Is a Frame, is a Fram is a Frame?
#1
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
From: When not sitting in the deser I reside in Fayetteville, NC
Bikes: Raleigh Moutain Bike
Is a Frame, is a Fram is a Frame?
Im looking to buy my first bike and I think I would rather research and buy the specific components I need rather than one already made with parts I don't want. I assume that my corp component is the frame. Now if I get a good frame will I be able to easily find peices that coincide with my frame? Or is it like a computer where everything has to be strictly compatable with everything else?
#2
Newbie Extraordinaire

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 556
Likes: 0
From: Just outside San Fransicsco
Bikes: Trek 1000
The frame and wheels are what make a bike "good" or "bad," with regards to fit and ride quality. You should be far less concerned about the components, which are always upgradable anyway.
Almost any modern frame will work with almost any modern Shimano or Campy components you'd like to put on it. I can't really think of any counter-examples, in fact.
Since it's your first road bike, however, I strongly suggest that you just buy an off-the-shelf bike from a good shop that is willing to spend some time fitting you. You really, REALLY need to be able to test-drive a complete bike to know whether or not the frame fits you and feels good. The worst thing you could possibly do as a first-time buyer is to buy a frame off the internet because its specs look "good" to you, without ever having ridden it.
- Warren
Almost any modern frame will work with almost any modern Shimano or Campy components you'd like to put on it. I can't really think of any counter-examples, in fact.
Since it's your first road bike, however, I strongly suggest that you just buy an off-the-shelf bike from a good shop that is willing to spend some time fitting you. You really, REALLY need to be able to test-drive a complete bike to know whether or not the frame fits you and feels good. The worst thing you could possibly do as a first-time buyer is to buy a frame off the internet because its specs look "good" to you, without ever having ridden it.
- Warren
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 10,879
Likes: 6
From: Northern California
Originally Posted by chroot
The frame and wheels are what make a bike "good" or "bad," with regards to fit and ride quality. You should be far less concerned about the components, which are always upgradable anyway.
Almost any modern frame will work with almost any modern Shimano or Campy components you'd like to put on it. I can't really think of any counter-examples, in fact.
Since it's your first road bike, however, I strongly suggest that you just buy an off-the-shelf bike from a good shop that is willing to spend some time fitting you.
Almost any modern frame will work with almost any modern Shimano or Campy components you'd like to put on it. I can't really think of any counter-examples, in fact.
Since it's your first road bike, however, I strongly suggest that you just buy an off-the-shelf bike from a good shop that is willing to spend some time fitting you.
I agree that newbies are generally better served by buying complete pre-built bikes. Building up your own bike is only interesting if you really want certain parts that do not come on stock bikes, but newbies will not have the knowledge to pick their own parts. Also, a bike shop is usually better equiped to help you with fitting complete bikes.
#4
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 352
Likes: 0
Yeah, you'd probably be better off getting a complete bike for your first. A number of reasons such as a new cyclist won't know how to put it together, won't know what to look for, won't get fit, etc etc.
I would read this article on buying a road bike
I would read this article on buying a road bike




