I own a Brooks and love it. However, it does require more care (and money) than the non leather ones. Since you are not into that, don't let others convince you and go with your gut. Check out Allay Saddles (owned by Topeak). I don't have personal experience with their products but heard good things about them. The "saddle finder" on their site seems quite helpful.

http://www.allaysaddles.com/?lkz=en