chainline questions for my new Paul hubs
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 486
Likes: 0
From: Louisville, Ky
Bikes: Surly Cross-Check, 1983 Specialized Stumpjumper
chainline questions for my new Paul hubs
hey everybody,
Just scored some sweet Paul hubs and I need to know what length bottom bracket I need for their 44mm chainline. Here is the trick, I am using some NOS Shimano 600 cranks (also sweet and cheap). I really want to run the chainring on outer position. After doing some searches on the board I found that a 107mm bottom bracket with 600's will give you a 42mm chainline, but Paul hubs have a weird 44mm thing going on. Any body using Paul hubs with a road double? or have any suggestions? I guess IF people are correct then I need a 109mm bottom bracket. Aren't many of those besides Phil and Sugino. I have found tons of 110mm. I believe that when ran with gears my cranks use a 113mm BB, which gives a outer chainline of 46mm (according to Sheldon), so take away 2mm and that gives me 44 chainline. So its either a 109 or 111? Maybe....crap.....
Anyways, any ideas or help is appreciated.
thanks
Just scored some sweet Paul hubs and I need to know what length bottom bracket I need for their 44mm chainline. Here is the trick, I am using some NOS Shimano 600 cranks (also sweet and cheap). I really want to run the chainring on outer position. After doing some searches on the board I found that a 107mm bottom bracket with 600's will give you a 42mm chainline, but Paul hubs have a weird 44mm thing going on. Any body using Paul hubs with a road double? or have any suggestions? I guess IF people are correct then I need a 109mm bottom bracket. Aren't many of those besides Phil and Sugino. I have found tons of 110mm. I believe that when ran with gears my cranks use a 113mm BB, which gives a outer chainline of 46mm (according to Sheldon), so take away 2mm and that gives me 44 chainline. So its either a 109 or 111? Maybe....crap.....
Anyways, any ideas or help is appreciated.
thanks
#2
109 is total length so if the added length were symmetrical on both sides you'd need 4 more millimeters to add 2mm to your chainline.
the added length is not symmetrical, however, and i recall reading that 107 and 109 both have the same length on the drive side, meaning the extra 2mm does you no good whatsoever. but i cannot verify this, a search might help.
good luck with your dilemma. i'd take it to a shop or co op since they should have a range of bb's on hand.
the added length is not symmetrical, however, and i recall reading that 107 and 109 both have the same length on the drive side, meaning the extra 2mm does you no good whatsoever. but i cannot verify this, a search might help.
good luck with your dilemma. i'd take it to a shop or co op since they should have a range of bb's on hand.
#3
jack of one or two trades
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 5,640
Likes: 0
From: Suburbia, CT
Bikes: Old-ass gearie hardtail MTB, fix-converted Centurion LeMans commuter, SS hardtail monster MTB
Originally Posted by dirtyphotons
good luck with your dilemma. i'd take it to a shop or co op since they should have a range of bb's on hand.




