Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Where Frames Made (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/270626-where-frames-made.html)

oilman_15106 02-20-07 12:24 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo
These threads usually crack me up. The frame is usually the cheapest part of the whole bike. There is not a single component group that I know of that is made in the USA or for that matter the U.S.A. either. So it is a false sense of patriotism that you display buy saying you will only buy American when the bulk of the parts are from anywhere but America.

Don't flame me here, because I do buy many American things. I just realize that many of the things we think are American made are usually not completely American made.

Just so you know USA is a city in Japan.

Botto: I love both the old and new America, not fond of Usa, though!

Didn't the FTC outlaw the "Made In USA" stuff that was actually made in USA, Japan?

G60 02-20-07 12:56 AM


Originally Posted by oilman_15106
Didn't the FTC outlaw the "Made In USA" stuff that was actually made in USA, Japan?

no. because nothing shady like that really happens.

http://www.snopes.com/business/genius/usa.asp

cs1 02-20-07 04:36 AM


Originally Posted by c_bake
This reply won't help the OP but anyway....What about the components? Shifters, wheels, carbon forks,handle bars, carbon seatpost, no way will these items be made in the USA. Kinda like buying a Harley Davidson then customiziing it with aftermarket products not made in the U.S.A. Go figure.
Late.

Yeah, know what you mean. My Lowrider has those nice Showa forks and Chinese battery. LOL

Tim

linus 02-20-07 04:58 AM

If you want to support the US, go get a couple of double cheese burger with super size fries and Coke.

WheresWaldo 02-20-07 05:35 AM


Originally Posted by G60
no. because nothing shady like that really happens.

http://www.snopes.com/business/genius/usa.asp

I use snopes too. I did not say anything was made in Usa, I just said there is a city called Usa, which there is! It's just that the Japanese did not rename it that, it was already called that. So the Snopes story is only partially correct within the scope of its limited view.

R900 02-20-07 05:36 AM

Trek makes most high end bikes in the USA, not just Madones. You'll need to check each frame, or you can email Trek customer service. Until recently the 2100 was made in the US.

Zouf 02-20-07 06:53 AM


Originally Posted by floyd landis
... because like you I'm not sure about Chinese made carbon quailty and the fact 1 factory makes like 5 companies bikes ...

Well, drop carbon as your favorite material - because if you're not sure about Chinese made carbon, you're not sure about carbon period, since it comes 90% from China + Taiwan.

And 1 factory also makes 5 company mp3 players (Foxconn), and cell phones (Foxconn again), and laptops, and... so I would suggest getting an 8-track tape player, and a set of drums to communicate, and some paper + pencil...

botto 02-20-07 07:06 AM


Originally Posted by teterider
Contrary to many posts and many posters in this forum, wanting to buy American is a good thing. We all buy lots and lots of foreign stuff everyday without hesitation, so there is nothing wrong with wanting to keep a US factory worker employed. As you will see now from this comment, there are so many people who simply have no clue why someone would want to this and enjoy flaming anyone who actually wants to buy american. I kid you not when I say in another forum on this topic someone posted that it wouldn't matter if all manufacturing left the US, oh and they threw in that the US flag was meaningless.

too much 'meaning' is attached to the stars & stripes (specifically post 9/11).

Namenda 02-20-07 07:11 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo
I use snopes too. I did not say anything was made in Usa, I just said there is a city called Usa, which there is! It's just that the Japanese did not rename it that, it was already called that. So the Snopes story is only partially correct within the scope of its limited view.


So, which part of the snopes article is incorrect? And how all-encompassing must this artice be, to say that no products were ever made in Usa, Japan...and then shipped here with a misleading label? Is there another aspect of this non-existant "scam" that wasn't addressed?

botto 02-20-07 07:12 AM


Originally Posted by Surferbruce
here's an incomplete list of builders who do ti and at least deserve a look. all here in the U.S.A.
Cherry Cycles
Fred Parr
Edge Cycles
David Wilson
Ogle Bike Works
Dean
Desalvo
James Frames
Roark Custom Bicycles
Primus Mootry
Gilmour
Rex Cycles
Kish
Kelson
HiTi
Holland
El Camino Fabrication
Rogue Cycles
Sramek
Strong
Zanotti
Ti Cycles
not to say that Sevens aren't great. I just met a couple who bought a pair for their 25th wedding anniversary and love em. If you're friends all have Sevens already though, why not do something different?

Don't forget J.P. Weigle

WheresWaldo 02-20-07 07:14 AM


Originally Posted by Namenda
So, which part of the snopes article is incorrect? And how all-encompassing must this artice be, to say that no products were ever made in Usa, Japan...and then shipped here with a misleading label? Is there another aspect of this non-existant "scam" that wasn't addressed?

Your reading to much into this, Snopes suggests that, according to the legend, the city was renamed. This is simply not true and they do not say that the city of Usa had that name already.

I have no idea if anything is actually manufactured there.

Namenda 02-20-07 07:18 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo
Your reading to much into this, Snopes suggests that the city was renamed, although not explicitly saying so. This is simply not true.

I have no idea if anything is actually manufactured there.


No, the snopes article says that Usa "was not creating (sic) by renaming another town". I'm just reading what is there, nothing more.

WheresWaldo 02-20-07 07:19 AM


Originally Posted by Namenda
No, the snopes article says that Usa "was not creating (sic) by renaming another town". I'm just reading what is there, nothing more.

Sorry, need coffee. Apparently I read more there than there was.

FYI, Usa has been there since at least the 8th Century.

Besides you responded before I edited my response, are you sitting on this thread this morning? :D

Namenda 02-20-07 07:22 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo
Sorry, need coffee. Apparently I read more there than there was.

FYI, Usa has been there since at least the 8th Century.

Besides you responded before I edited my response, are you sitting on this thread this morning? :D


Just went and got my second cup...my daughter woke up waaay too early this morning, and I'm suffering. School vacation week is for the birds.:D

WheresWaldo 02-20-07 07:24 AM

I was awakened by my dog this morning, who insisted on whining until someone let her out at 6:30, she usually sleeps until 8:00. Although she is Made in America, she is still called an English Lab.

Now I am going to get my cup, while I take a break from BF and browse the Dell Small Business site.

acorn_user 02-20-07 07:29 AM

Surely it's a good thing to support American industry? These guys have jobs and families too.
And it's not like making stuff here makes it totally uncompetitive.
Anyway, good on the OP for wanting to support industry in this country.

botto 02-20-07 07:31 AM


Originally Posted by acorn_user
Surely it's a good thing to support American industry? These guys have jobs and families too.
And it's not like making stuff here makes it totally uncompetitive.
Anyway, good on the OP for wanting to support industry in this country.

acorn_user
Senior Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Newcastle-upon-Tyne

?

Namenda 02-20-07 07:36 AM


Originally Posted by botto
acorn_user
Senior Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Newcastle-upon-Tyne

?


That's not in Mississippi, is it?

botto 02-20-07 07:45 AM


Originally Posted by Namenda
That's not in Mississippi, is it?

http://lorien.ncl.ac.uk/ming/Dept/Ncl/images/ukmap.jpg

Namenda 02-20-07 07:47 AM


Aberdeen is in England?!:eek:

I had no idea Kurt Cobain was British.:D

botto 02-20-07 07:52 AM


Originally Posted by Namenda
Aberdeen is in England?!:eek:

I had no idea Kurt Cobain was British.:D

Ecosse.

Namenda 02-20-07 07:57 AM


Originally Posted by botto
Ecosse.


You're right...those flannel shirts did favor kilts.

StanSeven 02-20-07 07:59 AM


Originally Posted by onkey
hmmm

on all my bikes, my frame is the most expensive part of the bike. isn't that how it should be? (no offense to people riding cheap frames with expensive groupo's)

example:

legend ti st - $4,095 dura-ace group - $1,500??

if crown jewel - $2,200 dura-ace group - $1,500?


cheers

Aw, man. You got it all wrong. If you have Legend Ti and IF Crown Jewel frames, you need $2,500 wheelsets, $350 CF bars and $180 CF stems, $250 saddles with $200 CF seatposts, and a $200 Ti kickstand. :)

merlinextraligh 02-20-07 07:59 AM


Originally Posted by teterider
Contrary to many posts and many posters in this forum, wanting to buy American is a good thing. We all buy lots and lots of foreign stuff everyday without hesitation, so there is nothing wrong with wanting to keep a US factory worker employed. As you will see now from this comment, there are so many people who simply have no clue why someone would want to this and enjoy flaming anyone who actually wants to buy american. I kid you not when I say in another forum on this topic someone posted that it wouldn't matter if all manufacturing left the US, oh and they threw in that the US flag was meaningless.


Read Capitalism and Freedom by Milton Friedman, then you'll see why the first statement is misguided, although well intended, and why it doesn't matter if all manufacturing left the US (and by the way it won't). http://www.amazon.com/Capitalism-Fre...e=UTF8&s=books

There are a couple of simple principles, most notably compartive advantage, and specialization that allow free trade to raise everybody's standard of living. It's not a zero sum game.

No way I can convince you of this in a forum post. But if you read the book (by a Nobel Laureate in Economics) you might get a new perspective.

ElJamoquio 02-20-07 08:27 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo
There is not a single component group that I know of that is made in the USA or for that matter the U.S.A. either. So it is a false sense of patriotism that you display buy saying you will only buy American when the bulk of the parts are from anywhere but America.

Where are SRAM parts made?

ElJamoquio 02-20-07 08:30 AM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh
Read Capitalism and Freedom by Milton Friedman, then you'll see why the first statement is misguided, although well intended, and why it doesn't matter if all manufacturing left the US (and by the way it won't). http://www.amazon.com/Capitalism-Fre...e=UTF8&s=books

<Politics and Religion> I haven't read the book, but to think the entire country is going to get skilled jobs is farfetched; and guiding the country to a situation where the only job available to high school graduates is flipping burgers seems to be a bad idea. </Politics and Religion>

TMB 02-20-07 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio
Where are SRAM parts made?


For the most part Taiwan and China.

There is a difference between an American company sourcing re-labelled parts out of another country and the parts being made in the US.

ElJamoquio 02-20-07 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by waytoomanybikes
There is a difference between an American company sourcing re-labelled parts out of another country and the parts being made in the US.

I recognize that an American company can manufacture parts overseas, which is why I asked. I don't believe SRAM re-labels anything, however.

WheresWaldo 02-20-07 08:51 AM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio
I recognize that an American company can manufacture parts overseas, which is why I asked. I don't believe SRAM re-labels anything, however.

SRAM owns TruVativ, correct? I thought that Gigantex made much of the TruVativ carbon stuff.

oilman_15106 02-20-07 09:24 AM


Originally Posted by R900
Trek makes most high end bikes in the USA, not just Madones. You'll need to check each frame, or you can email Trek customer service. Until recently the 2100 was made in the US.

Check the Trek entry level road bikes: Made in China sticker proudly displayed on the headtube.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:13 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.