Originally Posted by
Grasschopper
I have a nice steel bike and I know it will last forever and I don't have to worry about it cracking, exploding or any of that other crap people say carbon bikes do...
...I know this because I ride it once or twice a year, otherwise it hangs on the wall in my home. It hangs there because my carbon bike is lighter (a lot), stiffer yet quiets bumps and vibrations better. I have both and choose the carbon bike 99.9% of the time...the steel bike goes out to show it off.
There's your answer. If it's going to hang on the wall, steel. If you intend to ride it, carbon.