Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Ipod? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/454784-ipod.html)

Dice 08-19-08 05:16 AM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 7299323)
It could be said that I am making an assumtion that is not supported by evidence, but I believe it is a reasonable assumption and I am too lazy to do the research to back it. However, it is easily disproved. Somebody just needs to show the vehicle code from one state that allows earphones in both ears. My argument is not necessarily that it is unsafe to do so, just that it is illegal to do so, and therefore it is not a strawman argument.

In any event, it most certainly IS illegal in California and I live in California so I will not do it. Of course, you can call my hypocritical too if you want, because I will admit that I do not stop at stop signs if I know there are no cars and I will sometimes roll through a light after stopping if is clear.

I got so confused while reading your arguments between uke and you that I forgot which laws you were fighting over :injured: However I always find it easier to bias for the person who doesn't post massive pics with sayings on them.

ehidle 08-19-08 05:29 AM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 7299151)
But regardless, I do try to follow traffic laws, and whether you like it or not, riding with earphones on both ears is always illegal

Not true.


Originally Posted by umd (Post 7299151)
Somebody just needs to show the vehicle code from one state that allows earphones in both ears.

Everything is allowed unless there is a law that says it isn't. There's no point in passing a law that says something is allowed unless it is created to usurp a lower government's law that says it isn't.

chipcom 08-19-08 05:48 AM


Originally Posted by daredevil (Post 7298987)
One ear bud? Volume down? Huh? Maybe if you're listening to some podcast or something.

For me, I want the best sound possible. For that, isolation is necessary.

Now, consider this. I ride a two lane rural highway on my commute. I SEE everything that approaches front and back EVERY F'N TIME. Why the hell do I need to hear them too? Explain that to me you natural selection and safety nanny goons! Come up with the scenario for me that says I need to hear em.

What if Elmer Fudd was in an electric car with a Klingon cloaking device and snuck up on you...weally, weally quiet? It could happen! :roflmao2:

chipcom 08-19-08 05:54 AM


Originally Posted by collegeskier (Post 7300264)
And since you are required to follow the rules of the road this would apply to cyclist too.

Ok let's go with this logic for a second. Most states require vehicles to be equipped with mirrors, so that means since the rules of the road apply to cyclists, you must ride with mirrors, right?

I don't think so...but nice try.

ncherry 08-19-08 06:01 AM


Originally Posted by BarracksSi (Post 7284142)
No. They think they can hear cars, which is a nice illusion until they try to get around a bus and get creamed by a Prius.

The new hybrids (not just the Prius) have caused me some concern. I often listen for the hum of the tires and the engine but the Prius' engine is not loud enough to notice so it throws me off a bit. I'm still getting used to that. Luckily the folks with the hybrid Lexus aren't as concerned for the environment as they are with they're status symbol and gun the motor to pass most cyclist. ;)

umd 08-19-08 08:16 AM


Originally Posted by collegeskier (Post 7300264)
Not to come to umd defense but it is illegal to ride in Illionis with a headset in (other then a cellphone headset or hearing aid).

Illinois law states that you may not wear a headset while driving. Headsets are defined as any device, other than a hearing aid, that allows the wearer to hear or receive electronic communications. (The use
of a single-sided headset or earpiece with a cellular or other mobile telephone is permitted.) Motorcycle, motor-driven cycle and moped operators may use intercom helmets that permit drivers and/or passengers to speak to one another.

And since you are required to follow the rules of the road this would apply to cyclist too.

I think it depends on how the laws are written. In california there are codes that specifically relate to the equipment of a motor vehicle and separately that of a bicycle, but then that a bicyclist is subject to the "duties applicable to the driver of a vehicle".


Originally Posted by Bicycle Use. VC 21200
Every person riding a bicycle upon a street or highway has all the rights and is subject to all the duties applicable to the driver of a vehicle, including the provisions of law dealing with driving under the influence of alcoholic beverages or drugs, except those provisions which by their very nature can have no application.

But they also include bicycles specifically regardling "headsets"


Originally Posted by Headsets and Earplugs. VC 27400
No person operating any vehicle, including a bicycle shall wear any headset covering, or any earplugs in, both ears. There are exceptions for persons operating authorized emergency vehicles, special construction or maintenance equipment and refuse collection equipment, and for any person wearing personal hearing protectors designed to attenuate injurious noise levels and which do not inhibit the wearers' ability to hear a siren or horn from an emergency vehicle or horn form another motor vehicle, and for any person using a prosthetic device which aids the hard of hearing.


Originally Posted by chipcom (Post 7300667)
Ok let's go with this logic for a second. Most states require vehicles to be equipped with mirrors, so that means since the rules of the road apply to cyclists, you must ride with mirrors, right?

I don't think so...but nice try.

I suppose it is possible that a state's code may be written that way but it is probably more likely that a bicycle and motor vehicle's equipment are defined separately, as in California. I learned my lesson last night so I'm not going to claim that must be the case.


Originally Posted by collegeskier (Post 7300264)
Also interesting umd is putting for a legal argument while starting a thread about no handed riding which is illegal in most states.

I've researched the handlebar thing before but searched again and the closest I could find for California is

Originally Posted by Carrying Articles. VC 21205
No person operating a bicycle shall carry any package, bundle, or article which prevents the operator from keeping at least one hand upon the handlebars.

Which requires the rider to be able to keep one hand on the bar but does not require actually keeping a hand on the bars.

umd 08-19-08 08:35 AM

Since Illinois was brought up...

(625 ILCS 5/1‑125.7)
Sec. 1‑125.7. Headset receiver. Any device, other than a hearing aid, designed to be worn on a person's head that enables the wearer to hear or receive electronic communications.
(Source: P.A. 90‑89, eff. 1‑1‑98.)

(625 ILCS 5/12‑610) (from Ch. 95 1/2, par. 12‑610)
Sec. 12‑610. Headset receivers.
(a) Except as provided under Section 11‑1403.3, no driver of a motor vehicle on the highways of this State shall wear headset receivers while driving.
(b) This Section does not prohibit the use of a headset type receiving equipment used exclusively for safety or traffic engineering studies, by law enforcement personnel on duty, or emergency medical services and fire service personnel.
(c) This Section does not prohibit the use of any single sided headset type receiving and transmitting equipment designed to be used in or on one ear which is used exclusively for providing two‑way radio vocal communications by an individual in possession of a current and valid novice class or higher amateur radio license issued by the Federal Communications Commission and an amateur radio operator special registration plate issued under Section 3‑607 of this Code.
(d) This Section does not prohibit the use of a single‑sided headset or earpiece with a cellular or other mobile telephone.
(Source: P.A. 92‑152, eff. 7‑25‑01.)

(625 ILCS 5/1‑146) (from Ch. 95 1/2, par. 1‑146)
Sec. 1‑146. Motor vehicle. Every vehicle which is self‑propelled and every vehicle which is propelled by electric power obtained from overhead trolley wires, but not operated upon rails, except for vehicles moved solely by human power and motorized wheelchairs. For this Act, motor vehicles are divided into two divisions:
First Division: Those motor vehicles which are designed for the carrying of not more than 10 persons.
Second Division: Those motor vehicles which are designed for carrying more than 10 persons, those motor vehicles designed or used for living quarters, those motor vehicles which are designed for pulling or carrying freight, cargo or implements of husbandry, and those motor vehicles of the First Division remodelled for use and used as motor vehicles of the Second Division.
(Source: P.A. 85‑1010.)

So, you win :thumb:

daredevil 08-19-08 09:10 AM

Now, now umd, you are starting to obsess. :D

I've got the 1st gen iPod charged up and I'm ready to take a nice ride around the secluded back roads of my neighborhood. Anybody that thinks I'm putting anybody at risk on this particular ride hasn't a clue so don't judge me.

Dice 08-19-08 09:11 AM

I wish I had the patience and smarts to read all that.

umd 08-19-08 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by daredevil (Post 7301652)
Now, now umd, you are starting to obsess. :D

It's what I do:D


Originally Posted by daredevil (Post 7301652)
I've got the 1st gen iPod charged up and I'm ready to take a nice ride around the secluded back roads of my neighborhood. Anybody that thinks I'm putting anybody at risk on this particular ride hasn't a clue so don't judge me.

Enjoy :beer:

chipcom 08-19-08 11:02 AM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 7301436)
So, you win :thumb:

You ain't figured out yet that cycling is the ONLY place you little weenies got a shot at beating me at anything? :D

Tsuru 08-19-08 11:50 AM


Originally Posted by Murrays (Post 7284459)
I get plenty of joy simply being on my bike without the need for listening to artificial noise.

god... what kind of music DO you listen to if you call it "artificial noise"? I feel for you.


*edit - oh, and I listen to the ipod when I ride alone, just not too loud. Never on group rides.

daredevil 08-19-08 12:35 PM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 7302155)



Enjoy :beer:

Thanks, I did. You know when I come across a situation where it may be helpful to hear, it doesn't take much to pause the machine. :)

bjlswim 08-22-08 04:06 PM

You ride with mirrors on your bike, how cute.

CharlieWoo 08-22-08 04:10 PM

Today I turned my iPod off briefly. I started hearing my bike making all sorts of noises and trucks coming up from behind, so I turned it back on. What a relief!

FIVE ONE SIX 08-22-08 04:44 PM

as far as the law goes concerning earphones, i guess it may vary by state, but i know that in NY state you may only wear an earphone in 1 ear for it to be considered legal. i'm not going to say that i didn't break that law earlier today though...

and like others, i always use an iPod when i ride alone, and never when i ride with a group. i know someone that used to use one when he rode with groups, and was one of the most hated riders because of it. i personally find that disrespectful, because communication is very important when riding with a group...

BarracksSi 08-22-08 11:02 PM


Originally Posted by CharlieWoo (Post 7325185)
Today I turned my iPod off briefly. I started hearing my bike making all sorts of noises and trucks coming up from behind, so I turned it back on. What a relief!

Sure, you heard the trucks -- but as they were passing, could you hear what was right behind them? Or were they still friggin' loud, drowning out everything else (including the noises your bike was making)?

C_Heath 08-22-08 11:08 PM

Ill take a chance. Not to bad traffic wise here anyhow. I cant stand to not have it on. Cept for at the beach. I dont wear it there.

Snow_canuck 08-22-08 11:09 PM

BTW it's iPod.

Motman320 08-22-08 11:09 PM

**** THAT. **** NO. NO WAY IN HELL. NEVER!!!!

I would ****ing kill myself before I rode with my ipod again.

I usually always rode with it on my cruiser, but after my first ride on my real bike I will never look back. I got half way into my ride and I just ****ing ripped that **** out of my ears and put it in my pocket. Not dangerous, it just bothers me. I love music and I am never in my car longer than 30 seconds without music, but now I just will never ride with it. I used to think I would ride with it, but now... NEVER!!!!

daredevil 08-23-08 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by bjlswim (Post 7325172)
You ride with mirrors on your bike, how cute.

and some of these guys have them on their cars too...and more than one! I think they're for something like 360 degree awareness or some horsecrap like that. Who needs that on a bike anyway? :rolleyes:

Somebody said something about them being more necessary if you are in traffic. Silly stuff man.

I've been spelling iPod correctly.:)

daredevil 08-23-08 07:41 AM


Originally Posted by Motman320 (Post 7326932)
**** THAT. **** NO. NO WAY IN HELL. NEVER!!!!

I would ****ing kill myself before I rode with my ipod again.

I usually always rode with it on my cruiser, but after my first ride on my real bike I will never look back. I got half way into my ride and I just ****ing ripped that **** out of my ears and put it in my pocket. Not dangerous, it just bothers me. I love music and I am never in my car longer than 30 seconds without music, but now I just will never ride with it. I used to think I would ride with it, but now... NEVER!!!!

Bothers you how? Makes you nervous?

dr_max 08-23-08 09:11 AM

I do never listen to music on my bike or whenever I'm training (running or cycling).

I once used my MP3 player while running but I found it annoying when the earphone kept falling because of the sweet in my ear.

On my bike I've never thought of using my MP3 because I hate it when other people do so and transform themselves in public dangers.

patentcad 08-23-08 02:43 PM

The idiots on BF (and there are so many of you) keep me entertained no matter what continent I'm on. Oddly enough, I am eternally in your debt.

umd 08-23-08 07:56 PM


Originally Posted by Motman320 (Post 7326932)
**** THAT. **** NO. NO WAY IN HELL. NEVER!!!!

I would ****ing kill myself before I rode with my ipod again.

I usually always rode with it on my cruiser, but after my first ride on my real bike I will never look back. I got half way into my ride and I just ****ing ripped that **** out of my ears and put it in my pocket. Not dangerous, it just bothers me. I love music and I am never in my car longer than 30 seconds without music, but now I just will never ride with it. I used to think I would ride with it, but now... NEVER!!!!

Well aren't you special.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:12 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.