Something is bent?
#1
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Something is bent?
I can't figure out what is wrong, or what has the bend. My chain is tighter at certain points in the rotation of the crank, but I can;t figure out if the front crank is bent or if it the rear hub that is bent. Also I don't think it would be because the axle isn't aligned correctly because then the chain wouldn't be loose at certain points and tight at others. I was about to order a new crank set but I thought I should ask first, any help is appreciated. Thanks.
#2
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 205
Likes: 2
From: Alameda, CA
Bikes: Windsor The Hour Plus, 2014 Novara Verita, Windsor Oxford
I can't figure out what is wrong, or what has the bend. My chain is tighter at certain points in the rotation of the crank, but I can;t figure out if the front crank is bent or if it the rear hub that is bent. Also I don't think it would be because the axle isn't aligned correctly because then the chain wouldn't be loose at certain points and tight at others. I was about to order a new crank set but I thought I should ask first, any help is appreciated. Thanks.
#7
ABQ
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 164
Likes: 4
I have never bought into that "centering the chainring" argument. Seems to me the chain itself is the big collection of variables here. A couple hundred plates held together with a couple hundred pins...can you say "tolerance stackup"?
#8
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 205
Likes: 2
From: Alameda, CA
Bikes: Windsor The Hour Plus, 2014 Novara Verita, Windsor Oxford
Statistically the error in the links should cancel out not add up.
#9
Broken neck Ken


Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 5,221
Likes: 3,516
From: Portland, OR
Bikes: Trek Domane SL6 Gen 3, Soma Fog Cutter, Detroit Bikes Sparrow FG, Trek Mt Track XCNimbus MUni
A frankenchain may well have stretched and nonstretched sections. But my money is on the chainring offcenter and/or out of round. I see this frequently on homegrown ss/fg conversions that come in the co op.
#10
ABQ
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 164
Likes: 4
TX,
Point taken.
But then connecting the ends of the chain together, and picking random segments to wrap around each of the cog and the chainring, would influence the tension on each unsupported side. The machining of the teeth on the cog and chainring now affect the tension of those segments, which will change as the crank is turned.
I think you have a better chance of eliminating a "cyclic" tightening/loosening of the chain if you pick a different set of teeth to wrap. The gear ratio is going to affect the "skid patch", ie the number of unique combos of teeth engaged at both the cog and chainring.
Runout is easy to check. It would seem to be difficult to make an "out of round" ring or cog, unless they are simply stamped.
Point taken.
But then connecting the ends of the chain together, and picking random segments to wrap around each of the cog and the chainring, would influence the tension on each unsupported side. The machining of the teeth on the cog and chainring now affect the tension of those segments, which will change as the crank is turned.
I think you have a better chance of eliminating a "cyclic" tightening/loosening of the chain if you pick a different set of teeth to wrap. The gear ratio is going to affect the "skid patch", ie the number of unique combos of teeth engaged at both the cog and chainring.
Runout is easy to check. It would seem to be difficult to make an "out of round" ring or cog, unless they are simply stamped.
Last edited by Onfixiate; 12-27-14 at 03:52 PM.







