Gatorskins Dilemma...
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 1,631
Likes: 328
Gatorskins Dilemma...
Had some older Conti tires on one of my bikes for years - an UltraGatorskin and a Duraskin+K that replaced the other UltraGatorskin back when it wore-out. I didn't ride that bike all that much so those tires lasted forever. I can't recall them ever flatting, and perhaps more importantly - I always really liked the way they rode. Beginning of this year I started riding that bike a lot and pretty quickly finished-off those old tires.
Even though I had other tires on hand, decided that since I liked those old Contis so much, I wanted the same thing again. Was sorry to find that those particular tires were discontinued or changed?
So I ended up buying some wire-bead DuraSkin Gatorskins with PolyX and hoping for the best. To say the least, I am disappointed. Yes, the damn things are indeed seemingly puncture-proof - but they ride like ****. Harsh, handle poorly, and give no feedback about what is going on under me.
IIRC...once upon a time were some kinds of Gatorskins not popular here? Does anybody here have experience with the particular tires I got? Maybe I am a Luddite being over-critical because they were not exactly what I had before and wanted again? But more importantly - anybody here ever have and like those older Ultra Gatorskin tires? And now that they are history - what tire did you choose as replacement?
Thanx for any help...
Even though I had other tires on hand, decided that since I liked those old Contis so much, I wanted the same thing again. Was sorry to find that those particular tires were discontinued or changed?
So I ended up buying some wire-bead DuraSkin Gatorskins with PolyX and hoping for the best. To say the least, I am disappointed. Yes, the damn things are indeed seemingly puncture-proof - but they ride like ****. Harsh, handle poorly, and give no feedback about what is going on under me.
IIRC...once upon a time were some kinds of Gatorskins not popular here? Does anybody here have experience with the particular tires I got? Maybe I am a Luddite being over-critical because they were not exactly what I had before and wanted again? But more importantly - anybody here ever have and like those older Ultra Gatorskin tires? And now that they are history - what tire did you choose as replacement?
Thanx for any help...
#2
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 281
Likes: 0
From: VA -> IN
Bikes: ones with two wheels
Had some older Conti tires on one of my bikes for years - an UltraGatorskin and a Duraskin+K that replaced the other UltraGatorskin back when it wore-out. I didn't ride that bike all that much so those tires lasted forever. I can't recall them ever flatting, and perhaps more importantly - I always really liked the way they rode. Beginning of this year I started riding that bike a lot and pretty quickly finished-off those old tires.
Even though I had other tires on hand, decided that since I liked those old Contis so much, I wanted the same thing again. Was sorry to find that those particular tires were discontinued or changed?
So I ended up buying some wire-bead DuraSkin Gatorskins with PolyX and hoping for the best. To say the least, I am disappointed. Yes, the damn things are indeed seemingly puncture-proof - but they ride like ****. Harsh, handle poorly, and give no feedback about what is going on under me.
IIRC...once upon a time were some kinds of Gatorskins not popular here? Does anybody here have experience with the particular tires I got? Maybe I am a Luddite being over-critical because they were not exactly what I had before and wanted again? But more importantly - anybody here ever have and like those older Ultra Gatorskin tires? And now that they are history - what tire did you choose as replacement?
Thanx for any help...
Even though I had other tires on hand, decided that since I liked those old Contis so much, I wanted the same thing again. Was sorry to find that those particular tires were discontinued or changed?
So I ended up buying some wire-bead DuraSkin Gatorskins with PolyX and hoping for the best. To say the least, I am disappointed. Yes, the damn things are indeed seemingly puncture-proof - but they ride like ****. Harsh, handle poorly, and give no feedback about what is going on under me.
IIRC...once upon a time were some kinds of Gatorskins not popular here? Does anybody here have experience with the particular tires I got? Maybe I am a Luddite being over-critical because they were not exactly what I had before and wanted again? But more importantly - anybody here ever have and like those older Ultra Gatorskin tires? And now that they are history - what tire did you choose as replacement?
Thanx for any help...
#3
I can't help you with your question, but inquiring minds (okay, mine) want to know: what bike are you running such tires on? I'm a little surprised to hear you running something other than an Italian racing tire, quite frankly.
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 493
Likes: 0
From: Chicago
Bikes: KHS Flite 100 Road Track Fissie Biek
Vittoria Randos are best tires, go with those. But anyways, gators are known for having ****ty sidewalls, now I've never had a problem with mine, a couple flats but those were tube issues, not tire related. But yeah like someone said above try out the gatorhardshells
#6
Your cog is slipping.



Joined: May 2009
Posts: 26,053
Likes: 100
From: Beverly MA
Bikes: EAI Bareknuckle
Yeah...not FG/SS or Eyetie specific - for my B'stone roadie...
"Vittoria Randos are best tires, go with those."???
Has this forum been completely overrun by dumbasses making blanket statements?
I don't claim to be a hot**** or anything but is there nobody here who can actually comment on how their choice of tires ride?
Maybe is too much to ask?
"Vittoria Randos are best tires, go with those."???
Has this forum been completely overrun by dumbasses making blanket statements?
I don't claim to be a hot**** or anything but is there nobody here who can actually comment on how their choice of tires ride?
Maybe is too much to ask?
- try different tires, making note of which ones you like best.
- continue to buy those.
#9
Okay --- since you asked:
What can I tell you? I ride a ton of miles, much of it commuting on terrible roads, on my bike shod with skinny Veloflex tires and let me tell you, besides being fast-rolling and sharp handling, they ride pretty damn comfortably. Not to mention those suckers are amazingly tough for racy tires.
#10
THE STUFFED


Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 12,671
Likes: 21
From: San Francisco, CA
Bikes: R. Sachs Simplicity; EAI Bareknuckle; Madone Gen 8
Don't just stick with the big tire companies, try what the smaller guys offer!
#13
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 1,631
Likes: 328
Lot can happen in a couple of days...glad this got cleaned-up, but can't help wondering what I missed after I left 
While suggestions to just try different tires do make sense at first glance - I have got to think that could get pretty expensive, or take a long time. Something I was trying to avoid
Thanx for reminding me...
I would not have anything else on my Cinelli but the reason for my question was that as much as I like them, I did not think Veloflex Masters are quite "right" for my bike that needs tires.
Sorry for asking a bicycling question in a bicycling forum - guess I should have known better...

While suggestions to just try different tires do make sense at first glance - I have got to think that could get pretty expensive, or take a long time. Something I was trying to avoid
Thanx for reminding me...
I would not have anything else on my Cinelli but the reason for my question was that as much as I like them, I did not think Veloflex Masters are quite "right" for my bike that needs tires.
Sorry for asking a bicycling question in a bicycling forum - guess I should have known better...
#15
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 2,751
Likes: 19
From: Seattlish
Bikes: SWorks Stumpy, Haibike Xduro RX, Crave SS





