re: the above table, one problem is what is the meaning of frameset (Gewicht Rahmen-set). Are we talking just frame and fork, which based on the weights given really seems unlikely. So what else is thrown in? RD hanger for sure, but seat post clamp? What about headset and bottom bracket? Hard to know. It is just that those weights are stupid high compared to other reviews.

As I interpret that chart, it is a scored comparison of the frames and then in the second section the parts added onto the frame. If there is an objective measurement of a factor, that is converted to a subjective score, better is lower. Each factor is given a percent weight in the final score. That is the top line of the chart. Each factor is scored from 0-5. The individual scores are weight averaged according to the percent given in the top line. So the frameset weight is multiplied by 0.25, the ride stability is multiplied by 0.15 and so on. Then all those weighted factors are added up for the final score. Low score wins it seems.

Here are the headings in order:
Frameset weight
Ride stability
Lateral stiffness, fork
Power transmission
Frame comfort
Paint
Finish
Instructions
Warranty
Weighted average
Weight of equipment added to the frame
Gear shift setup
Brakes
Crankset
Wheels
Tires
Stem
Saddle
Weighted average for complete bike
Weighted average for frame and bike (40% frame, 60% bike)

Hope this helps.

Re: this thread, it is important to note the Trek ALR is scored MUCH worse in comfort than the Cannondale. The two complete bikes are comparable in total score, but that comfort score really stands out.