Do they exist? I bought a pair of Pearl Izumi WxB covers last season and - granted - they bore daily use all last winter, but I went to put them on a few weeks ago and lo! they're falling apart. Toe strap's frayed to oblivion, the bead along the bottom of the cover has separated from the neoprene on the other one. I put them through hell, because I don't have dedicated winter mtb boots (or boots for that matter), but I was wondering if anyone had had good luck with covers that could stand up to a true day-in/out beating. Also, anyone tried to repair their covers? Thanks!

I've been looking for a replacement pair for my neoprene booties that are starting to show their age. I think I have settled on these. These look to be the most durable ones out there. If I end up picking them up, I'll be sure to post a review.

Please use a link that works.

I recently purchased a pair of Endura overshoes because they seemed to be sturdier than the Pearl Izumi ones in the store. Thus far, I am very very happy with them.

You'll have to let me know how they work out. These are falling apart.

The link should have been to a pair of BBB ArcticDuty covers.

https://www.wiggle.com/bbb-arcticduty-shoe-cover/

This past Monday (12/30/13) I did my 14 mile commute at about 15°F and tried a new set of foot coverings that IMO that kept my feet significantly warmer than usual. In the past I had bought a pair of neon green shoe covers made by Gore-Tex, for wet riding. During the winter, I use platform pedals with toeclips, and my usual footwear is thin and thick socks, running shoes and Totes rubber overshoes. I use plastic bags over my running shoes to put on the Totes more easily (see the sequence below).

So with the additional Gore-Tex shoe coverings at 15ºF, I did not perceive cold until about mile 10, and I did not feel cold in the sense of permeating the soft tissues of my foot until about mile 12, but it was tolerable. At about mile 12 I have a downhill run of several hundred yards that irreversibly drains the heat from my extremities. The next day at 21ºF, I rode without the Goretex, and started feeling cold at about mile 9 and finished significantly colder at my mile 14 destination than the day before.

I use a pair of Touring Shoe Covers I ordered a few months back. With these on, even a pair of pretty ordinary boots will keep my feet warm and dry, and so far they've stood up to daily use.

I haven't owned them long enough to say if they'll last over the long haul, but so far they are in good shape.

I got a pair of PI Reinforced Super rugged Wetsuit material ones , they beefed up toe and the sole portion
between hole for the Cleat and the heel of your MTB shoes .. hung them on a peg at the LBS , so let me know , PM

maybe the shop camera can do a snap, then..

These look warm and durable and have several positive reviews. I went ahead and ordered a pair. I'll review these later this month. I ride in winter and would like to find a large cover.

Below is what I used last winter. If I can use both an inner and outer cover along with wool socks and a fleece footbed, I should be good down to 20F.

Well its official. The shoe covers I bought in late November are falling apart. The soles are tearing up from wear against my pedals, and the zippers on the back are going. They still keep my feet warm and waterproof, but I expected them to last longer than just a couple months. Those arcticduty covers posted above look really promising, so I'm going to take a chance and order them.

Barrett - How'd the BBB shoe covers work out?

Good, these are the warmest and most weather resistant covers I've used. They are also large enough to fit a thinner cover under this cover and over my cycling boot. They are heavy looking and not the easiest to remove.

Thanks for the info. What size did you get an what shoes/size are you wearing these with?

Main thing is to try not to walk in shoe covers. They're not made for it. If you want to be able to walk, buy winter MTB boots, Lakes or Northwave, something like that.

My LG neoprene covers held up well all last fall (cold and wet through Oct/Nov) and this winter. No significant damage and limited wear not affecting performance. +1 on Carbonfiberboy's comment about not walking around in them, especially on gravel. I think some people buy them too small and then overstretch them. If they are hard to put on, get the next bigger size.

I should note that during the very coldest weather, I switch to insulated, waterproof/windproof hiking boots and don't clip in, so my covers might not get some of the mid-winter beating others may.

the fleeced Neoprene ones I mentioned above would be fine, they actually cut out the heel and sole
around the cleat mount have a Toe and across the arch of sturdy rubber like a shoe sole.

I bought actual winter shoes. Good investment. I can still add booties for really cold days.

I used Bontrager's waterproof RXL softshell shoe covers all winter long for daily commuting, and the only issue I ever had was that a few of the little reflective bits on the backs of them fell off in the wash. The covers themselves have held up terrifically, with no holes, tears, or anything like that. They're really warm, too!