Thinking of a handlebar bag. I've looked at the Revelate Sweetroll, Ortlieb Handlebar pack, several others, Axioms etc. even some Chinese stuff (I figure) on Amazon.
I'm looking at max maybe 4-5 days, campgrounds, and I'm trying to avoid the added expense of a front rack and front panniers which I would rarely use.
So I'm looking at something for maybe clothing, or sleeping bag or some other soft "bulk" items to free up pannier & rear rack space. So a small bag isn't adequate. (And realistically, I haven't loaded up with what I think I would carry for 4 days so not sure what I need, if anything) Just looking for a relatively inexpensive option for additional storage.
Maybe a Revelate Harness with a larger drybag? (I have plenty of drybags from kayaking)

Go with the Revelate Harness. It has more versatility then most of the other handlebar bags. You can carry a little or carry a lot, it adjusts better to fit anything. It's also cheaper.

I have gone with a longer and thinner than average stuff sack and a couple cheap straps (Coughlins). The straps were their "sleeping bag straps" and were about $2. The stuff sack was one that a tent came in. I wanted a bit of space between the bag and the bars so I used short pieces of pvc pipe as spacers. The straps went through the pipe, around the bar, and around the bag. It worked great and was essentially free since I always have some spare straps on hand and the bag was a tent bag that I had.

I have done a similar setup with the same straps but with a bundle of gear rolled up in my tarp. That worked fine as well.

In a couple cases I strapped a little camera bag on the bundle for quick access. It also contained my phone, money, plastic, and ID.

I have also used traditional handlebar bags, but they are more suited to stuff like cameras, phones, and other small items you want handy. I like the Nashbar Elite bag pretty well and it was inexpensive.

Since you have drybags, etc., if you want a DIY project.
How to make your own DIY handlebar roll harness | Bicycle Times Magazine

I have not tried this so I can't recommend for or against

That was my thought at well. With the sweet roll or the Ortlieb, I'd be limited to the bag that is attached. With the revelate harness I'd have the option of different bags, or even strapping on something like a tarp or tent.

This may be a good option to try out for an overnighter and see how it works out. Could possibly even rig it so that one COULD use a small traditional bar bag with the bundle.

Another option. I'm pretty handy rigging or making things. Just need to find where to get a sheet of polyethylene. I've also used some Kydex on ocassion. It would be simple to roll & form a half loop then attach straps.


Thanks for the input guys!