Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Tip of fork fell off. WTH!!! (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/902333-tip-fork-fell-off-wth.html)

denvertrout 07-18-13 08:32 PM

Tip of fork fell off. WTH!!!
 
1 Attachment(s)
Noticed my brake was rubbing and went to move the brake assembly, but it was tight. Noticed the whole fork move and saw a straight, perfectly round line around the fork. Took the wheel off and the tip fell right off in my hand. Now what? Will bring it by a trek store in the morning. 2005 madone, so not sure what they will say. Anyone ever see this before?

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=329897

Homebrew01 07-18-13 08:37 PM

Bummer
Some good epoxy, and a nut & bolt for mechanical interferance should take care of it.

WhyFi 07-18-13 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by Homebrew01 (Post 15865836)
Bummer
Duct tape should take care of it.

Correcter.

martinus 07-18-13 08:48 PM

You need to tighten the QR more ...

bianchi10 07-18-13 09:41 PM

Hahahaha I'm sorry that is SO not funny, because I would be PISSED if that happened. That is horrible. Hopefully Trek will take care of you and replace the frame, at which point you can sell it and get a better bike.

Freaking Trek...

rpenmanparker 07-18-13 09:59 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15866022)
Hahahaha I'm sorry that is SO not funny, because I would be PISSED if that happened. That is horrible. Hopefully Trek will take care of you and replace the frame, at which point you can sell it and get a better bike.

Freaking Trek...

You think new frame? Or just new fork? I had a defective Trek fork years ago back in the glued and screwed aluminum tube days. Actually I did get a new frame. I don't think they have the ability to match new forks with old frames, so it is easier to replace the whole thing. No choice of color though. They sent me a crappy robin's egg blue color frame with pink decals that they couldn't sell. A few years later I finally sent it back to them for repainting to candy apple red when I discovered some corrosion bubbles in the paint around the bottom bracket. Long gone now. Time heals all Trek problems.

bianchi10 07-18-13 10:02 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 15866067)
You think new frame? Or just new fork? I had a defective Trek fork years ago back in the glued and screwed aluminum tube days. Actually I did get a new frame. I don't think they have the ability to match new forks with old frames, so it is easier to replace the whole thing. No choice of color though. They sent me a crappy robin's egg blue color frame with pink decals that they couldn't sell. A few years later I finally sent it back to them for repainting to candy apple red when I discovered some corrosion bubbles in the paint around the bottom bracket. Long gone now. Time heals all Trek problems.

Lol that would suck to not have the ability to chose the color! And if I got a Robin egg blue with pink lettering I would freak!

whitemax 07-19-13 06:26 AM


Originally Posted by denvertrout (Post 15865821)
Noticed my brake was rubbing and went to move the brake assembly, but it was tight. Noticed the whole fork move and saw a straight, perfectly round line around the fork. Took the wheel off and the tip fell right off in my hand. Now what? Will bring it by a trek store in the morning. 2005 madone, so not sure what they will say. Anyone ever see this before?

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=329897

I'd be surprised if they didn't at least get you another fork or replace the frame. Glad you caught the issue before it caught you.

Nachoman 07-19-13 06:49 AM

That obviously could have been a potential disaster.

ahsposo 07-19-13 06:57 AM


Originally Posted by Nachoman (Post 15866671)
That obviously could have been a potential disaster.

Yeah, thank goodness for those lawyer tabs. <-----------------------------------sarcasm

pallen 07-19-13 07:49 AM

That does not inspire confidence

tagaproject6 07-19-13 07:51 AM

A replacement fork is in order, unless Trek weasels out of it by saying it is neglect/abuse.

denvertrout 07-19-13 08:29 AM

So, after doing some research what I have figured out is that the dropout is aluminum and it is bonded somehow to the carbon fork. The other side is also showing "wear", nothing loose, but a very faint line where the two pieces meet. Trek said to bring to dealer with receipt, which I don't have. Hopefully will not be to big a problem and they will work with me. No abuse, no crashes, do not over tighten when putting the wheel on. I am crossing my fingers...

pallen 07-19-13 08:33 AM

There is no abuse that would cause a part to become unbounded. Cracks, scratches, dents, maybe, but unbonding like that is a manufacturing defect.

roadwarrior 07-19-13 08:37 AM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15866022)
Hahahaha I'm sorry that is SO not funny, because I would be PISSED if that happened. That is horrible. Hopefully Trek will take care of you and replace the frame, at which point you can sell it and get a better bike.

Freaking Trek...



http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=329941

True...it's never ever the rider's fault. No potholes, didn't ever cram down the QR, etc...

And to the OP, I have no clue why it broke, I just love posts where people think nothing should ever ever break.

Another "41" moment.

kv501 07-19-13 08:39 AM


Originally Posted by roadwarrior (Post 15867008)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=329941

True...it's never ever the rider's fault. No potholes, didn't ever cram down the QR, etc...

And to the OP, I have no clue why it broke, I just love posts where people think nothing should ever ever break.

Another "41" moment.

Kind of like when his Ti skewers broke.

roadwarrior 07-19-13 08:39 AM


Originally Posted by denvertrout (Post 15866978)
So, after doing some research what I have figured out is that the dropout is aluminum and it is bonded somehow to the carbon fork. The other side is also showing "wear", nothing loose, but a very faint line where the two pieces meet. Trek said to bring to dealer with receipt, which I don't have. Hopefully will not be to big a problem and they will work with me. No abuse, no crashes, do not over tighten when putting the wheel on. I am crossing my fingers...

Did you buy the bike used?

If not, is this the shop from which you bought the bike?

If not and you bought it from a shop , call the shop and get a purchase record. They can email it to you no problem.

Warranty extends to the original owner.

merlinextraligh 07-19-13 08:50 AM

^ True.

Based on history, Trek is likely not going to warrant that if you're not the original purchaser. They might just to get the fork off the street, given the safety impication.

You could expoxy it, and likely be fine, or you could send it to someone like Calfee.

Personally, i'd just buy a new fork for the piece of mind, if they don't replace it under warranty.

kv501 07-19-13 09:03 AM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 15867059)
^ True.

Based on history, Trek is likely not going to warrant that if you're not the original purchaser. They might just to get the fork off the street, given the safety impication.

You could expoxy it, and likely be fine, or you could send it to someone like Calfee.

Personally, i'd just buy a new fork for the piece of mind, if they don't replace it under warranty.

Calfee doesn't work on forks or handlebars. Kind of a bummer.

Leinster 07-19-13 09:12 AM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8-QNAwUdHUQ

bianchi10 07-19-13 09:13 AM


Originally Posted by roadwarrior (Post 15867008)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=329941

True...it's never ever the rider's fault. No potholes, didn't ever cram down the QR, etc...

And the OP, I have no clue why it broke, I just love posts where people think nothing should ever ever break.

Another "41" moment.

Pipe down dude. I was being sarcastic about the coincidence of it happening to a trek since most people around here think trek is such a sub par company. I didn't imply anything that equipment should last forever.

tagaproject6 07-19-13 09:18 AM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15867139)
Pipe down dude. I was being sarcastic about the coincidence of it happening to a trek since most people around here think trek is such a sub par company. I didn't imply anything that equipment should last forever.

Incorrect, you imply everything and anything that any 41 reader can lift out of any post. LOL!

E.g. From your post, I can see that you are a plumber and that you believe Trek is an evil corporation and that you are a snazzy dresser! :P

bianchi10 07-19-13 09:26 AM


Originally Posted by tagaproject6 (Post 15867159)
Incorrect, you imply everything and anything that any 41 reader can lift out of any post. LOL!

E.g. From your post, I can see that you are a plumber and that you believe Trek is an evil corporation and that you are a snazzy dresser! :P

Hahaha you are very wise

denvertrout 07-19-13 03:59 PM

I am not the original owner. Brought it to the shop and they said I was probably our of luck since I am not original owner. They are going to try to submit a claim anyway, or at least contact their rep and see what if anything can be done. I am tempted to try to "glue" it myself, but not sure that is worth the risk and will likely buy a new one.

Turnin2 07-19-13 04:33 PM

Glue it?
You live in Denver? Like in the mountains?
That's not going to be on your mind when you are bombing it downhill?

Buy a new one.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:17 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.