Handlebar types... what are the pro's and con's
#26

(sorry to the guy who posted this in the riser fan club thread)
While I like risers for in-city riding the track stem basically negated everything good about risers. The stem and bars are now sitting on my work bench and the bullhorns are back on.
Risers work well with a normal stem because they keep you head up in traffic. It's not about hand positions, it's about visibility for me.
To the OP, experiment with as many bars as you can. You will find something that YOU like and post it here for everyone to tell you how wrong you are.
#27
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 79
Likes: 0



Personally I like your bike alot! flat bars are cool. I dunno how i would feel riding it, but i'm down to try a bunch. esp cuz i work at a Co-Op now and I can get stuff cheap as BALLS
#30
Originally Posted by TheDLake
The only thing I don't like (Besides the cheesy foam) is my upright position. I feel the the bars a bit too low causing my arms to get tired. Maybe it's my setup.. maybe its me.
This seems like a fit issue.
#31
ive got chopped and flipped bars on my bike, and honestly, it's the most comfortable setup i can imagine. ive ridden drop bars before, and after a while, my back gets tired and they can suck for city visibility IMO. flatbars are plain silly -- not only do they look rediculous on a track bike, but they make the bike ride like a waaaay oversized BMX without a seat drop.
sure people will argue that im wrong and that flatbars are so cool, but this is just my $.02
sure people will argue that im wrong and that flatbars are so cool, but this is just my $.02
#32
I personally think Porteur and Randonneur style bars are really comfortable, depending on the geometry. Mustache bars are just too weird looking, so I have never tried them.
#33
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 187
Likes: 0
I just put those on my (stock) flatbar road bike. I like them. It's got those thumb shifters so I moved those to the stem and the brake levers on the straights near the ends of the bar. I think I installed it upside down to give me more drop (I didn't know it till i saw your pic, I thought I put them right side up). The bike shop guy found them in back so neither of us had seen anything like it(I got them reasonably cheap). The most difficult thing was taping in sections and having it look like one piece. I recommend these.
#35
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 279
Likes: 0
Some really fine points were completely missed here!
Flat bars or risers actually pick a rider's head up to see in traffic without craning the neck. They also fit better in traffic once chopped to shoulder length.
Cyclocross bars are excellent bars, not too road-y drop, wide enough for control, flared sides (like the midge) for more leverage up hills, usually more ergonomic. Salsa Bell-laps are great.
I actually have three set-ups for whatever I feel like riding that day. I run Nitto B115s for longer rides, Nitto B123s for the velodrome, and MTB risers cut down a bit for prarie paths and kicking around town. None are perfect but none are inherently flawed either.
Flat bars or risers actually pick a rider's head up to see in traffic without craning the neck. They also fit better in traffic once chopped to shoulder length.
Cyclocross bars are excellent bars, not too road-y drop, wide enough for control, flared sides (like the midge) for more leverage up hills, usually more ergonomic. Salsa Bell-laps are great.
I actually have three set-ups for whatever I feel like riding that day. I run Nitto B115s for longer rides, Nitto B123s for the velodrome, and MTB risers cut down a bit for prarie paths and kicking around town. None are perfect but none are inherently flawed either.
#37
King of the Hipsters
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 2,128
Likes: 2
From: Bend, Oregon
Bikes: Realm Cycles Custom
The "handshake" (thumb up, pinky down) position represents the strongest and most stress-free orientation of the hands on the handlebars.
This corresponds to the hoods of drop bars or the horns of bullhorns.
Sit in a hard chair with your feet aligned as if on pedals and about as far apart as on pedals.
Hold a pencil in each hand.
Lean forward and imagine holding your handlebars about as far from your hips as suits you; and begin to stand up.
Just as your bottom begins to break with the chair, look at the pencils in your hands.
The angle of the pencils indicates the angle of the hoods or horns, and the angle of your torso (as determined by the height of the bars and the length of the stem), best suited to YOUR body.
This corresponds to the hoods of drop bars or the horns of bullhorns.
Sit in a hard chair with your feet aligned as if on pedals and about as far apart as on pedals.
Hold a pencil in each hand.
Lean forward and imagine holding your handlebars about as far from your hips as suits you; and begin to stand up.
Just as your bottom begins to break with the chair, look at the pencils in your hands.
The angle of the pencils indicates the angle of the hoods or horns, and the angle of your torso (as determined by the height of the bars and the length of the stem), best suited to YOUR body.
#38
It's an old photo
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 774
Likes: 0
From: Entropia
Bikes: Cannondale R500, Specialized Hardrock
If you think about it, riding on the horizontal section of bullhorns, road drops, or even track drops gives you the same exact position as flats, although often narrower. Risers do have a rise, but that's the kind of adjustment you should be making at your stem.
#39
-
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 454
Likes: 0
From: Banned in DC
Also, you can't get much sweepback in drops.
#40
Banned
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 5,317
Likes: 0
From: GA
Sit in a hard chair with your feet aligned as if on pedals and about as far apart as on pedals.
Hold a pencil in each hand.
Lean forward and imagine holding your handlebars about as far from your hips as suits you; and begin to stand up.
Just as your bottom begins to break with the chair, look at the pencils in your hands.
The angle of the pencils indicates the angle of the hoods or horns, and the angle of your torso (as determined by the height of the bars and the length of the stem), best suited to YOUR body.
Hold a pencil in each hand.
Lean forward and imagine holding your handlebars about as far from your hips as suits you; and begin to stand up.
Just as your bottom begins to break with the chair, look at the pencils in your hands.
The angle of the pencils indicates the angle of the hoods or horns, and the angle of your torso (as determined by the height of the bars and the length of the stem), best suited to YOUR body.
Likewise how you hold your hands with no load doesn't set a hard and fast rule for how you can best hold bars and apply force in all the directions needed when riding a bike.
Originally Posted by zacked
Flat bars of the same length allow for a lot more leverage than drops or bullhorns.
#41
-
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 454
Likes: 0
From: Banned in DC
You have that backwards. hold your hand like you were holding flat bars of a given length. Now pretend you are holding the hoods or horns of the same length. You will see that as you rotate your hand your forearm moves out about 2-3cms on each side. So flat bars of a given width provide the leverage of horns or drops about 4-6cms narrower.
#42
Banned
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 5,317
Likes: 0
From: GA
But since you generally use a shorter stem with drops or bullhorns than flats the difference between hoods and flat bars shouldn't be that great.
#43
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,276
Likes: 0
Perhaps you're just referencing how they're typically situated in the bicycle world, but that seems like it would be ridiculously uncomfortable if they were a foot above your pelvis. Your wrists would be angled almost to the extreme.
My girlfriend has a Schwinn World Tourist with those types of Porteur bars, or whatever it is that they're called, and they are level with the saddle. Meaning when I ride the bike, I'm slightly leaned forward with my hands placed out in front of me with my wrists hardly angled at all. With the right saddle for that kind of riding position, I actually think it's incredibly comfortable. Especially on a bicycle that I won't be riding more than 5-10 miles a day. I'm actually seriously considering putting some porteur bars with no rise on my new IRO build for that reason.
My girlfriend has a Schwinn World Tourist with those types of Porteur bars, or whatever it is that they're called, and they are level with the saddle. Meaning when I ride the bike, I'm slightly leaned forward with my hands placed out in front of me with my wrists hardly angled at all. With the right saddle for that kind of riding position, I actually think it's incredibly comfortable. Especially on a bicycle that I won't be riding more than 5-10 miles a day. I'm actually seriously considering putting some porteur bars with no rise on my new IRO build for that reason.
#44
Banned
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 5,317
Likes: 0
From: GA
Perhaps you're just referencing how they're typically situated in the bicycle world, but that seems like it would be ridiculously uncomfortable if they were a foot above your pelvis. Your wrists would be angled almost to the extreme.
My girlfriend has a Schwinn World Tourist with those types of Porteur bars, or whatever it is that they're called, and they are level with the saddle. Meaning when I ride the bike, I'm slightly leaned forward with my hands placed out in front of me with my wrists hardly angled at all. With the right saddle for that kind of riding position, I actually think it's incredibly comfortable. Especially on a bicycle that I won't be riding more than 5-10 miles a day. I'm actually seriously considering putting some porteur bars with no rise on my new IRO build for that reason.
My girlfriend has a Schwinn World Tourist with those types of Porteur bars, or whatever it is that they're called, and they are level with the saddle. Meaning when I ride the bike, I'm slightly leaned forward with my hands placed out in front of me with my wrists hardly angled at all. With the right saddle for that kind of riding position, I actually think it's incredibly comfortable. Especially on a bicycle that I won't be riding more than 5-10 miles a day. I'm actually seriously considering putting some porteur bars with no rise on my new IRO build for that reason.
#45
Guest
Posts: n/a
Flip and chops wont be any higher than your current brake hoods. If your hoods are too uncomfortable to ride on you might want to try tektro aero levers (pic); they're cheap as ****, they feel great and they're easy to brake with from the tops. The big draw of drops is multiple hand positions and cobnverting to flipnchops is basically just going to lose you that aero position while not gaining anything new.


#46
raodmaster shaman
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,431
Likes: 0
From: G-ville
i especially liked this gem from the bike snob site:
"Risers with Quill Stems
Using risers on a street bike is better than drop bars with grips on the tops. At least the rider has come to terms with the fact that he or she will be staying in the upright position. And sure, sometimes you need a little more bar height than your steer tube would otherwise allow. But very often I see bikes with quill stems and riser bars with the stem lowered to its minimum height. Why not just use regular bars and raise the stem? There's a reason you didn't see risers much until the threadless thing took over. And yes, I realize it works just fine, but it's making five lefts to go right--like using air conditioning and the heat at the same time--and consequently inelegant."
SO TRUE.
"Risers with Quill Stems
Using risers on a street bike is better than drop bars with grips on the tops. At least the rider has come to terms with the fact that he or she will be staying in the upright position. And sure, sometimes you need a little more bar height than your steer tube would otherwise allow. But very often I see bikes with quill stems and riser bars with the stem lowered to its minimum height. Why not just use regular bars and raise the stem? There's a reason you didn't see risers much until the threadless thing took over. And yes, I realize it works just fine, but it's making five lefts to go right--like using air conditioning and the heat at the same time--and consequently inelegant."
SO TRUE.
#48
slot machine
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 482
Likes: 0
From: Richmond, Va
Bikes: fuji and a Meteor
I like my road drops with a billion hand positions. The good thing about bars is they aren't that hard to change out depending on your stem. Ride a bunch of them and you may find you like some for a while and then want to change em' out. I change bars every few months between drops, flat/riser, and horns, depending on my mood.
#50
Member
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
From: SF
Bikes: SE Lager, Specialized RockHopper x2







