I’ve never worn a balaclava, but I might try one out as it does sound like a nice solution in deep winter. Kinda curious.

I know very little about these balaclavas. There sure seem to be a lot of types, brands I notice ...

I was wondering how you ended up with the ‘right’ balaclava, how your search went.
How or why did you start wearing one? Do you have different items for different situations, weather types? What are your experiences? ... What to look out for? Materials? Any disappointments you may want to share? And do they work comfortably wearing regular glasses? Maybe you went back to wearing separate pieces? ...

Bye the bye, a nice tip perhaps for in between seasons (autumn):
Wear a tube as a neck gaiter first, then grab the scarf by the back and pull it over the back of your head to cover your ears & neck; the tube ending halfway your skull (or slightly back). Loosen up things a little for comfort (chin). And, if you want, you can easily pull up/down the scarf to cover your chin / mouth / nose. (Maybe you even want to fold things for extra warmth or more stretch towards your skin.)
Next: To protect your front head, you could add a lightweight headband. Or ... pull something like a Castelli summer skullcap over your head! One of the extra advantages is that it will keep the tube more in place, securing your ear protection.

Most balaclavas made from stretchy material and are "one size fits all "...I get my balaclavas at a industrial clothing supply store... Black colour, made from lightweight fleece, they are very warm, dry fast, comfortable to wear... They have a lot of stretch in them, so you can pull it your mouth or leave your mouth uncovered., and they are long enough to cover the neck/throat area.

My favorite one is a thin merino wool balaclava, which also covers my head and can be worn with or without covering the face/mouth/nose. For my purposes, it's worked better than the fleece or rib knit poly blends.

In warmer winter, I wear it over ear warmers with a normal helmet (I have ear issues in the cold). For colder weather, I wear it alone with a snowboard helmet. For extreme cold (like 0F and below), I have a homemade thick wool face cover that goes over the top.

My balaclava doesn't really cover the neck, other than the very top, but my winter outer layers do that.

Balaclava's work very well when they're open faced and the temp isn't low enough to need your nose and mouth covered.
Problem is that as soon as you cover your nose and mouth, the air you're breathing in and out goes by your nose and glasses and fogs up your glasses.

I haven't found a perfect solution for that other than wearing contacts. I got a balaclava that has a straight piece that you can put over your nose but leaves your mouth open and it works ok but not great, it's kind of a pain and isn't trustworthy when the temp drops to the point where you want no exposed skin.

I've seen ones that look hilarious that have a separate channel for air from your nose and mouth to go in and out through, but by that point I realized I'd rather just take my car when it's so cold I would need one biking wasn't much fun at those temps anyways.

I believe to have read somewhere that some people add a headband around their nose for this purpose (and maybe minimize breathing through the mouth). But I haven’t tested this myself yet.

Yeah, the one I had that worked relatively well, the piece was like a headband that went over your nose/mouth.
Problem is, that covers a narrow range of maybe 5-15f. Once you get to 5-10f you get into the range where any exposed skin is vulnerable to frostbite. Keep in mind you're riding into the wind of course. So having something that might leave some skin exposed is...iffy.

I don't recall the exact temps any more, just because like I said I realized it wasn't a lot of fun riding below 15f so I stopped doing it. Others who ride in those temps regularly for transporation might have better experience than I do.

I wear a balaclava, but I make sure that it can be pulled under my chin, and under my beard. My beard doesn't get on with being covered up.

Actually, I believe the idea was to wear a headband or so underneath the balaclava (or Buff whatever).

started wearing one for bike commuting because my face was too cold on brutal days. I eventually settled on one that covered the bridge of my nose but I had to cut a larger opening for my mouth. I wear safety glasses when it is very cold. this is fine except when I stop. the moisture from my eye sockets will fog them. so when I stop & there is no airflow, I have to take them off





when it is not brutal out I have another I like with most of the face open but still covers everything else.





when it is just "cold" I use use a variety of other head warming options, often changing them at 1/2 way points on joy rides, such as a thin beanie, or knit hat w/o brim or a simple thin hooded sweatshirt. funny how useful a thin sweathsirt can be. you can layer under it & you can flip the hood down periodically for cooling, or back up for chills

Although it doesn't get that cold in Middle Tennessee, I have (2) balaclavas that I use since I get cold easily. The first is a very lightweight but breathable one that I wear when it's in the 50's. When it's 40 or below, I have a thicker fleece (REI) balaclava that covers the majority of my face. These do the job for me although the thicker fleece version means I have to adjust my helmet in order for it to fit without being too snug. Hope that helps.

I meant that the one I used had a similar design to that so I imagine it would work similarly. I don't remember the exact numbers but it was something like this:

25f+: Headband and helmet was enough
15-25f: Open face balaclava worked well
5f-15f: Nose covering piece plus balaclava worked well
5f and below: It leaves to much exposed skin and I felt it was to risky because of the low temp and frostbite.

If you regularly bike in a range you feel it would be enough for I'd say your plan is a good one. It's also cheap and easy to do with little risk or extra gear.

I'm winter biking in Minnesota, so the temps I ran into may be a bit different than the ones you run into...

I'm a freak ... any balaclava that covers my mouth and I'm too hot... even when the temps are sub-zero (F).

The pic below was the 2018 Fat Tire Loppet in Minneapolis on the same day as the coldest Super Bowl ever (those wimpy football players, they played inside). Temps were between -5 and 0F and I rode the race (22 miles) and rode the 11 miles home after the race. I focus on wool: 45NRTH Toaster Fork, Smartwool skull cap, wool buff. If I'm struggling to keep my face warm enough, I can pull up the buff ... typically do this if I have to stop for a few minutes or riding into a wind.


Photo credit TMB Images

My advice is to get one with a form fitting neck.

One with a baggy neck will bunch up under the jacket collar and be uncomfortable.


-Tim-

you want goggles that are double paned. I bought a cheap pair of smith snowboarding goggles (and helmet) that I use when it gets stupid cold outside. the smith goggles don't fog up.

I have a couple different ones I wear on my commutes. Down to 0 degrees F I wear a thinner one from carhartt. Below zero I switch to a rag wool one. To help with heat retention I use a cheap shower cap and punch a hole in the top to fit over the mounting bracket for my helmet light.

Thanks for the tips.
I’ve noticed some do and some don’t protect your forehead as well. It’s similar with skull caps. So, something to pay attention to.

Love how I see some D-I-Y here, because cycling doesn’t have to be all that expensive.

One of my D-I-Y tips is, when your frontwheel fork is too thick or has a somewhat difficult shape. You can use plastic straps to add a piece of an electricity tube or simular to the fork. That way it may be easier to attach lights or mirrors etc.

Saw a Houston Ball player in Boston wearing a balaclava under their batting helmet in last nights game ..

I love the balaclava for it's versatility. You can regulate your heat retention by partially removing it.

Mine is medium thickness made from technical fibers. It works well down to about -5*C. Below that I will need second layer on my head, as well as something to cover up my exposed facial area. Also, at 5*C or colder I'll go with bigger goggles as opposed to visors or glasses. The extra protection for the eyes and surrounding area is important when you generate your own windchill.

My face was cold and a scarf was too bulky and sweaty. I read about blaclavas here on bikeforums years ago. Not knowing anything I bought a thin nylon one. It worked well and still works well for me down to my limit of 10F. It seems for me blocking the wind is more important than insulation. Below 10F I'm sure insulation is more important.

As far as glasses fogging up, that was always a problem until I began cleaning my glasses with hand soap and warm water, then blow drying them with by mouth through an empty pen tube, or pursed lips. It works in the dry altitude of Colorado. What I discovered is a thin, invisible soap film is left on the lenses which helps prevent fogging. This is how anti-fogging agents like rain-X work.

Being thin and stretchy the balaclava can be worn as a cap only, a cap and chin cover (tucked under my bottom lip), over my mouth, or over my mouth and nose. Over my nose will lead to fogging sometimes which can be somewhat avoided by breathing though my mouth and affecting and overbite to direct the breath down and away.

Also, being bald, I wear it inside out so the seam doesn't leave an indentation on my bare scalp, which makes it look like I had my head split in two.

Anyways...that's what works for me.

Going to address a couple things in your post, Bobby.

An alternative to a balaclava that I greatly prefer is a merino beanie and neck tube. You can pull the neck tube up the back of your head and across your face so that it covers either just the chin or all the way up to your nose, or you can pull it down on warmer days to just cover your neck. Or on really warm days, just wear the beanie. Much more adjustable than a balaclava, especially the loose-fitting ones that tend to be sold.