View Poll Results: Keep dork disc or remove it
Voters: 128. You may not vote on this poll
Dork disc
#26
Senior Member
Sorry, wife called me away...what was the topic?
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: TC, MN
Posts: 39,521
Bikes: R3 Disc, Haanjo
Liked 9,462 Times
in
4,673 Posts
Likes For WhyFi:
#28
Serious Cyclist
Is the cost of perhaps a new rear derailleur, chain, paint, any carbon fiber in the area, the dropout, some spokes (and perhaps the wheel) for a should-never-happen but can mishap OK for you? If so, remove the dork disc. Recently someone here posted about the mishap he just had. The $$ total was impressive.
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
#29
Senior Member
Who cares.
Maybe your next poll can be about what color socks you should wear...
Maybe your next poll can be about what color socks you should wear...
#31
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2017
Location: Hollister, CA (not the surf town)
Posts: 1,772
Bikes: 2019 Specialized Roubaix Comp Di2, 2009 Roubaix, early 90's Giant Iguana
Liked 1,640 Times
in
579 Posts
So. You've read several pros and cons and can't decide for yourself? If you're looking for a consensus to validate what you think you should do, you're not likely to find it here.
Likes For cycledogg:
#34
Senior Member
No road bike should even come with one. Or any bike really.
My road bike did not, but my hybrid did - I was impressed with my ability to cut it off with a scissors without so much as removing the rear wheel.
My road bike did not, but my hybrid did - I was impressed with my ability to cut it off with a scissors without so much as removing the rear wheel.
#35
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Seattle
Posts: 1,072
Bikes: my precious steel boys
Liked 605 Times
in
359 Posts
for a semi-"actual" answer, these things exist because of lawyers, and because of department store bikes with rear derailleurs that manufacturers fully expect will be taken into a bike shop maybe once every two years when the tire flats. A properly adjusted RD will not dump the chain into the spokes, but a properly adjusted Shimano Tourney RD can become an improperly adjusted one after some kid dumps it on the ground a few times or bangs it against the garage door.
check your RD limit screws any time you adjust anything in the rear of the bike (cassette change, rear wheel change etc), and any time you crash or bang the RD against the cafe door when you try to bring your bike in like a nincompoop.
check your RD limit screws any time you adjust anything in the rear of the bike (cassette change, rear wheel change etc), and any time you crash or bang the RD against the cafe door when you try to bring your bike in like a nincompoop.
#36
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: Québec, Canada
Posts: 2,184
Bikes: SL8 Pro, TCR beater
Liked 599 Times
in
451 Posts
What's the worst thing that can happen? Suddent rear wheel braking?
Better hang your self tight to the bars! In that case, I'd recommend to have a good compression plug to make sure your fork tube does not break. There's another funny thread about that currently running.
Better hang your self tight to the bars! In that case, I'd recommend to have a good compression plug to make sure your fork tube does not break. There's another funny thread about that currently running.
#37
Senior Member
Is the cost of perhaps a new rear derailleur, chain, paint, any carbon fiber in the area, the dropout, some spokes (and perhaps the wheel) for a should-never-happen but can mishap OK for you? If so, remove the dork disc. Recently someone here posted about the mishap he just had. The $$ total was impressive.
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
#38
I see the DD as coming from the same school of thought that brought us "lawyer lip" forks, various annoying wheel-retaining washers, turkey levers, chain guards, flags, kneepads, safety vests, mirrors, etc. All promising to deliver a safer, virtually "idiot-proof" cycling experience but mostly failing in everyday use.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
#39
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: Québec, Canada
Posts: 2,184
Bikes: SL8 Pro, TCR beater
Liked 599 Times
in
451 Posts
I see the DD as coming from the same school of thought that brought us "lawyer lip" forks, various annoying wheel-retaining washers, turkey levers, chain guards, flags, kneepads, safety vests, mirrors, etc. All promising to deliver a safer, virtually "idiot-proof" cycling experience but mostly failing in everyday use.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
#40
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Seattle
Posts: 1,072
Bikes: my precious steel boys
Liked 605 Times
in
359 Posts
I see the DD as coming from the same school of thought that brought us "lawyer lip" forks, various annoying wheel-retaining washers, turkey levers, chain guards, flags, kneepads, safety vests, mirrors, etc. All promising to deliver a safer, virtually "idiot-proof" cycling experience but mostly failing in everyday use.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
If you let these people go too far, we'll eventually have mandatory rubber tooth guards on all bicycle stems (to keep from chipping your tooth) and top tube padding, on every new men's bike sold, to prevent reproductive damage.
#41
Member
Dork disc, those plastic, aluminum or chromed steel discs between the rear wheel spokes and the freewheel/cassette. Common on lesser derailleur bikes from the early '70s on. Their purpose is to keep the derailleur from hitting the spokes when either poorly adjusted or the derailleur hanger is bent. They may also keep the chain from falling into the gap between cog and hub or minimizes the subsequent damage if it does happen. Basically good, simple insurance that no respectable roadie would ever be caught dead with.
Ben
Ben
It is hard to clean but it never occurred to me that it could be removed. Don't know when the scratches were made on the thing. I've owned the bike since new in the early 70s... Purchased in Portland, BTW.
#42
Brings back memories. Had Nuovo Record drivetrain on the Trek 660 I bought used in college. And black Modolo brakes with aero lovers. I felt like a real cyclist. Rode the hell out of bike until a crack formed in the head tube. It became my permanent trainer bike until a rear chainstay snapped.
On a serious note...I did manage to skewer myself pretty deeply with a uncapped FD cable. Hurt like hell.
On a serious note...I did manage to skewer myself pretty deeply with a uncapped FD cable. Hurt like hell.
#43
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: Québec, Canada
Posts: 2,184
Bikes: SL8 Pro, TCR beater
Liked 599 Times
in
451 Posts
Brings back memories. Had Nuovo Record drivetrain on the Trek 660 I bought used in college. And black Modolo brakes with aero lovers. I felt like a real cyclist. Rode the hell out of bike until a crack formed in the head tube. It became my permanent trainer bike until a rear chainstay snapped.
On a serious note...I did manage to skewer myself pretty deeply with a uncapped FD cable. Hurt like hell.
On a serious note...I did manage to skewer myself pretty deeply with a uncapped FD cable. Hurt like hell.
#44
That also happened to me to during a fall, except I got spiked in the ankle. Also hurt like hell. Thanks to the dirt and grease and me being a tough guy the thing got infected.
#45
Senior Member
#46
Banned.
I voted 'keep it' if it is shiney metal! If plastic then...make it go away.
Those discs are really vestigial disc wheel remnants. Back in the really olden days the rear wheel was a complete disc but climate change caused them to change. It wasn't very windy 'back then' but as the climate got hotter all the dinosaurs tried to hide under the trees for relief but ended up knocking them over and trampling them so there weren't any wind breaks. The bicycles had to evolve or perish and there you have it! Dork Discs!
Those discs are really vestigial disc wheel remnants. Back in the really olden days the rear wheel was a complete disc but climate change caused them to change. It wasn't very windy 'back then' but as the climate got hotter all the dinosaurs tried to hide under the trees for relief but ended up knocking them over and trampling them so there weren't any wind breaks. The bicycles had to evolve or perish and there you have it! Dork Discs!
Likes For Cyclist753:
#47
Advocatus Diaboli
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Wherever I am
Posts: 8,836
Bikes: Merlin Cyrene, Nashbar steel CX
Liked 1,600 Times
in
1,052 Posts
#48
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Melbourne, Oz
Posts: 9,562
Bikes: https://weightweenies.starbike.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=152015&p=1404231
Liked 730 Times
in
519 Posts
Is the cost of perhaps a new rear derailleur, chain, paint, any carbon fiber in the area, the dropout, some spokes (and perhaps the wheel) for a should-never-happen but can mishap OK for you? If so, remove the dork disc. Recently someone here posted about the mishap he just had. The $$ total was impressive.
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
If you chose not to use a dork disc, see to it if you ride conventionally spoked wheels, that the "pulling" spokes on the drive/right-hand side come off the inside of the hub flange. In other words, if you are standing on the left side of the bike (on most, you cannot see anything behind the cassettes standing on the right), those drive spokes that come off the top of the hub and are pointed back as they go to the rim. Now, those spokes should be coming out of the hub flange toward you; so you cannot see the spoke heads. They are hidden between the flange and the cassette.
If those pulling spokes are indeed on the inside, then, when you do dump the chain off the cassette into the spokes, your non-pulling spokes will do their best to reject the chain and you will minimize damage. With outside pulling, the spokes will suck your chain down deeper and the damage level goes far higher. (If you try to visualize this, you will come to the conclusion I"m full of smoke. This was the word of both my shop mechanic 40 years ago and the local guru-to be who used to hang out at our shop, the then far from famous Sheldon Brown. Also my experience. Actually I've never tried outside pulling but I do look at both the damage and lacing pattern every time I see one of those mishaps. Yes, the worst inside pulling disasters are worse than the best outside pulling disasters, but overall, inside pulling comes out far ahead. I've usually been able to jury rig and ride home. Most outside pulling - that's not remotely an option.
Ben
#49
HarborBandS
Back in my 1990's bike shop days, we knew a rider wasn't "serious" if they had a dork disk, plastic reflectors, or a kickstand.
Now that I am a mature 40-something, this seems ridiculous. Yet I still don't have bikes with any of these items. I can't shake my old bias.
And I will say, that in multiple decades of riding, including may crashes in my early years, I have never thrown a chain in to a wheel. Not once.
Now that I am a mature 40-something, this seems ridiculous. Yet I still don't have bikes with any of these items. I can't shake my old bias.
And I will say, that in multiple decades of riding, including may crashes in my early years, I have never thrown a chain in to a wheel. Not once.
#50
Fredly Fredster
Dork disks rule! My Domane still has it's dork disk. The dork disk on my 1.1 fell off several years back... sad day. All of my reflectors eventually came loose and fell off on both road bikes.