Well, I've done some re-prioritizing. The other thread was more about disc specific models. While I feel that, yes, discs would be nice, I don't currently have 'em and manage to stop just fine in the rain.

I'm a Clyde at 228#'s, tend to ride the MUP, and do the bus/bike thing. Currently having to place/remove my bike from the rack at the front of bus 3x a work day. I want something a bit more efficient than what I'm currently riding- 2006 Kona Smoke. That being said, here's my list of hopefuls:

-Kona Dew. This one just might be the best climber in the bunch. Don't really have to contend with that much elevation change, but someday I know I am. The fact it's also one of the least expensive of these models doesn't hurt, neither.

-Felt Verza City 3. Not exactly sure why I put this one in, other than my LBS carries Felt. But maybe this one has the better specs?

-KHS Urban Xpress. This one is steel, which I prefer. I think that this one is geared a bit higher than the others.

-Giant Escape City. This one is the only bike of the group that is currently on the floor (in my size) at two different shops. The one closest to work has this exact trim level, while one closer to home has a more base model.

-Trek Allant. Seen it one the floor last week, even sat on it. Didn't care for the handlebars, so those could probably be switched out at purchase. I like the rack on this one better than the Giant, but the Giant has fenders that cover more...

When looking at those, keep in mind that I'm more concerned about the frame and wheel sets; I need something that can handle the abuse.

Edit: I deleted the Metro 9 and the Coda because they are true "special orders". These other models the shop wouldn't mind keeping in inventory if I am not satisfied. All of these are available from the same LBS. Also added a Trek from a different shop.