Depends on what your "winter" consists of. I tried them (not the exact ones, but the Cabelas ones), but ended up with these after one winter:

https://www.revelatedesigns.com/inde...5&ProductID=14

I can wear thin merino wool gloves under them and be fine down to 20-30 below zero here in Minnesota. The ATV style are good for wind protection, but lack insulation, so you need heavier gloves/mittens under them if you are riding really cold temps.