Foot retention
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 140
Likes: 16
From: Montréal
Bikes: Marinoni Piuma Custom
Foot retention
I want to change my pedals with better one but I don't know what to buy. Best pedals with cages or staps for around 100$. Low shipping cost to Canada.
Thanks
Thanks
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
For Bmx pedals oddesy pc's and any good strap will work. Like companies burro, r.e.load, ynot, fyxation, and seagull. Some of those companies have pedals/strap combos where you can get both for like $75 which isn't bad. For cages I like the double all city plastic cages, i'm not a pro when it comes to straps though I would just use the all city double straps but i'm sure there's better ones for more money.
#4
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 140
Likes: 16
From: Montréal
Bikes: Marinoni Piuma Custom
For Bmx pedals oddesy pc's and any good strap will work. Like companies burro, r.e.load, ynot, fyxation, and seagull. Some of those companies have pedals/strap combos where you can get both for like $75 which isn't bad. For cages I like the double all city plastic cages, i'm not a pro when it comes to straps though I would just use the all city double straps but i'm sure there's better ones for more money.
#5
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
I honestly can't think of any I like both. On my 3 bikes I have 1 with straps and cages, 1 with spd shoes and clipless pedals, then the other I have odyssey pedals and ynot straps. If you skid a lot your foot will never pop out of the bmx pedals and straps. 1 advantage I can think of is how easy you can adjust them for different size shoes. Just pull the velcro loosen/tighten it, then synch it back down. Ynot staps are very good though, I've been using the same pair daily for 4 years.
#7
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 140
Likes: 16
From: Montréal
Bikes: Marinoni Piuma Custom
Here's what i found:
-fyxation gates pedals/straps for 85$US (with shipping)
-Steve Hamilton Pedal by Animal/holdFast straps for 87$US (with shipping)
-VP-531 BMX Pedal/YNOT Pedal Strap for 118$ CAN (108$US) (with shipping)
Best combo for my $$ ?
-fyxation gates pedals/straps for 85$US (with shipping)
-Steve Hamilton Pedal by Animal/holdFast straps for 87$US (with shipping)
-VP-531 BMX Pedal/YNOT Pedal Strap for 118$ CAN (108$US) (with shipping)
Best combo for my $$ ?
#8
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
I would go for the cheapest, they're all very similar. Fyxation or Holdfast and call it a day, you won't tell a difference between either.
:EDIT I heard of the metal clips on holdfast digging into feet, don't know how true that is but fyxation's don't have those metal pieces so i'd go with them.
:EDIT I heard of the metal clips on holdfast digging into feet, don't know how true that is but fyxation's don't have those metal pieces so i'd go with them.
Last edited by Philasteve; 06-13-14 at 01:28 PM.
#10
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
Yeah I would get those before anything else, like I said, my Ynot straps are going 4 years strong. I forgot Ynot was located in Toronto, Tom Mosher work's for them.
Last edited by Philasteve; 06-13-14 at 02:50 PM.
#11
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 140
Likes: 16
From: Montréal
Bikes: Marinoni Piuma Custom
#12
Grumpy Old Bugga
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 4,229
Likes: 9
From: Adelaide, AUSTRALIA
Bikes: Hillbrick, Malvern Star Oppy S2, Europa (R.I.P.)
Oh you wild, reckless man. Next you'll be suggesting people read stickies 
Now, addressing the question at hand, you'll be amazed at what you find out there if you look and ask silly questions. For example, some years ago now, my son was after general purpose pedals and was sold a set of Giant MTB pedals. Just generic platform pedals with nylon double gate toe clips and nylon straps for a dirt cheap price. Surprisingly, they were very good and we bought a second set. Both sets are still working well and are preferred pedals for bikes intended for casual use. On the other hand, I've wasted a lot of money buying 'good' pedals and fancy clips and straps that haven't proven as successful, though the problem has usually been the pedals (I'se got wide old pharts footsies).
My Hillbrick is happy with MKS Urban platforms with MKS double gate toe clips and straps that were sold on special as a set by Scrod at the time I was buying them. While he doesn't have a special on at the moment, the message is to look around and you might be amazed at what you'll find.
Interestingly though, the best pedals I've come across are the Shimano M324 ... modified somewhat. These are platform one side and SPD clipless the other. However, you can remove the SPD clips. This leaves an aluminium spigot which is easy to grind off giving you a single sided platform pedal. Fit MKS toe clips and leather straps and you have a wide, smooth, solid pedal that can be rebuilt if needed (you don't need the special tools as I proved with one of my sets). I've used two sets of these for nearly a decade now and they are excellent. The MKS Urban should be better but the mangled Shimanos still work well.
Realistically, your options are only limited by your willingness to search and think laterally. On the other hand, my spare parts box is full of platform pedals that should have worked but which didn't. The rotten things are a bit like saddles, you need to find something that suits your feet, your shoes and your lifestyle.

Now, addressing the question at hand, you'll be amazed at what you find out there if you look and ask silly questions. For example, some years ago now, my son was after general purpose pedals and was sold a set of Giant MTB pedals. Just generic platform pedals with nylon double gate toe clips and nylon straps for a dirt cheap price. Surprisingly, they were very good and we bought a second set. Both sets are still working well and are preferred pedals for bikes intended for casual use. On the other hand, I've wasted a lot of money buying 'good' pedals and fancy clips and straps that haven't proven as successful, though the problem has usually been the pedals (I'se got wide old pharts footsies).
My Hillbrick is happy with MKS Urban platforms with MKS double gate toe clips and straps that were sold on special as a set by Scrod at the time I was buying them. While he doesn't have a special on at the moment, the message is to look around and you might be amazed at what you'll find.
Interestingly though, the best pedals I've come across are the Shimano M324 ... modified somewhat. These are platform one side and SPD clipless the other. However, you can remove the SPD clips. This leaves an aluminium spigot which is easy to grind off giving you a single sided platform pedal. Fit MKS toe clips and leather straps and you have a wide, smooth, solid pedal that can be rebuilt if needed (you don't need the special tools as I proved with one of my sets). I've used two sets of these for nearly a decade now and they are excellent. The MKS Urban should be better but the mangled Shimanos still work well.
Realistically, your options are only limited by your willingness to search and think laterally. On the other hand, my spare parts box is full of platform pedals that should have worked but which didn't. The rotten things are a bit like saddles, you need to find something that suits your feet, your shoes and your lifestyle.
#13
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
Oh you wild, reckless man. Next you'll be suggesting people read stickies 
Now, addressing the question at hand, you'll be amazed at what you find out there if you look and ask silly questions. For example, some years ago now, my son was after general purpose pedals and was sold a set of Giant MTB pedals. Just generic platform pedals with nylon double gate toe clips and nylon straps for a dirt cheap price. Surprisingly, they were very good and we bought a second set. Both sets are still working well and are preferred pedals for bikes intended for casual use. On the other hand, I've wasted a lot of money buying 'good' pedals and fancy clips and straps that haven't proven as successful, though the problem has usually been the pedals (I'se got wide old pharts footsies).
My Hillbrick is happy with MKS Urban platforms with MKS double gate toe clips and straps that were sold on special as a set by Scrod at the time I was buying them. While he doesn't have a special on at the moment, the message is to look around and you might be amazed at what you'll find.
Interestingly though, the best pedals I've come across are the Shimano M324 ... modified somewhat. These are platform one side and SPD clipless the other. However, you can remove the SPD clips. This leaves an aluminium spigot which is easy to grind off giving you a single sided platform pedal. Fit MKS toe clips and leather straps and you have a wide, smooth, solid pedal that can be rebuilt if needed (you don't need the special tools as I proved with one of my sets). I've used two sets of these for nearly a decade now and they are excellent. The MKS Urban should be better but the mangled Shimanos still work well.
Realistically, your options are only limited by your willingness to search and think laterally. On the other hand, my spare parts box is full of platform pedals that should have worked but which didn't. The rotten things are a bit like saddles, you need to find something that suits your feet, your shoes and your lifestyle.

Now, addressing the question at hand, you'll be amazed at what you find out there if you look and ask silly questions. For example, some years ago now, my son was after general purpose pedals and was sold a set of Giant MTB pedals. Just generic platform pedals with nylon double gate toe clips and nylon straps for a dirt cheap price. Surprisingly, they were very good and we bought a second set. Both sets are still working well and are preferred pedals for bikes intended for casual use. On the other hand, I've wasted a lot of money buying 'good' pedals and fancy clips and straps that haven't proven as successful, though the problem has usually been the pedals (I'se got wide old pharts footsies).
My Hillbrick is happy with MKS Urban platforms with MKS double gate toe clips and straps that were sold on special as a set by Scrod at the time I was buying them. While he doesn't have a special on at the moment, the message is to look around and you might be amazed at what you'll find.
Interestingly though, the best pedals I've come across are the Shimano M324 ... modified somewhat. These are platform one side and SPD clipless the other. However, you can remove the SPD clips. This leaves an aluminium spigot which is easy to grind off giving you a single sided platform pedal. Fit MKS toe clips and leather straps and you have a wide, smooth, solid pedal that can be rebuilt if needed (you don't need the special tools as I proved with one of my sets). I've used two sets of these for nearly a decade now and they are excellent. The MKS Urban should be better but the mangled Shimanos still work well.
Realistically, your options are only limited by your willingness to search and think laterally. On the other hand, my spare parts box is full of platform pedals that should have worked but which didn't. The rotten things are a bit like saddles, you need to find something that suits your feet, your shoes and your lifestyle.
#15
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,452
Likes: 12
From: Philadelphia
Bikes: Surly CreamRoller. 98 Giant Rincon. SE UVT
Yeah I really enjoy my bikew oth my pcs and ynot straps. Those things grip my feet like no other. Ive never bombed a hill at top speeds and had to worry about my foot popping out doing a little speed check skid.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ModeratedUser24102018
Singlespeed & Fixed Gear
28
09-03-16 05:03 AM








