Honest question : did you even try riding the saddle? How many miles?

I don't understand how you can offer a review and expect to have it taken seriously when it makes absolutely no mention of how the saddle rides, is it comfortable, is it durable etc etc. I get that you're trying to tell us it isnt a tensioned saddle and by simply looking at it you feel it wasnt worth the money, but is the point of a saddle supposed to be to provide a platform from with you sit on to ride your bike?

So, maybe you just forgot to mention how it rides, how long it took to break in, how it feels after 20 40 or 60 miles on it. How it holds up in different conditions, how durable it is based on using it, and so on. I get that you're not comfortable with how it was built by looking at it, but so what? It's a freakin bike seat. How do you think it functions as a bike seat???
IMO if you added that I'd be able to take your reviews much more seriously. Without that this just seems utterly ridiculous.