Are all 'track' bikes created equal?
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
Are all 'track' bikes created equal?
So being in the market for my first fixie/track bike (to get me through until I can afford a second track only bike) to get into racing with I was recommend the Mercier Kilo TT after doing some research it seems this bike may or may not be the best bike to start on with in my budget (ID like to stay 500 or less but can maybe go up to a fuji track classic price) So my question is are all the bikes marketed as track truely track geo or is say the mercier or the fuji going to give me problems since I'm new?
#2
I think most of the steel entry level 'track' bikes are going to be the same. The two you listed are similar and will be fine for your first year or two of track riding. You might be better off getting a used aluminum bike, but that is going to be less desirable as a street bike. However, finding a used bike will be easier after you spend some time at the track and get a better idea of what is out there and what you want. The steel bikes do OK as double duty street/track.
One simple thing I look at with track geometry is bottom bracket drop. Road bikes have drop around 70mm, track bikes around 55mm. Obviously if it has braze ons for brackets or water bottles, its not really a track frame.
One simple thing I look at with track geometry is bottom bracket drop. Road bikes have drop around 70mm, track bikes around 55mm. Obviously if it has braze ons for brackets or water bottles, its not really a track frame.
#3
Which track are you going to be riding on? What do you think your percentage of track vs street use for this bike? Would this be the only bike you own?
Having rack braze ons and water bottle bosses doesnt really effect if a bike would make a good track racer or not.
Having rack braze ons and water bottle bosses doesnt really effect if a bike would make a good track racer or not.
#4
If you don't mind me asking, how much do you weigh? (Or just answer that you are "lighter", "normal", or "heavier"). If you are lighter guy, a Fuji Track may not be a bad option for the money. Lighter guys won't flex it as much if at all.
The Kilo TT is HEAVY. I raced with a guy that raced one. One day I gave him a ride home and I loaded it on to my car and was like "HOLY MOLY this is heavy." The guy maybe weighed 140lbs. The bike felt like it was 25lbs (heavy tires, heavy tubes, steel bars, double straps, heavy saddle, etc...). The bike was like 17.8% of his body weight.
I think bike/body weight ratio is an interesting number to look into.
The Kilo TT is HEAVY. I raced with a guy that raced one. One day I gave him a ride home and I loaded it on to my car and was like "HOLY MOLY this is heavy." The guy maybe weighed 140lbs. The bike felt like it was 25lbs (heavy tires, heavy tubes, steel bars, double straps, heavy saddle, etc...). The bike was like 17.8% of his body weight.
I think bike/body weight ratio is an interesting number to look into.
Last edited by carleton; 07-21-11 at 11:06 AM.
#5
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
And for the moment it will be my only bike (budget restrictions are only going to allow one purchase right now would like to stay under 500 but of course can be flexible if theres just some amazing deal.
As far as track:street Im not sure yet since its my only bike I will have to train on the streets with it too
@carelton last weigh in was 182lbs 10% bf
Last edited by jduvall; 07-21-11 at 11:17 AM.
#7
The Northtexas superdome in frisco texas.
And for the moment it will be my only bike (budget restrictions are only going to allow one purchase right now would like to stay under 500 but of course can be flexible if theres just some amazing deal.
As far as track:street Im not sure yet since its my only bike I will have to train on the streets with it too
@carelton last weigh in was 182lbs 10% bf
And for the moment it will be my only bike (budget restrictions are only going to allow one purchase right now would like to stay under 500 but of course can be flexible if theres just some amazing deal.
As far as track:street Im not sure yet since its my only bike I will have to train on the streets with it too
@carelton last weigh in was 182lbs 10% bf
If you are 182, I'd say shoot for an aluminum bike. Any steel bike that you won't flex will be sort of (if not really) heavy.
If you can save a bit more and/or stretch the budget, the Felt TK3 is a great bike. There are lots of others, too. Of course, used in good condition is always a better value. Maybe the velodrome has a forum. I know there is some sort of Texas Bike Racing forum. Maybe check classifieds there.
#8
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
The Superdrome is awesome.
If you are 182, I'd say shoot for an aluminum bike. Any steel bike that you won't flex will be sort of (if not really) heavy.
If you can save a bit more and/or stretch the budget, the Felt TK3 is a great bike. There are lots of others, too. Of course, used in good condition is always a better value. Maybe the velodrome has a forum. I know there is some sort of Texas Bike Racing forum. Maybe check classifieds there.
If you are 182, I'd say shoot for an aluminum bike. Any steel bike that you won't flex will be sort of (if not really) heavy.
If you can save a bit more and/or stretch the budget, the Felt TK3 is a great bike. There are lots of others, too. Of course, used in good condition is always a better value. Maybe the velodrome has a forum. I know there is some sort of Texas Bike Racing forum. Maybe check classifieds there.
#9
- Buy only a track bike and ride on the track several times a week and maybe on the rollers at home.
- Buy a road bike and train on the road then rent/borrow a track bike for race days.
- Have both road and track bikes and train where it's most effective and/or convenient. This is the most popular option for several reasons.
If you live near the track and it's not a problem to go 3-5 days/nights a week, then the first option might be best right now. I know people who have done that with great success. If you live far away and will see the track only a few days a month, then a road bike will be more useful. There are lots of people that also do that with great success. I live 3.5 hours from the nearest velodrome. But, most serious racers have both and use the most appropriate bike for the job at hand.
#10
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
If your goal is to race on the track competitively you will either:
- Buy only a track bike and ride on the track several times a week and maybe on the rollers at home.
- Buy a road bike and train on the road then rent/borrow a track bike for race days.
- Have both road and track bikes and train where it's most effective and/or convenient. This is the most popular option for several reasons.
If you live near the track and it's not a problem to go 3-5 days/nights a week, then the first option might be best right now. I know people who have done that with great success. If you live far away and will see the track only a few days a month, then a road bike will be more useful. There are lots of people that also do that with great success. I live 3.5 hours from the nearest velodrome. But, most serious racers have both and use the most appropriate bike for the job at hand.
- Buy only a track bike and ride on the track several times a week and maybe on the rollers at home.
- Buy a road bike and train on the road then rent/borrow a track bike for race days.
- Have both road and track bikes and train where it's most effective and/or convenient. This is the most popular option for several reasons.
If you live near the track and it's not a problem to go 3-5 days/nights a week, then the first option might be best right now. I know people who have done that with great success. If you live far away and will see the track only a few days a month, then a road bike will be more useful. There are lots of people that also do that with great success. I live 3.5 hours from the nearest velodrome. But, most serious racers have both and use the most appropriate bike for the job at hand.
#12
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
Im ordering the pedals off of ebay Shimanos for I think it was 40 bucks so thats not to bad. The shoes yeah those will cost some but not to bad I'll buy those from the shop that I pick up the felt from. My wife is very supportive in this endeavor cause its something I've very interested in (I was a road racer when we started dating, but I've since packed on a lot more muscle making me better suited to sprint or hopefully track than road race, not to say I wont still dabble in that now and then)
#14
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
#15
Senior Member

Joined: May 2002
Posts: 10,123
Likes: 4
From: Near Portland, OR
Bikes: Three road bikes. Two track bikes.
The R540 will do nicely; certainly much better than anything you can get with the Nashbar logo on it. Myself, I use the old-style Ultegra pedals, which are really very similar to the R540s (the clip and pedal body are identical, I think the only difference are the axle and bearings).
__________________
Cat 2 Track, Cat 3 Road.
"If you’re new enough [to racing] that you would ask such question, then i would hazard a guess that if you just made up a workout that sounded hard to do, and did it, you’d probably get faster." --the tiniest sprinter
Cat 2 Track, Cat 3 Road.
"If you’re new enough [to racing] that you would ask such question, then i would hazard a guess that if you just made up a workout that sounded hard to do, and did it, you’d probably get faster." --the tiniest sprinter
#16
Sounds like you are all set.
The TK3 is a decent bike (if you don’t mind the toe overlap). Alternatively you could rent and look around for a good used bike for the price of the TK3 (although some people do like new bikes). The Kilo has to be manhandled a bit on the track, I think you will like the TK3 a lot better. The nice thing about not renting is that you can really get your bike dialed in for yourself and don’t have to re-adjust everything every time you ride.
The TK3 is a decent bike (if you don’t mind the toe overlap). Alternatively you could rent and look around for a good used bike for the price of the TK3 (although some people do like new bikes). The Kilo has to be manhandled a bit on the track, I think you will like the TK3 a lot better. The nice thing about not renting is that you can really get your bike dialed in for yourself and don’t have to re-adjust everything every time you ride.
#17
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: Basra al Basrah Iraq
Bikes: Dawes SST Al (2011) Trek 1000 (2003?)
Sounds like you are all set.
The TK3 is a decent bike (if you don’t mind the toe overlap). Alternatively you could rent and look around for a good used bike for the price of the TK3 (although some people do like new bikes). The Kilo has to be manhandled a bit on the track, I think you will like the TK3 a lot better. The nice thing about not renting is that you can really get your bike dialed in for yourself and don’t have to re-adjust everything every time you ride.
The TK3 is a decent bike (if you don’t mind the toe overlap). Alternatively you could rent and look around for a good used bike for the price of the TK3 (although some people do like new bikes). The Kilo has to be manhandled a bit on the track, I think you will like the TK3 a lot better. The nice thing about not renting is that you can really get your bike dialed in for yourself and don’t have to re-adjust everything every time you ride.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
sinikl
Singlespeed & Fixed Gear
30
03-15-13 12:24 AM
Hornstull
Singlespeed & Fixed Gear
0
08-27-12 11:46 AM
McStuff
Track Cycling: Velodrome Racing and Training Area
4
07-17-10 02:13 PM






