carbon fork vs full carbon
#5
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 1,549
Likes: 0
From: Go Ducks!
Generally speaking, the knock on aluminum is a harsh ride.
Adding carbon bits is an effort to alleviate this. It works on my Sequoia; it's smooth and comfortable. But these guys are right- there's just way too many variables here for any kind of blanket statements.
Other than this, and this'll probably turn out to be debatable, but here goes... an all-carbon bike is your best shot at BOTH maximum stiffness AND a tolerably comfortable ride.
Adding carbon bits is an effort to alleviate this. It works on my Sequoia; it's smooth and comfortable. But these guys are right- there's just way too many variables here for any kind of blanket statements.
Other than this, and this'll probably turn out to be debatable, but here goes... an all-carbon bike is your best shot at BOTH maximum stiffness AND a tolerably comfortable ride.
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 345
Likes: 0
Bikes: 2012 BMC SLR01, 2012 Yeti ASR5, 2013 Trek Crockett
It depends on what kind of ride you want. I have 1 aluminum road bike with carbon seat stays and a carbon fork, and 1 full carbon bike. The full carbon bike is a much better bike, its lighter and significantly more comfortable, but it costs alot more. The carbon seat stays on the aluminum bike may help a little, but they are not designed to be as compliant as the stays on my carbon bike.
I think other features of the bike other than material contribute to how a bike rides. You can design an aluminum bike to be fairly comfortable, and can design a carbon bike to be stiff and harsh.
I recommend test riding a bunch of different bikes to figure out if a carbon bike is worth the extra money. If you can't afford it, there is nothing wrong with an aluminum bike.
I think other features of the bike other than material contribute to how a bike rides. You can design an aluminum bike to be fairly comfortable, and can design a carbon bike to be stiff and harsh.
I recommend test riding a bunch of different bikes to figure out if a carbon bike is worth the extra money. If you can't afford it, there is nothing wrong with an aluminum bike.





Which bikes are you checking out?

