Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   Do people purposely choose to ride a too small frame simply because it looks better? (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/1024814-do-people-purposely-choose-ride-too-small-frame-simply-because-looks-better.html)

Muffin Man 08-14-15 09:57 PM


Originally Posted by BilbroSwaggins (Post 18076815)
speaking of pedalroom, your dean titanium is #2 on the featured board on the main page

Used to be the top featured. I think there's a new featured bike every week.

BilbroSwaggins 08-14-15 10:05 PM


Originally Posted by Muffin Man (Post 18076818)
Used to be the top featured. I think there's a new featured bike every week.

thats pretty rad dude.

Muffin Man 08-14-15 10:08 PM


Originally Posted by BilbroSwaggins (Post 18076834)
thats pretty rad dude.

Thanks!

jlafitte 08-14-15 10:28 PM


Originally Posted by thedapperest (Post 18075230)
My Winsdor was 54cm and I bought it simply because the the rest of the components were so good, I knew it was gonna be small but I figured I'd deal with it (at the time I thought my optimal range was 56-59 until I rode a friends and realized it was more 57-62). My position on that thing was so aggressive and it eventually started hurting my back, nevertheless, I kept my stem slammed and flipped and rode it like that until I built up my Flite. Now I'm considering building it up with risers and throwing in some spacers to be a beater.

Excellent plan. :thumb:

ggpepper 08-15-15 09:09 AM

I'm 5'9 and one of my favorite rides is my 63cm KiloTT. Sure the saddle is slammed and I have to lean the frame on dismount to save the fellows. But I love the ride, it's fast and aggressive. Don't really care what people think.

TejanoTrackie 08-15-15 09:19 AM

#KiloTT

TenSpeedV2 08-15-15 09:30 AM


Originally Posted by BilbroSwaggins (Post 18076801)
must be nice. my lbs stocks bikes made for giants. 54CM is the norm and maybe you'll see a 52 every once in a while. meanwhile i have to find 49 and 48 cm bikes......

Those are not gigantic sizes. Your height does not coincide with them, that's all. Try riding a 58. Not all shops carry them for some reason. I have seen a lot of them just max out at a 56cm and they can always order you a 58, or gasp, a 61 if needed.

BilbroSwaggins 08-15-15 04:27 PM


Originally Posted by TenSpeedV2 (Post 18077559)
Not all shops carry them for some reason. I have seen a lot of them just max out at a 56cm and they can always order you a 58, or gasp, a 61 if needed.

I have never been able to buy anything in stock from the shop.

catgita 08-15-15 06:28 PM

Step 1: Walk into shop.
Step 2: Say "where the fixies"
3: Say "sick"
4: Buy, or have parents buy.
5: Ride the wrong way down the street, on the sidewalk, cross against the light without looking while crossing diagonally to the other side.

Steps 1-4 and step 5 are actually the same behavior.

oops, not PC...
steriotypes are just too tempting

Regulatori 08-15-15 08:26 PM

One thing I never understood the range of manufacturer sizing compared to what people are riding.

Example...I was looking at a Pista Special that came in 49cm-63cm.

My bike is a 55cm but I could also fit a 57cm and I'm just under 5'10". If you go through sizing threads (one example.. http://www.bikeforums.net/singlespee...ta-owners.html ), you'll find a LOT of the riders in the 6 feet to 6'2" range are riding 55cm and 57cm bikes. That's just one thread...I see a bunch of bike forum threads with similar heights/bike sizing (6'-6'3" riding 55cm and 57cm bikes).

Yeah, I know, it depends on body proportions....but if so many riders in the low 6' - 6'3" range are riding 55cm and 57cm...what height do you need to be to ride a 63cm bike comfortably? That's 3-4 sizes larger. 6'8"-7'?

prooftheory 08-15-15 08:43 PM

You know that height by itself isn't a great heuristic for bike sizing, right?

Dave Cutter 08-15-15 09:14 PM

Buy ye cycling kit and bicycle to please others.... eat to please thy self ~ Ben Franklin

thedapperest 08-15-15 10:40 PM


Originally Posted by prooftheory (Post 18079001)
You know that height by itself isn't a great heuristic for bike sizing, right?

I sure hope they do. I'm 5'10.5 and my frame is 60.5 ctt but I know guys taller than me who ride smaller frames which are perfect fit

Mumonkan 08-16-15 03:43 AM

for fun, im the exact same height, yet my road bike has a 52 ST and 55 TT. best fitting bike ive owned.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lq...10bho4_500.gif

gear64 08-16-15 06:53 AM

I look at bike fit like wine club. Excessively large might be mad dog. Excessively small might be grape juice. There's lots of good stuff in between and who cares about oakiness, frutiness, or any other obsessively descriptive term one may choose to ponder over. Currently I ride three different frame sizes; smallest and largest are my favorites. Largest also has longest stem. One could argue this may be my max comfortable setup, then smaller just makes me more upright; but I've never found the smaller ones to be uncomfortable or unpleasant. On the other hand riding my daughters 16" mtb for a tune up is definitely grape juice.

tomatsu 08-16-15 08:19 AM

What the **** is juice? I want some grape drink, baby!

Night_shift 08-16-15 09:13 AM

I measured myself using about 2-3 fit calculators you can find online. All said I was roughly 54cm, 170mm crank, standard stuff. In real life when I ride stuff that is 52-56 it really works for me! Crazy right?

Andersper 08-16-15 10:43 AM

A lot of frames larger than 58 cm look a bit out of proportion, even with 700c wheels. That's just a matter of personal preference, but I'm guessing some tall people feel the same way and go for smaller frames.

hairnet 08-16-15 12:55 PM


Originally Posted by Andersper (Post 18079888)
A lot of frames larger than 58 cm look a bit out of proportion, even with 700c wheels. That's just a matter of personal preference, but I'm guessing some tall people feel the same way and go for smaller frames.

It's funny when people see my bikes and ask if the wheels are 26". No, they're 700c

Happened a lot with these two bikes.
http://i.imgur.com/LnJCKQj.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/MkI7tnA.jpg

jlafitte 08-16-15 07:59 PM


Originally Posted by hairnet (Post 18080149)
It's funny when people see my bikes and ask if the wheels are 26". No, they're 700c

Happened a lot with these two bikes.
http://i.imgur.com/LnJCKQj.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/MkI7tnA.jpg

Dude who are you, André the giant? :D

SquidPuppet 08-17-15 11:16 AM


Originally Posted by Andersper (Post 18079888)
A lot of frames larger than 58 cm look a bit out of proportion, even with 700c wheels. That's just a matter of personal preference, but I'm guessing some tall people feel the same way and go for smaller frames.

That's funny. I'm not tall, yet I prefer the way big bikes look. To me, bikes 58cm and under look too small for 700c wheels. All in the eye I guess.

Muffin Man 08-17-15 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by Mumonkan (Post 18079331)
for fun, im the exact same height, yet my road bike has a 52 ST and 55 TT. best fitting bike ive owned.

Do you have a really long torso/arms? You don't have much post showing, and your stem is decent length.

Andersper 08-17-15 02:01 PM


Originally Posted by hairnet (Post 18080149)
It's funny when people see my bikes and ask if the wheels are 26". No, they're 700c

Happened a lot with these two bikes.
http://i.imgur.com/LnJCKQj.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/MkI7tnA.jpg

Do you guys still have problems with smog in LA? Never mind, you're probably too tall to be bothered by it anyway. ;)


Originally Posted by SquidPuppet (Post 18082699)
That's funny. I'm not tall, yet I prefer the way big bikes look. To me, bikes 58cm and under look too small for 700c wheels. All in the eye I guess.

Interesting. What's your take on double top tube designs that Rivendell (and others) produce?

SquidPuppet 08-17-15 03:00 PM


Originally Posted by Andersper (Post 18083305)
Do you guys still have problems with smog in LA? Never mind, you're probably too tall to be bothered by it anyway. ;)

LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO




Interesting. What's your take on double top tube designs that Rivendell (and others) produce?
I like them if they are set up certain ways. I don't like them with drop bars. It's just a looks thing.

Mumonkan 08-17-15 03:42 PM


Originally Posted by Muffin Man (Post 18082955)
Do you have a really long torso/arms? You don't have much post showing, and your stem is decent length.

my limbs are short but my torso is long, i have a hard time getting shirts long enough that dont make me look like this guy

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...uL._UX385_.jpg

my inseam is only 30", i think an ideal seattube would be around 50 for me, but i think that might require a sloped TT


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:20 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.