2017 Specialized Roubaix review
#551
Senior Member


Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 152
From: midwest
Bikes: 2018 Roubaix Expert Di2, 2016 Diverge Expert X1
#552
Junior Member
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Bikes: 2108 Roubaix Expert DI2
Also, the SWAT box came empty, I had to pay for all the items to complete the kit. I wasn't expecting that.
Best of luck!
#554
Junior Member
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Bikes: 2108 Roubaix Expert DI2
#555
Senior Member


Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 152
From: midwest
Bikes: 2018 Roubaix Expert Di2, 2016 Diverge Expert X1
#556
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 156
Likes: 1
I've attached a photo as I do not have a long enough posting history to embed a URL.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
I'll be adding an XLabs rear bottle holder and maybe get the carbon bars with internal routing. I've been thinking of a bento box to hold food and my phone. Hate to add weight and clutter. I'm riding the Konocti challenge on Saturday and I'll know soon enough how well she goes.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
- Modified the rear cassette to a 40 tooth XTR with a Wolf Roadlink and etc.
- Changed the 28mm stock tires to 32mm Gatorskins. 70/85psi F/R seems to work, I'm a big guy.
- Added my Wahoo, lights, etc.
- Tiny saddle bag for keys, cards, whatnot.
- SPD pedals
- ISM PR 3.0 Saddle
- Pricey little bell
I'll be adding an XLabs rear bottle holder and maybe get the carbon bars with internal routing. I've been thinking of a bento box to hold food and my phone. Hate to add weight and clutter. I'm riding the Konocti challenge on Saturday and I'll know soon enough how well she goes.
#557
I've attached a photo as I do not have a long enough posting history to embed a URL.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
- Modified the rear cassette to a 40 tooth XTR with a Wolf Roadlink and etc.
- Changed the 28mm stock tires to 32mm Gatorskins. 70/85psi F/R seems to work, I'm a big guy.
- Added my Wahoo, lights, etc.
- Tiny saddle bag for keys, cards, whatnot.
- SPD pedals
- ISM PR 3.0 Saddle
- Pricey little bell
Can you tell us how tall you are and how much you weigh?
Should be comfy with the bars up nice and high.
How about a comparison with your Secteur? I own both a Secteur and Roubaix SL3. Can you compare the relative ride comfort of new Roubaix with Future Shock to your Secteur? You mentioned you run 32mm tires on your new Roubaix. What size tires did you run on your Secteur?
Lastly, have you put both on a scale to determine what the weight diff is? Secteurs aren't light...somewhat dependent on components....but the new Roubaix with disc brakes isn't exactly light either. Was curious what the weight diff is?
Congrats on the new bike. Looks very nice.
Last edited by Campag4life; 10-03-17 at 03:15 AM.
#558
Senior Member


Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 152
From: midwest
Bikes: 2018 Roubaix Expert Di2, 2016 Diverge Expert X1
I've attached a photo as I do not have a long enough posting history to embed a URL.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
I'll be adding an XLabs rear bottle holder and maybe get the carbon bars with internal routing. I've been thinking of a bento box to hold food and my phone. Hate to add weight and clutter. I'm riding the Konocti challenge on Saturday and I'll know soon enough how well she goes.
This is a 61cm 2018 Specialized Roubaix Expert. It replaces my Specialized Secteur that I use on solo century rides in the mountains here. I'll also commute on it. Comfort on chip seal and ease of climbing are the goals.
- Modified the rear cassette to a 40 tooth XTR with a Wolf Roadlink and etc.
- Changed the 28mm stock tires to 32mm Gatorskins. 70/85psi F/R seems to work, I'm a big guy.
- Added my Wahoo, lights, etc.
- Tiny saddle bag for keys, cards, whatnot.
- SPD pedals
- ISM PR 3.0 Saddle
- Pricey little bell
I'll be adding an XLabs rear bottle holder and maybe get the carbon bars with internal routing. I've been thinking of a bento box to hold food and my phone. Hate to add weight and clutter. I'm riding the Konocti challenge on Saturday and I'll know soon enough how well she goes.
#560
Senior Member


Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 152
From: midwest
Bikes: 2018 Roubaix Expert Di2, 2016 Diverge Expert X1
I think it is the version on android - says it does not recognize some components. One other thing, the swat-box is in the way of a chain catcher.
Last edited by GeneO; 10-07-17 at 04:20 PM.
#561
Just picked up a 2018 base model a few weeks ago and I love this bike. I set out to do a quick 10 mile ride today and it turned into 30 because it’s just so much fun to ride.
Last edited by RadialHead; 10-07-17 at 04:00 PM.
#563
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 774
Likes: 1,000
From: Gatorland and BlueRidge heaven
Bikes: 2021 Trek Domane SLR 7, 2012 Giant Defy 0, 2012 Trek Domane 6.2 P1, Bianchi Infinito CV disc Di2
LBS informed me my 2018 Expert (Di2 and disks) is in. I won't be able to pick it up for several weeks. I think the red/black looks awesome, but I got white because I'm going to put a teal wrap on it ( for OC ), and I have a Domane with black/lime green that looks similar to the Roubaix.
I have two bikes with Di2 already, and I did ride a demo Expert back in May.
I have two bikes with Di2 already, and I did ride a demo Expert back in May.
__________________
Ride hard and ride on......
Ride hard and ride on......
Last edited by wthensler; 10-08-17 at 04:22 PM.
#564
Newbie

Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
From: Western Australia
Bikes: 2011 S-Works Roubaix
SWorks Roubaix
All this talk of SWAT boxes and discs makes me want to comment. My SWAT box came fully loaded apart from a gas canister so I find it strange you'd have to buy the bits. Mind you, it was $170 AUD!!
I have a 2017 SWorks Roubaix which I've put Dura Ace R9170 disc brakes on and as much as I love the bike, the brake noise is driving me insane. Have any of you had issues in the wet with these (or the Ultegra equivalent) brakes? It looks like the front caliper has a faulty piston which is slow to return, and doesn't return all the way. As the bike picks up grit from the wet road, it catches on one side of the disc (the bad piston side) and rubs until it clears. I've tried all the tricks - space the pads when I re-center, clean everything thoroughly, massage the piston (yes, that's a thing!) and it's still bad. Considering a warranty return of the caliper. The rear caliper leaked from new and I had to return that, so i'm a little rattled by the 9170 stuff at the moment.
Here's my bike. Last ones was the SL3 version of the same.
I have a 2017 SWorks Roubaix which I've put Dura Ace R9170 disc brakes on and as much as I love the bike, the brake noise is driving me insane. Have any of you had issues in the wet with these (or the Ultegra equivalent) brakes? It looks like the front caliper has a faulty piston which is slow to return, and doesn't return all the way. As the bike picks up grit from the wet road, it catches on one side of the disc (the bad piston side) and rubs until it clears. I've tried all the tricks - space the pads when I re-center, clean everything thoroughly, massage the piston (yes, that's a thing!) and it's still bad. Considering a warranty return of the caliper. The rear caliper leaked from new and I had to return that, so i'm a little rattled by the 9170 stuff at the moment.
Here's my bike. Last ones was the SL3 version of the same.
#567
All this talk of SWAT boxes and discs makes me want to comment. My SWAT box came fully loaded apart from a gas canister so I find it strange you'd have to buy the bits. Mind you, it was $170 AUD!!
I have a 2017 SWorks Roubaix which I've put Dura Ace R9170 disc brakes on and as much as I love the bike, the brake noise is driving me insane. Have any of you had issues in the wet with these (or the Ultegra equivalent) brakes? It looks like the front caliper has a faulty piston which is slow to return, and doesn't return all the way. As the bike picks up grit from the wet road, it catches on one side of the disc (the bad piston side) and rubs until it clears. I've tried all the tricks - space the pads when I re-center, clean everything thoroughly, massage the piston (yes, that's a thing!) and it's still bad. Considering a warranty return of the caliper. The rear caliper leaked from new and I had to return that, so i'm a little rattled by the 9170 stuff at the moment.
Here's my bike. Last ones was the SL3 version of the same.
I have a 2017 SWorks Roubaix which I've put Dura Ace R9170 disc brakes on and as much as I love the bike, the brake noise is driving me insane. Have any of you had issues in the wet with these (or the Ultegra equivalent) brakes? It looks like the front caliper has a faulty piston which is slow to return, and doesn't return all the way. As the bike picks up grit from the wet road, it catches on one side of the disc (the bad piston side) and rubs until it clears. I've tried all the tricks - space the pads when I re-center, clean everything thoroughly, massage the piston (yes, that's a thing!) and it's still bad. Considering a warranty return of the caliper. The rear caliper leaked from new and I had to return that, so i'm a little rattled by the 9170 stuff at the moment.
Here's my bike. Last ones was the SL3 version of the same.
#568
Newbie

Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
From: Western Australia
Bikes: 2011 S-Works Roubaix
The ride is completely different. I'm 6'5" and ride a 58cm (all my length is in my legs) so cornering on the SL3 wasn't a particularly smooth experience for me. I tended to sit up quite a bit and the bike was slow through the corners, possibly because of the wheelbase length as well as my height. They say the 2017 model has the Tarmac geometry and I'd believe it. I'm certainly quicker through corners because I feel like it pulls through them faster, but combine that with a suspended handlebar stem which removes any road surface uncertainty and you have a great handling bike.
I suffer a lot from back and neck injuries and this bike has helped that out too I feel. I've forgotten that my head stem is suspended even though I'm using a "service center only" spring which is 60 Lbs/In. I think that's double the firmest spring you usually get with the bike. You just don't feel so beat up anymore after a long ride.
The down side to all this tech is for the people behind you. Imagine riding over every bump you see because it doesn't hurt your hands, braking later into corners because of the discs and taking tighter lines through the corners. No wonder everyone is worried about differing brake systems in the pro peloton.
#569
2011 SWorks SL3 was my older one. It developed a crack where the top tube meets the seat tube so was replaced with a 2017 model - lucky me.
The ride is completely different. I'm 6'5" and ride a 58cm (all my length is in my legs) so cornering on the SL3 wasn't a particularly smooth experience for me. I tended to sit up quite a bit and the bike was slow through the corners, possibly because of the wheelbase length as well as my height. They say the 2017 model has the Tarmac geometry and I'd believe it. I'm certainly quicker through corners because I feel like it pulls through them faster, but combine that with a suspended handlebar stem which removes any road surface uncertainty and you have a great handling bike.
I suffer a lot from back and neck injuries and this bike has helped that out too I feel. I've forgotten that my head stem is suspended even though I'm using a "service center only" spring which is 60 Lbs/In. I think that's double the firmest spring you usually get with the bike. You just don't feel so beat up anymore after a long ride.
The down side to all this tech is for the people behind you. Imagine riding over every bump you see because it doesn't hurt your hands, braking later into corners because of the discs and taking tighter lines through the corners. No wonder everyone is worried about differing brake systems in the pro peloton.
The ride is completely different. I'm 6'5" and ride a 58cm (all my length is in my legs) so cornering on the SL3 wasn't a particularly smooth experience for me. I tended to sit up quite a bit and the bike was slow through the corners, possibly because of the wheelbase length as well as my height. They say the 2017 model has the Tarmac geometry and I'd believe it. I'm certainly quicker through corners because I feel like it pulls through them faster, but combine that with a suspended handlebar stem which removes any road surface uncertainty and you have a great handling bike.
I suffer a lot from back and neck injuries and this bike has helped that out too I feel. I've forgotten that my head stem is suspended even though I'm using a "service center only" spring which is 60 Lbs/In. I think that's double the firmest spring you usually get with the bike. You just don't feel so beat up anymore after a long ride.
The down side to all this tech is for the people behind you. Imagine riding over every bump you see because it doesn't hurt your hands, braking later into corners because of the discs and taking tighter lines through the corners. No wonder everyone is worried about differing brake systems in the pro peloton.

That said, I have done my share of casual racing through curvy courses with good club riders riding hard. I really like the handling of a SL3 but yes, it doesn't handle like a Tarmac which btw, I don't mind. I like how easy the SL3 is to ride.
As to frame size, please don't take this wrong but at 6'5", you should be on a 61. You could even ride a 64 but would be a hint too big...but no doubt there are 6'5" guys opting for the biggest 64cm Future Shock Roubaix.
You mention bad back and neck, the amount of drop you ride because your saddle is so high is a key contributor.
A myth of bike fit is...you would be too stretched out on a 61. No. As the bars come up you need more horizontal reach. Anyway, you made your choice and what matters.
A further myth is about your reference to Tarmac geometry. The word geometry at is turns out has different meanings. There is the three point rider contact on the Roubaix which is virtually identical between the new future shock Roubaix versus the SL3 for example we have both owned...and there is the angles of the frame including head tube angle and trail of the bike which affect handling. As it turns out, Specialized was able to achieve the fit of the old Roubaix which average bike riders prefer and make the bike handle closer to the Tarmac by choice of frame member angles. So, the term geometry really doesn't do justice to the new bike. Geometry in the context of rider fit is preserved. But yes, the geometry of the frame that affects handling is clearly different. Riding position is almost identical to the old Roubaix but agreed, the new bike handles more spritely as you say.
As to the disk brake comments you make, forgive me again, but pros aren't that plussed about different brake systems...disk versus caliper in the peloton. Rather the vast majority, probably 98% of the pro peloton still ride caliper brakes even though disk brakes are allowed. That is a separate conversation. Suffice to say, one of the things that will likely keep me off the new Future Shock Roubaix is the bike isn't offered with caliper brakes which would also make it lighter. I don't want a road bike with disk brakes and the vast majority of pro riders don't as well.
Congrats on the new steed and thanks for sharing your observations with us!
Last edited by Campag4life; 10-09-17 at 08:46 AM.
#570
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,693
Likes: 298
From: Northeastern MA, USA
Bikes: Garmin/Tacx Bike Smart
#571
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 95
Likes: 0
From: DFW, TX
Bikes: Giant MB (need to determine model)
I am new here. I road a lot when I was in college and much younger. I'll be 50 next month and as a birthday present to myself, I'm picking up a bike. I have more time now that my kids are in school and I need to get back into shape. My LBS has mid-week rides to get me started and weekend rides to extend my range.
Looking to pick up a 2017 SL4 Comp UDi2. LBS has it significantly discounted and has one in my size (49). I'm 5'4" with a 27" inseam.
I am trying to keep myself from getting a 2018 Expert UDi2 at a much higher price. My GF is pushing me to stick to my original decision with the SL4 and in a year or two, decide on an upgrade.
Most of my riding will be on paved roads with the occasional gravel. My LBS has a few 40/50 something year old riders and they all ride Roubaixs. Mostly from a comfort perspective which is the reason I am leaning towards this bike.
With that said, the 2018 Expert UDi2 does have a lot going for it, but at this point, I'm looking at a $2400 premium over the cost of the 2017 SL4 Comp UDi2 (LBS has them priced at $2200).
Is this a worthy upgrade? Or stick with the 2017 SL4?
Looking to pick up a 2017 SL4 Comp UDi2. LBS has it significantly discounted and has one in my size (49). I'm 5'4" with a 27" inseam.
I am trying to keep myself from getting a 2018 Expert UDi2 at a much higher price. My GF is pushing me to stick to my original decision with the SL4 and in a year or two, decide on an upgrade.
Most of my riding will be on paved roads with the occasional gravel. My LBS has a few 40/50 something year old riders and they all ride Roubaixs. Mostly from a comfort perspective which is the reason I am leaning towards this bike.
With that said, the 2018 Expert UDi2 does have a lot going for it, but at this point, I'm looking at a $2400 premium over the cost of the 2017 SL4 Comp UDi2 (LBS has them priced at $2200).
Is this a worthy upgrade? Or stick with the 2017 SL4?
#572
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 238
Likes: 3
From: Fremont, CA
Bikes: 2015 Spec Roubaix Expert, 2016 Spec Diverge Expert X1, 2018 Allez Sprint eTap
I have a 2015 SL4 Roubaix Expert, which I love very much, but if it weren't for my wife watching my every moves, I'd be owning a new Roubaix right now, likely one with UDI2 to boot. The only bad reviews about it seem to be from people who've never ridden one

Of course, $2400 is nothing to sneeze at, but if you can swing it, I'd say "it's only money"


Geoff
#573
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 774
Likes: 1,000
From: Gatorland and BlueRidge heaven
Bikes: 2021 Trek Domane SLR 7, 2012 Giant Defy 0, 2012 Trek Domane 6.2 P1, Bianchi Infinito CV disc Di2
Yeah, I say go for it. The 2018 Roubaix Expert will be my third bike with UDi2, and the first with disks. I'm just under 5'11" and went with the 58. The Roubaix frame is a bit taller and a shorter wheelbase than my Domane, so a little twitchier in the turns. And dang, even with carbon fiber, it's a heavy bike.
Any bike that makes you want to ride is worth the extra $$$, IMO. And all of my bikes make me feel that way.
Any bike that makes you want to ride is worth the extra $$$, IMO. And all of my bikes make me feel that way.
__________________
Ride hard and ride on......
Ride hard and ride on......
Last edited by wthensler; 10-09-17 at 05:30 PM.
#574
Senior Member


Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 152
From: midwest
Bikes: 2018 Roubaix Expert Di2, 2016 Diverge Expert X1
Yeah, I say go for it. The 2018 Roubaix Expert will be my third bike with UDi2, and the first with disks. I'm just under 5'11" and went with the 58. The Roubaix frame is a bit taller and a shorter wheelbase than my Domane, so a little twitchier in the turns. And dang, even with carbon fiber, it's a heavy bike.
Any bike that makes you want to ride is worth the extra $$$, IMO. And all of my bikes make me feel that way.
Any bike that makes you want to ride is worth the extra $$$, IMO. And all of my bikes make me feel that way.
I am 5'11" but with a longer torso. A 58 would be pushing stand over for me, and my saddle height over bar would be too little. I got the 56 and I feel a bit too upright, my saddle height is near my bar height, so will probably need to adjust that. I have had o set he saddle back about 1.5 cm.



