Erik_A

Which drop-bar shifters (and group) do you recommend for long distance bikepacking / loaded touring? Shimano 105 ST-5700 vs SRAM Force. I have the opportunity to get either group for about the same price. So far, I have been all Shimano on my road and CX bikes, but have heard that some folks love the SRAM doubletap shifters. In either case I would be using them with a compatible MTB rear derailleur (XT or X-9).

fietsbob

Road bike gearing may only be suitable when you bring nothing but Money and a rainjacket on your tours .

you go all in for either , both are market competitors , try bikes with both and Decide for your self. .
apparently to be anywhere near functional in mix and match look for 9 speed stuff Bar end more than Brifters

they want to be more incompatible all the time to stay mutually exclusive ..

Ford vs GMC which is the better Pickup truck?

staehpj1

I thought that the 10 speed Shimano brifters weren't compatible with MTB drive trains. Am I mistaken about that?

Erik_A

Thanks for all of the advice. I am planing on carrying about 50-60 lbs of gear in bikepacking frame, seat, and bar bags. Riding on everything but super-technical singletrack (mainly fire-roads and gravel).

10 speed Shimano is compatible with 9-speed and older MTB rear derailleurs.

niknak

I would go with Sram 10 speed. Sram rear derailleurs have stiffer springs, which can help overcome cable friction, a common problem in dirty conditions. The Type 2 mountain derailleurs also reduce chain slap and have a nice cage lock feature for easier rear wheel removal.